Jump to content
Banner by ~ Kyoshi Frost Wolf

Nyactis Mewcis Catlum

User
  • Posts

    242
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Nyactis Mewcis Catlum

  1. All good things must come to an end eventually. I definitely would prefer that the team devote their energy to making G5 as lovingly crafted as G4 was than to artificially extend G4's length for the sake of appeasing fans.
  2. The premiere essentially recaps all the important information you need to know in order to understand it, so no, the movie isn't required viewing. I'd still watch it anyway just to get the details on exactly what they're talking about, but their summaries of events just about cover it.
  3. I'm honestly surprised I didn't reply to this before. I voted no on allowing her to fly. I think the issue should be left where it was in Flight to the Finish, where it's left ambiguous. In this way, both camps can be happy. The problem with validating her flying is that, to me, it takes away from the intrigue of her having a disability. I understand this is an optimistic show and I'm ordinarily all for that, but, like...disabilities don't go away in real life. And it's really nice to have a character who has a disability who is treated fairly, loved equally, and allowed to flourish in other ways, as opposed to brute forcing her way past it - because you can't actually do that in reality. And what I appreciate about this show is making these subtle analogues, but the analogue would be entirely destroyed if it was confirmed that she could fly. I wouldn't jump ship off the show if they permitted it, I'm sure you could make a great message out of that, and I'm cool with it in fanfiction, too, just... I don't know, the message is less impactful and it shuts those with disabilities out if they explicitly say she doesn't have one. Given the poll's results, a lot of people want her to fly, so if they confirm she has a disability, my concern there is that they'll either 1) phone it in or 2) displease a lot of fans and spark debate, both of which I would prefer to avoid. Hence, the ambiguity that it currently has I think is the place that it should stay at. I've had deep feelings for this for years now. Scootaloo's disability, or rather my ability to interpret she has one, has been something pretty significant to me during the show's run time, ever since the conversation first came up and the show lightly brushed upon it. It's a personal struggle that I can relate to, and I'm sure I'm not the only one. It's the same kind of thing I liked in Hurricane Fluttershy, where Fluttershy was still flying underneath the level of the lot of pegasi even by the end, but her effort still mattered in the end and her presence was still significant to contributing to the solution. That the effort to better yourself is still a worthwhile endeavor, even if you may never reach the levels that other people are at, and that your life still has meaning even if you're stuck in a rut you may never get out of. For me, that's a far more significant message than "you can overcome literally every problem if you just try". It's more nuanced, more relatable, and something that doesn't sound blindly optimistic to the point of discouraging those who are in situations where their best won't overcome a problem, no matter how much they wish it to.
  4. People within the fandom are talented enough to make quality animations, of this I have no doubt - the fandom is in abundance with those. My concern would be if such a project would be written well. The problem is that a lot of the writers within the fandom don't take audience in mind (and when they do, it's only through the aforementioned pandering). This makes sense as most fan creations are just wish fulfillment, but if you're going to devote so much time and energy to a fan-film, it'd seem a waste to make it sub-par in the writing department. Double Rainboom exemplifies the fears that I have. A lot of it is just random memes and jokes that date it horribly, and it also warps the personalities of the characters it depicts for the sake of having its premise work. It's not the worst fan thing I've ever seen, but it's evident that the writing wasn't proofread that thoroughly, and it doesn't really represent the spirit of the show. There's a certain tone that the show goes for, and I'll be honest when I say I don't think a lot of fan works actually play upon that tone.
  5. Hi. I'm a woman. I have told you numerous times why you're having trouble, in multiple threads. I was being fair in those responses and tried to be at-level with you. You haven't responded any of those times. Since it doesn't seem to be getting across to you, I'm going to be very blunt in this response. Women want the alpha guys because they're the ones who treat them with genuine respect. They're the ones who are outright about their feelings toward these women. Women are averse to you because it's very, very clear you resent them, and every post you make oozes with this resentment. You don't believe a word you're saying when you wax sentiment about protecting women and wanting to respect them. You say that, but your actions don't back it up. You're going through the motions because, like most people, you crave social intimacy and you think that's the way you're going to earn it. When these actions aren't met supportively, your response to it is, "What the heck? Why don't these women like me? I'm doing exactly what they want! I'm doing what they say I should do! Ugh, women are so hard to understand..." But here's the thing: you shouldn't be doing things to be a good person just to get that attention. You should be doing good things because they're the right thing to do. You're not winning women over because, quite frankly, you're transparent. And women are generally self-respecting enough not to date someone who's going to resent them or prejudge them based on their gender. Are there women out there who go for people who treat them badly? Sure. Are there women who pass up opportunities that would benefit them to their detriment? I could say so. But it's not, like, a system, man. It's not like these women are systematically against you, trying to beat you to the ground. And even if they were: why do you want to impress them in the first place? Why do you want women who won't respect you? Surely you want a partner who's going to love you for who you are, and not for an act you put on simply to make them like you? Here's my word of advice: you NEED to let that resentment for women that you have go. And don't tell me you don't have it. Actions speak louder than words. Once you start seeing women as individuals rather than a collective playing to a system, you'll find you'll have much better luck with them. Also, be genuine, to yourself and to other people - don't say things that you don't believe in and don't agree with. People can see through it, and there is literally no one on this earth who likes a phony, so if you want to be liked, be honest. And really think about why people believe the things that you're saying instead of just parroting it. Why do people believe that? Do you think it's actually legitimate? If so, why? If not, why not? Give it some serious thought, not just one to two minutes. Research into claims you see on the internet. Think about why someone is an authority figure on a subject in the first place. This is your world view we're talking about here. And lastly, have some respect for your fellow man, too. Instead of seeing these alpha men as your opponents, really examine the men with successful relationships and figure out what they have in common. If you emulate that, or at least attempt to understand it, you may find yourself having more success than you currently are treating them as enemies. You don't even know the agonized noise I just made. Add that to my list.
  6. I've drank alcohol once in my life. It was gross.
  7. Stereotypes don't come from nowhere. A lot of stereotypes have a grain of truth to them - how much truth depends on the subject of the stereotype. That being said, no particular group of people should be judged by a stereotype. Every individual is different in some way; some people will exhibit stereotypical traits more than others. It's presumptuous to assume that a group will all act the same, even if that group shares some similarities. It's always safest to judge a person by their individual characteristics, devoid of what you may have heard before. This is true no matter the group, gender, race, etc. It's also why sweeping generalizations of a group are something I discourage, because there will always be exceptions no matter what stereotype you're banking on. I'm very individualistic in the way I treat people. I do my best to treat everyone free of any external biases. I let people's own actions speak for themselves, and make judgments off of that, rather than what I may have heard somewhere else. It is typical for the human mind to attempt to pick up patterns in people's behavior, and sometimes those patterns ring true, and I'll even point out these patterns from time to time, but I do my best not to let these patterns make me prejudge someone before I've come to know them.
  8. You know how the joke goes: it's interesting how "politics" sounds as if it's a combination of "poly", meaning many, and "ticks", meaning blood-sucking creatures. As of the S8 premiere, discussions about ponies have been curbing more toward the political side. I'm not overly surprised by this, as cartoon analytics often tie in the media they consume with the real world - as well they should, as cartoons and other media don't exist within a vacuum. The cautionary tale is not so much in the fact that real world events and politics are being related to the media we consume, but rather that the oversaturation of it is blinding us to what the episodes, and indeed the spirit of the show, are actually primarily about. This would not be the first time that this issue will come up, and it will certainly not be the last, either. I think the problem in this lies in the assumption that events within a cartoon or any other media are actually, 100%, 1-to-1 parallels of these events and they're intended to be. The problem is that making them like this would make the media not age well, as it will comment on events that may eventually blow over as time proceeds onward, which is why I think reducing it to that can be problematic in the sense that it misses the overall message being conveyed. I am, of course, the first person who will tell you that no interpretation is wrong when it comes to media, and it's why I didn't like Fame & Misfortune, because it attempted to spread the idea there's a wrong feeling to garner about it. Rather, I'm attempting to say that authorial intent is rarely these 1-to-1 parallels as no smart writer would do that; it would date the work unless it's outright about it being that particular parallel (such as older works that specifically talk about an issue). I also find another problem is that these comparisons are, well, to be frank, they're not well thought-out, and I think that's because people oversimplify why something is good or bad, rather than actually considering why they feel that way. In other words, they listen to the authority figures that have told them this over their life, but never stopped and considered why those authority figures said that to them. I'm not suggesting that such ideas should not be discussed, but I think some of the prevalence of these discussions can be attributed to not thinking enough into what makes a similarity, a similarity. Just because it reminds you of something, doesn't mean it's actually like that something in practice. And some of you who have thought already into what I'm saying know what I'm talking about, but for those who don't, the examples I provide you are: racism & imperialism, especially in the case of the latter. I don't think, and would never agree with, the idea that the S8 premiere was intended to parallel any particular real world situation. Certainly, it's inspired by real world events, but it's not specifically criticizing anything (except perhaps how the school functions, which arguably parodies real school boards, but even then it's not targeting any specific school board). I also don't think the Cutie Map has any particular implication toward this, either. And I think, given some of the arguments I've seen, people are bringing in their own personal issues with the world into the episode and suggesting that the episode is saying that much. A noteworthy example, though the individual will not be named, is something regarding "white unicorns", despite Chancellor Neighsay never displaying any bias toward a particular faction of pony, nor would any bias toward colors of all things make any sense within the My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic universe. And this is what I mean. As I said, there is no wrong way to interpret a work, but I do think there is a simplified way of viewing it and there's a nuanced way of viewing it, and many people seem to be taking the simplified way without considering nuance. And that is why it's getting so heated and controversial. They're looking at an episode and suggesting it's making a statement that it may not actually be making. You could say it's an unintended side effect of the episode, which I would certainly agree in the case of other episodes, but when examining the actual context, the authorial intent rings clear as day that a political jab is probably not what they were trying to make with the premiere. Even without that, the focus on this particular aspect of the episodes without even seeing the full season, without giving Chancellor Neighsay a chance to get the development he clearly is going to (given that he's coming back), and the discussion seems inundated with the same talking points. I've noticed that a lot of the topics about these premieres are similar. Of course, be the change you want to see, I'm aware, and making more topics of my own would probably aid to remedy the situation, but I figured it was worth making a journal entry discussing it and pointing out that it's a trend I noticed. And evidently, I wasn't the only one to have noticed it, as I've seen other journal entries and status updates of people growing frustrated with it. I'm not frustrated that politics are being related to ponies, and in fact I believe it to be inevitable. But I do think there's a possibility such discussion is not nuanced enough, and it's also not contained enough. Those are just my thoughts, though. Feel free to let me know what you think.
  9. Definitely understandable. While the show does parallel the real world, I think people get a little too carried away in how close the parallel is actually supposed to be. I have noticed the constant insistence of political topics such as imperialism being encouraged in the show, and I just don't get that impression at all, among other arguments that seem to have nothing to do with the episode's contents (I'm still baffled by the whole "white unicorn" thing in one of the threads, like what the heck? where on earth did that come from?). You have my regards.
  10. I watched some of it. Couldn't stomach watching the rest. Read a synopsis; it was exactly as I feared it would be. From the depths of my heart, I have to say sincerely: you're not missing much. Truthfully, you're not really a fan unless you pass Go, collect $200, and then use those $200 to buy every single piece of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic merch on the market, including imports from Japan, and then make your graduation song Celestia's Ballad. Only once you have done those things can you call yourself a proper fan of the show. Obviously. I've skipped a few episodes myself due to being preoccupied, but I am slowly going back over what I missed. Some of them I also skipped because the premise of the episode didn't interest me.
  11. You could argue, though, that such friendships wouldn't have even been given a chance if the School of Friendship didn't exist. It was clear the cultures didn't intersect often before then, and they were quick to accuse each other when the Non-Pone 6 disappeared. Thorax and Ember would have never made friends if Spike hadn't made friends with them to begin with. It's like a domino effect. And also, the problem wasn't even the Mane 6, the problem was the EEA. They would be able to teach friendship just fine, but they stuck "by the book" too much when friendship doesn't go "by the book" by nature.
  12. Yona is definitely my favorite. While the other characters are a bit similar to personalities we've already seen before (which is the point), Yona is a stand-out in mannerisms and disposition, which is what makes her so endearing to me. I'm really interested in how she develops; she has a lot of potential.
  13. There's a reason that I went by the name "Scootaloved" when I first joined (and I still have a note of it in my signature). The sisterly relationships for the other two pairs are adorable and amazing, but Rainbow Dash and Scootaloo will always have my favorite relationship of the series. Maybe it's because of the implications of Scootaloo's home life (even if her parents are loving as can be they're clearly not around enough to give her the support she needs, and to me it's pretty evident that Scootaloo's looking up to Rainbow was a way of helping her through what was a pretty lonely fillyhood), or the fact that Scootaloo positively influences Rainbow Dash to be a better pony for her sake, or how the two actually had to work to develop their relationship rather than it being a gimme, but the two of them are just really, really precious to me.

     

    When I first joined the fandom, there was an idea that was prevalent in it that I wasn't particularly fond of and didn't support; I'm not going to go into details about it other than to say that the implication was that Rainbow and Scootaloo had a bad relationship, and I was so, so happy when show-canon completely dashed it. If you can find no other merit in Rainbow's character, the very least you can reflect is that she's a supportive, caring older sister to Scootaloo, somepony you can tell direly needed the support in her life.

    1. Shrug

      Shrug

      Very true. Not to mention. Their sisterly relationship is what helps make episodes like Sleepless in Ponyville and Flight to the Finish among the best in the whole series and very high in my favorites list. :) 

  14. Rainbow Dash saying that she's proud of Scootaloo in "We'll Make Our Marks" reprise never fails to make me emotional bye

    1. Shrug

      Shrug

      That whole entire song never fails to make me very very emotional. :kindness:

    2. GrimGrimoire

      GrimGrimoire

      There are several emotional moments involving Dash and Scoots. That is one of them

  15. It's grown on me. I admit, I didn't like their appearances at first, but I actually think these designs are better, and it's because the designs now have more opportunities to be individualistic - which is super important to the character growth of the changelings which previously functioned as a dark hivemind.
  16. I mean, to be fair, half of those species proved to be a threat to the ponies at some point or another. (Changelings especially, as we have outright witnessed what they have done to ponies. It's no joke when their leader is able to take out Celestia of all ponies, and even managed to encapsulate them later.) It's very easy to demonize characters (and, thus, people) who have these perspectives, especially if we think they're ridiculous (and we've seen them being ridiculous because we personally know the other species), but characters also exist as a venue for us to understand real people who may think or feel similarly. Outright dismissal of his reasoning just because to you it's morally unjustified is probably why you're having trouble understanding him. But of course, I'm one of those people who sings kumbaya and thinks the world could do with more of us attempting to understand one another.
  17. No problem! I'll be sure to keep an eye out for that. Fair enough! Wait mode is probably the best one to implement if you're going to implement any of them and stick to one. I only recall Active being helpful for me in FFVII when I had to build limit breaks and so let my opponents attack me, and I'm doubtful that limit breaks will actually come into play with this game. (Or will they...?) I would stick to Active just because it's faster when playing FFVII, but Wait mode is far more accessible because then enemies can't attack you during menus, so I'm not surprised you would lean toward that instead. Will it be possible to skip over turns if you have more than one character with a filled, er...whatever term you're going to use once Rest Time is full? That was something I appreciated in FFVII since it allowed more versatility in strategy as opposed to waiting for everyone to go in a set order, so I'd be interested in your thoughts on that. And no problem! I'm looking forward to this!
  18. It's clear that they're still pretty new to the concept, and although Thorax and his fellow changelings are friendly, it's easy to see from Thorax's gripes toward Spike, along with the other problems he has leading the changelings, that it's a little rocky going for them at times, and there's no sense in not attending a welcoming, open environment where he can learn more about it. A willingness to be friendly doesn't mean that he's actually good at friendship, much the same way that me being able to sing in front of a crowd doesn't mean that I'm not off-key. Given that the griffon was the most stubborn of the group, and the authority figure griffon clearly still saw the idea of friendship as a complete waste of time, I think it's safe to say they have a long way to go still. They know one side of communion, but not the entire thing. They build their society off of competition, which can easily chew itself and spit itself back out. I mean, it is essentially what the ponies themselves learned, communion. It's what allowed Equestria to become as strong as it is. And they're not taking away their culture by suggesting that they need to work on acting as a community among themselves and with other species, merely expanding it and making it richer. Or perhaps "spread friendship" reaches children and rolls off the tongue better than "spread skills in making friends, diplomatic relations, and benefiting interpersonal relationships".
  19. The racism charge seems to come from two ideas, one of which existed even before the Season 8 Premiere and the other as a result of it. The first one that already existed actually comes from the Cutie Map, and it's from people believing that the ponies' spread of friendship is analogous to imperialism, an act that is commonly associated with racism (racism is not always the reason for imperialism in reality, but it's commonly attributed to that mainly in the United States' case; whether or not such a claim is accurate is a debate for another topic). I have argued, and will continue to argue, that the two situations aren't actually analogous to each other at all, because the spreading of friendship is in no way similar to attempting to conquer a nation for political power, but that's generally the gist of why people think that contributes. As for the Season 8 premiere...
  20. I don't anticipate that politics will become all that large a factor within MLP at any point. There are some situations in MLP that could be considered analogous to real life situations, but they won't be the main focus of the stories that are being told. After all, it is a little girl's show. I wouldn't say there won't be references to political situations here and there, but at most they will be subtle, such as
  21. If nothing else, I do think MLP: FiM is one of the best cartoons marketed specifically for girls. Generally speaking, a lot of girl cartoons revolve around the same plots that lack pretty much any proper substance. MLP: FiM is unique in that I can actually recommend it to people. As for best cartoons of all time, though, I don't think MLP: FiM quite reaches that level. There are some cartoons that I like more than it, such as Danny Phantom.
  22. Let me start with prefacing that your artwork is absolutely gorgeous, and I'm really looking forward to seeing the direction that this project takes. Also I would totally beta test but that's not important. Now, with that being said... I was looking at the sprite work that you had on the over world. Of course, I'm sure right now you're just attempting to get an overall scheme working for it, but once you've got that, if you plan on sticking to these bigger sprites at the bottom, might I suggest making another expression for when the pony is low on HP? I always find small touches like that really nice in games. If it's possible, an idle animation to your main sprites too could work wonders, but I can understand if that part would be too much of a hassle. EDIT: If you want an example of this, Kingdom Hearts has got a nice one. Also, something else - Are you going for a system similar to the ATB system such as that used in earlier Final Fantasy games? Because if so, count me in approval of it. The ATB system is a great system. If you plan on implementing that, though, you might want to implement a Wait mode for it on top of the normal mode, so players can go at different paces. Final Fantasy VII is a good example to go by for ATB, as it's got an Active, Recommended, and Wait mode. Active is everyone goes literally once they get the chance to and you can also skip turns as long as someone is able to act; but this also applies to enemies, so they can attack you while you're not doing anything. Wait makes it so turns go at the player's pace entirely, so enemies can't attack until after the player characters have already gone. I believe Recommended is a mixture of the two. If I'm completely off the mark, though, feel free to let me know.
    1. Show previous comments  5 more
    2. Shrug

      Shrug

      You joined a few years ago on another account? What happened to that account? 

    3. Nyactis Mewcis Catlum

      Nyactis Mewcis Catlum

      I ditched it, basically. I changed a lot since I had that account and I had no attachment. I worked it out with the staff and it's since been banned since you're not allowed to have more than one account. (It's not because of any actual infractions on the account, though. I didn't have any at the time.)

    4. Shrug

      Shrug

      Sounds like a very respectable reason to not use an account anymore to me. 

×
×
  • Create New...