Jump to content
Banner by ~ Kyoshi Frost Wolf

Nyactis Mewcis Catlum

User
  • Posts

    242
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Nyactis Mewcis Catlum

  1. It's all right. There are things to like about it, a lot of things to dislike about it. I usually try to play the devil's advocate and say the opposing view just to get people thinking, but I'm honestly going to have to go with the crowd on this one: Mud Briar is not only very much Sheldon Cooper, but he's reminded me of why Sheldon is a horrible character. It's not the fact that he's socially awkward or stunted. I have no problem with Maud (even in this episode, even if I do think it was really a dick move for her to basically ditch Pinkie Pie when they had morning plans) and she's got something similar. But there's something you can read from Maud that you can't read from Mud (or at least, I was unable to read until that final act). To put it simply, when Pinkie was describing Maud as caring and warm, she was right. Maud may not be emotive, but from the way she speaks to Pinkie, even in this episode, you can tell that she really does care about her sister. She puts investment in conversations that you can tell take energy from her, she does willfully attempt to make a bridge to others, and she lets others speak. I think it's in that stupid "technically" quirk. Someone else put down Pinkie Pie for getting upset at that, but... You can kinda get why. The way he says it is super condescending. I know the last act tries to spin it as if it's not, but I'm sorry, you don't use that wording unless you think you're smarter than the person you're talking to. Not to mention his comments are the "peanut gallery" type; literally made just for the sake of correcting someone or inserting your own input when it's clearly not wanted. His character is redeemed a little by the end. I noticed the "See you later" thing, and it was one thing I actually really liked about the episode. Pinkie's sisters were also amazing and I'm really glad to have seen them again. And Pinkie's little, uh...breakdown...was kind of entertaining, even if it caught me completely off guard. I'm kind of glad I didn't look at this thread when it happened so I was completely blindsided by the floating Mane 5 heads saying the opposite of their biggest character quirks. (I kinda like the style those heads are drawn in, actually. Huh.) It's an...okay lesson. I know people are saying that it's "mature", but (and here Scootaloved goes, into personal shit again when we're talking about cartoon ponies...) I've had an experience where I learned about someone's significant other, and there was something really off about the relationship, and I was told not to question it because clearly my friend was being made "happy" in that situation. Turned out, that relationship was abusive as all get-out. I'm not saying that that should be your immediate thought whenever someone's significant other rubs you the wrong way, but it's something to note that your gut reaction about a person is not always wrong and you shouldn't just fully dismiss it. I think it's something you should legitimately weigh. The resolution was a bit too quick to go into that particular nuance, but... To be honest if they trimmed the fat on the jokes they probably could've at least brushed upon that particular issue. Last, this is the first episode to implement that new intro. The rhythm junkie in me hates it. The continuity junkie in me loves it. I can't decide how to feel. Oh, and this cute little tidbit: "So you're saying I should crack open Mud Briar like a rock..." I'm already waiting for the grimdark fanfictions.
  2. Mmmmmmmmm

    It was okay, I guess. The episode feels like the resolution was really rushed.

    shrug emoji

    1. Shrug

      Shrug

      The resolution was my least favorite part of the episode. We definitely get a good moral out of this but I don’t like how all of a sudden the episode makes Mud and Pinkie friends. Like. I understand that Pinkie has a new appreciation for him due to how happy he makes her sister but what about the rest of the episode where Pinkie hates everything about him? It feels so forced to me that the episode seems to imply that they are actual friends now. @Scootaloved

  3. "So you're saying I should crack open Mud Briar like a rock..."

    NO, THE CUPCAKES HYPE WAS JUST DYING DOWN, WHAT HAVE YOU DONE

  4. Starlight's great in this episode so far, though.

    1. CypherHoof

      CypherHoof

      GlimGlam is great of course, and she is growing into her Councillor role well - but i don't think she added a lot to this episode (and you would think, given she and Maud are supposed to be close, she would have known about Mud already)

  5. To be honest, Pinkie Pie is kind of right when she says that Maud and Mud don't have as much in common.

    On the surface they certainly look similar, but Mud has an arrogant air to him that Maud does not have. Think it's that "technically" quirk of his. While Maud is certainly awkward, she's more awkward in the lack of emotive perspective; Mud is awkward in the "socially awkward nerd who thinks he knows everything about the world" perspective.

    Maud is not like Sheldon of the Big Bang Theory. This guy is. And Sheldon's kinda an insufferable d-bag.

    1. Nyactis Mewcis Catlum

      Nyactis Mewcis Catlum

      Yikes, yeah.

      "Stop acting like you know my sister better than me!"
      "Technically, I never said that."

      She never accused you of saying anything, bozo, and that's exactly what you're acting like.

  6. Watching Maud Couple now!

    Already sort of realizing a problem: Maud's humor worked well in other episodes because she was unexpected, but it's kind of lost its effect. Her character is consistent, though, so this isn't really a major gripe.

    1. Nyactis Mewcis Catlum

      Nyactis Mewcis Catlum

      This guy is fucking Sheldon from the Big Bang Theory.

    2. Shrug

      Shrug

      At the very least I’ll say that Maud isn’t in this episode that much. Even when she is, it’s not like she is used as just a joke character. We see how she interacts with Pinkie and Mud and that is really the focus of her role here. 

      However. In episodes like Gift of the Maud Pie, I would definitely call what you just said a flaw. 

  7. Five facts about Scootaloo:

    1 - She's a chicken.

    2 - SCOOT-SCOOTALOOOOOOOOO

    3 - If you dislike her what is wrong with you

    4 - bwoooop 

    5 - her design is fun as heck to draw

    1. Shrug

      Shrug

      I’m just gonna take a wild guess and say you like Scootaloo. :P 

    2. Nyactis Mewcis Catlum

      Nyactis Mewcis Catlum

      Maybe just a little bit.

  8. I know it probably sounds dumb. It's not like I hated the scooter 'cause it looked bad or anything... Anyway, I gave it a shot eventually and found I really liked it, and so I've had it ever since.
  9. You remember that? Dunno, it's clear when I look back on it that singing isn't my special talent... But hey, if we had Sweetie Belle singing it, it might be worth it to make another song!
  10. Dear Princess Celestia, Hey, so you might not know me, but your sister helped me out one time... Tell her that I said thanks for that, by the way! I'm glad she came to me in my dreams! Anyway, I was wondering if you had any powers like Princess Luna does? If you're able to walk dreams or something else? And I'm also wondering...if it took you time to get those powers? I don't know how it works with alicorns, and I don't really want to ask Princess Twilight because she might bring it up during our Twilight Time. Are there late bloomers among alicorns? Are there alicorns that were never able to get their powers? Scootaloo
  11. I...know that? Celestia makes a comment about being in StarSwirl's class. That's what I was referring to.
  12. It's kinda cool seeing other people use my ask format. Twilight is running her own school - I'm wondering what your experience is with the classroom setting? Aside from obviously being in StarSwirl the Bearded's classroom and foreseeing over classes, of course. Have you ever run a classroom yourself?
  13. What will this exactly entail? Will it block people who are loading lots of pages? I tend to reload pages a lot while I'm waiting for replies in threads, and of course i check notifications the instant I notice them. I'm assuming it won't block what could be considered normal user activity?
  14. While Twilight focuses on platonic love (friendship), Cadance focuses on romantic love. A better question is what Flurry Heart will be the princess of.
  15. Oh, there's nothin' like it! The exhilaration, the wind blowing through your mane - Nothin' compares to the feeling of soaring through the air...
  16. Some answers transported from another forum (note, when I write in text like this, it's me speaking, not Scootaloo): Favorite of Rainbow Dash's friends, huh? Y'know, all of 'em are nice ponies! I get to be around Applejack and Rarity the most - 'cause, y'know, they're Sweetie Belle's and Apple Bloom's sisters - but I can't say I like 'em more than the others. Pinkie Pie's got a lotta energy, so she kinda gets tiring after a while... But Fluttershy's super kind. Guess that makes sense, 'cause that's her element... Maybe Princess Twilight Sparkle? I learned a lot from her, and she's really smart, too! Twilight Time's great, and next to spending time with Rainbow Dash and my friends, it's probably my favorite thing to do! I've always been a big fan of chocolate!
  17. I don't mind nicknames! As for Applebloom and Sweetie Belle, dunno, you'd have to ask them. I don't think they'd mind either, though. ... Whaaa? There's no way any of them would go evil! Why would you ask somethin' like that!? ... I use a hot air balloon, of course.
  18. What do I wanna work? D'ya mean where do I wanna work, or what do I wanna do? ... I'll answer both, just in case! Never really thought about it, in either case! I know if I got an actual job, I'd want it to be in Ponyville... Y'know, 'cause my friends and Rainbow Dash are here. Other than that, I've kinda learned being in a hurry to figure out what I wanna do for the rest of my life takes away from the fun of it! So I'll take it as it comes. Plus, I've got a lot goin' for me right now with the Cutie Mark Crusaders.
  19. I mean, it's pretty clear it's not our world's naming conventions - that's why I started the topic in the first place. I'm interested in how it works.
  20. You sure not a tree? Oh? Are you interested in being able to perform magic?
  21. Cute April Fool's joke, Discord. You got me.

    1. Show previous comments  2 more
    2. Shrug

      Shrug

      @Scootaloved Yeah. I know what you meant. I have a Discord account. :lol:

      But what was the April Fool’s Joke? Lol

    3. Nyactis Mewcis Catlum

      Nyactis Mewcis Catlum

      The new commands that they put in and the "randomly crashing" that Discord will do, lol.

    4. Shrug

      Shrug

      Oh okay. Thank you. I hadn’t noticed. :lol:

  22. To all, again: Are you content with being the type of pony you are (unicorn, earth pony, pegasus...in Twilight's case, alicorn)? If you could be anything else, what would you be? (Doesn't have to be a pony, either!)
×
×
  • Create New...