Villain Reformation: Should the Dazzlings have a chance to redeem themselves?

[Sugar Pea 2,682]

I think two villain reformations is enough., in my opinion. xD

 

I mean, I absolutely loved the Dazzlings in Rainbow Rocks and all, but they were some pretty bad girls. (On account of their history and present day agenda).

 

Do you think Hasbro would be beating a dead horse if the Sonata, Aria and Adagio were to be reformed in the future, seeing as they were left empty handed?

Edited February 11, 2015 by teacup-bunnies23

[VitalSpark 1,830]

I hope they keep them as characters. If you have a villainous character, there are two obvious ways for them to stick around and stay relevant after their initial defeat:

• reform them; or
• have them come up with a new plan.

I think it would be a little dull if they went down the reform path yet again. They've already done it with Luna and Sunny, and that's great, but they don't need to keep doing the same old thing. Them coming up with a new plan for taking over the world doesn't seem likely in Equestria Girls 3, which looks like it will feature some brand new antagonists.

 

But although those are the two obvious ways to keep the characters relevant, there are other routes they could take. A new and far worse villain could appear that forces old enemies to work together. Perhaps the Dazzlings and the Humane 7 will need to temporarily put aside their differences to defeat someone far more evil? At the end, while the two groups might not be friends with each other, they might start to develop a mutual respect. Something more nuanced than full reformation.

Edited February 11, 2015 by VitalTwilightSparkle

[Metallic Strings 185]

Personally, I don't like it that almost all the villains in mlp reformed. I want to see other plans that they have to stop the ponies. The only one who hasn't reformed was tirek.

[VitalSpark 1,830]

The only one who hasn't reformed was tirek.

 

Not so. Sombra and Chrysalis haven't been reformed. Sombra was possibly killed.

 

And although they're more antagonists than villains, Gilda, Diamond Tiara, Silver Spoon, and the Flim Flam brothers have not yet been reformed.

Edited February 11, 2015 by VitalTwilightSparkle

[Metallic Strings 185]

Not so. Sombra and Chrysalis haven't been reformed. Sombra was possibly killed.

 

And although they're more antagonists than villains, Gilda, Diamond Tiara, Silver Spoon, and the Flim Flam brothers have not yet been reformed.

I hope discord doesn't actually reform like shown in the season 4 finale.

[VitalSpark 1,830]

Um, somebody hasn't watched the episodes. He's *been* reformed since like middle of what, season 3? It was a whole episode. Somewhere around there.

 

I assume @ was referring to Discord's temporary return to the dark side, that happens at the end of Season 4, showing that his reform is perhaps still fragile.

 

Personally I think he's likely to remain good now, with the season 4 finale being a blip on his path to reformation. Being reformed doesn't mean he'll stop causing problems though, as we've seen in Princess Twilight and Three's a Crowd. We might see him doing things that perhaps seem bad, but turn out to have prevented something worse from happening, or end up teaching the Mane 6 an important lesson.

Edited February 11, 2015 by VitalTwilightSparkle

[VitalSpark 1,830]

He did say he only joined Tirek so Twilight would get her key.

 

No, he didn't. He had genuinely switched sides. He states his reason for joining Tirek in part 2 of the episode:

 

Tirek tricked me into believing that he could offer me something more valuable than friendship. But there is nothing worth more. I see that now.

 

Of course, it turned out that in the end this helped Twilight get her key, but that was an unintentional consequence. I think if that had been his plan all along, he would have mentioned it at some point.

Edited February 11, 2015 by VitalTwilightSparkle

[Fractured_Spectrum 201]

I would like to see the Dazzlings reformed. Sonata is considered too cute and ditzy to even be evil so... Ya. That's my weak argument. XD

[Ashen Pathfinder 16,161]

@

 

As this topic is covering characters that have only appeared in the Equestria Girls films, it has been moved to the Equestria Girls forum. Keep in mind that Sugarcube Corner is for topics covering the fandom, and anything related to EqG goes in that specific forum.

 

Thanks.

[Jangocoolguy 433]

Eh, no thanks. It would feel redundant after Sunset's redemption. Plus, we've had enough bad guys reformed in this franchise as it is.

 

Though I can see them taking a middle ground with Sonata being good (she was lousy at being bad to begin with) while the other 2 stay bad. Heck, they could even further split it with Adagio being evil and Aria being a mere jerk.

[Silver Letter 1,832]

I don't think we'll see them again at all but if we did then they are not likely to present much of a threat without any powers. Redeeming them may just be a boring story.

[Metallic Strings 185]

Sorry about the whole discord confusion, I did see all the episodes, but haven't watched the show recently.

[applejock 358]

Considering the geniune nature of this show (films), yes they should!

 

And frankly i would be shocked to NOT see them as part of the 3rd film.

[KatonRyu 1,033]

They've lost the source of their powers but they're still ancient beings. It's quite conceivable that they would be reformed to provide exposition if it ever becomes necessary. I hope they don't, though.

 

Don't get me wrong, I liked the Dazzlings as antagonists, but not every bad guy just needs friendship to become a better person. They did that well with Sombra by essentially killing him, and Chrysalis wasn't reformed either. So, all in all, I ope the Dazzlings stay gone because not every villain needs to be redeemed.

[CarrieShadow 7]

I enjoyed the Dazzlings as antagonists too, don't get me wrong. However, if the writers come up with a good way to reform them, as they did with Sunset Shimmer, why not take the opportunity?

[cmarston1 5,959]

I don't really think they should.  Ignoring the fact that we already have had Sunset Shimmer and Discord reform from being evil (and Luna too i guess but Nightmare Moon wasn't really much of a character) the films already have a good amount of major characters in them.  With human Twilight, Sunset Shimmer, the high 5, and at least one new main antagonist possibly 3 there would be too many main characters for the Dazzlings to fit into the EQG 3.  And that is not counting pony world Twilight and Spike who likely will appear again, and possibly Flash Sentry but who knows.

I'd rather see new villains then rehashing old ones.

[Singe 2,111]

No. I always found reforming to be nothing more than rebuking individuality and force change to cater to others. You were born to be bad and its your nature, but you must reform to good in the best interest of Equestrian society. The series just doesn't offer a middle ground.

Edited February 14, 2015 by Singe

[MysticShine 529]

Not all villains need to be reformed. That in itself is teaching a bad lesson. It's basically saying "All people have good inside them". Some people just don't. There are evil people in the world.

[Nnoitra 9]

No,Keep them evil, They are hotter that way

[NavelColt 22,881]

The Dazzlings were born as Sirens to our knowledge, unless whatever species they are isn't unique to them, and they're simply three examples of their species who got magic amulets that lets them enchant through singing. I personally prefer the first theory. More to work with in headcanon.

 

So going by that logic, no, they shouldn't be reformed because they were 'born what they are', so to speak.

If they were to be brought back in the future EQG series or third movie, I'd hope to see them plotting to re-attain their powers.

[MitBoy 2]

Yes, please. I think, after the thing that they did to Dazzlings, they kinda should reform them. Also I think "too much redemption" is probably the worst excuse for not doing this.

Because they was slighty better as villiains then Sunset is also  pretty bad reason (in my opinion).

I'm not saying they should give us, like, one hour story, just to show they are happy now.

Edited February 20, 2015 by MitBoy

[_GLaDOS_ 102]

I don't think the can even reform! They have to fed off of hate only to survive, plus their awesome villains. I really hope they get more character development in the future.

[Woodie Pecker 46]

I think the school should accept them. Sonata building a bridge to the others through Pinkie Pie. Aria coming towards Rainbow Dash as a competitor and Adagio should try to be nice but has a hard time doing that, because she's a rude control freak.

[Ashen Pathfinder 16,161]

I'll be honest; I want the Dazzlings to stay as villains. While Shimmer didn't do it for me as a villain AND works much better as a protagonist, the Dazzling are just FUN villains to watch. They're bad, and the LOVE it! Add in their facial expressions and they're just a treat to watch.

 

So no, I want them as vilains still.

[Woodie Pecker 46]

I don't think the can even reform! They have to fed off of hate only to survive, plus their awesome villains. I really hope they get more character development in the future.

Yes, they are the best MLP villains. BUT they're not like the changelings, which really need to feed of of love. They need the hate to gain power, not for survival. It's only there to power that which is already powerful. Which they can't do anymore because their crystals shattered.