Personally, I didn't extremely love Pinkie Pride. Yeah, it's an awesome episode with great music, story, and WEIRD AL, but it didn't capture me too well. I REALLY liked Twilight's Kingdom though.
TO be honest, I never liked anthro stuff, at all. I like my ponies as cute adorable little ponies. Also, I'm a sucker for heartwarming stuff and fluff. If it's adorable, I'll read/view it.
You win the internet. Anyway, I think Tirek in MLP G1 was defeated lamely. The reason I say that G4 Tirek wasn't was because his battle with Twilight. THAT WAS AWESOME!
I like almost all of the Brony Reviewers, but Chad Rocco AKA CR takes the cake. He accentuates the negativity on a level that challenges the Nostalgia Critic and the Angry Video Game Nerd (I like those guys though) AND hated "A Canterlot Wedding" and Season 3 so much that he left the fandom and hates the show for that. Even Digibrony doesn't go that negative!