Would MLP be more enjoyable to watch in 3D?

[cider float 2,537]

When I mean 3D I mean like with 3D glasses and an alteration of the episodes like in some movies these days since 3D movies seems to make the picture appear more alive. Of course it will still have the non-3D look as well.

[Radiobolt 186]

No, I really like it they way it is, to be honest :/

[Ragingdubstep 61]

Nah, but maybe as game it would be cool 

[Sage 125]

Stereoscopy doesn't work to well with 2D animation if you ask me. It'd look really awkward, especially if it was done just because and not the first thing they thought about when animating. 

Edited July 28, 2015 by Sage

[Grepper 3,192]

I don't think I'd want to watch every episode that way, but I'd try watching one.

It would be quite a bit of work for the studio to re-render the episode in 3D, because unlike in CGI films, there is no "actual" depth in the animation to begin with.

[Dark Qiviut 22,296]

No. Anytime I watch in 3D, I start feeling dizzy, nauseous, or both. Watching FIM in 3D will literally ruin the experience for me because I'll feel physically sick.

Edited July 28, 2015 by Dark Qiviut

[cider float 2,537]

I'd give it a try if they make it work somehow.

[superdogz1999 551]

I think that MLP in 3D will be amazing. Seeing the ponies come right out of the screen and into your face will amaze you.

[Espurr 449]

No. Just, just no. Never. 3D is already sometimes sickening to watch so... no.

[Rainboom Dash 1,055]

I don't think it'd work for the show itself, but I'd be interested in the movie being 3D...

[They call me Loyalty 1,946]

That's just annoying, personally. I'm more like 4th dimension, on my way to 5th already.

It's unconditional here, feeling just like heaven the whole time.

[Pastel 7,629]

The 3D you're talking about works for action movies, not for calm shows like MLP:FiM.

[Sekr Gray 520]

Speaking from this type of 3D effects, I'd pass on it. It might be fun to see pinkie pie jump out of the screen at you, but that's really the main effect you'd get from the show as is.

 

However, remaking the episodes in 3D models and animation, that could be quite interesting (think something like SFM).

[cmarston1 5,956]

Not really.

I don't see how 3d effects would work for a 2D cartoon like FIM.

[Leave a Whisper 703]

When I mean 3D I mean like with 3D glasses and an alteration of the episodes like in some movies these days since 3D movies seems to make the picture appear more alive. Of course it will still have the non-3D look as well.

 

I guess it depends on the person. It's a cool concept, but 3D can give some people headaches and people like me, who's eyesight isn't so hot anymore would see it as blurred and kinda fuzzy.

[weesh 690]

The 3DS fire emblem games look REALLY awkward when they push the 2D pictures out from the backgrounds.  if you just adjust the depth of a 2D image, it actually is more distracting than helpful.  It would be a lot of effort to make the visuals worse.

 

 

However, remaking the episodes in 3D models and animation, that could be quite interesting (think something like SFM).

 

Oh, please no.

SFM ponies are monstrous abominations.  they look like clay.  even the really well done animations are held back by how creepy the fur, manes and eyes look.

[user1342342 143]

The 3DS fire emblem games look REALLY awkward when they push the 2D pictures out from the backgrounds.  if you just adjust the depth of a 2D image, it actually is more distracting than helpful.  It would be a lot of effort to make the visuals worse.

 

 

 

Oh, please no.

SFM ponies are monstrous abominations.  they look like clay.  even the really well done animations are held back by how creepy the fur, manes and eyes look.

 

If they shrunk the heads down to a normal size, they would be a lot more tolerable for me. I'd like to see an episode animated in actual 3D, that would be pretty cool.

[Steve Piranha 29,405]

I dunno, I think 3D is a waste of cash anyway. Never had a movie 3D experience that made me speechless 

[weesh 690]

I dunno, I think 3D is a waste of cash anyway. Never had a movie 3D experience that made me speechless 

 

"how to train your dragon" used it expertly.  you felt THERE.  it managed to add dramatically to the experience without being distracting.  

[Steve Piranha 29,405]

"how to train your dragon" used it expertly.  you felt THERE.  it managed to add dramatically to the experience without being distracting.  

Which one, the second? I didn't feel that in the first movie at least

[weesh 690]

Which one, the second? I didn't feel that in the first movie at least

 

the first, i didn't see the second in 3d.  

 

what do you expect for a 3d movie?  do you want it to be so audacious that you stop paying attention to the movie and start marveling at the 3d? 

in the opening scene where Hiccup hides behind the post, I felt the fear of fire rushing past me

in the flight scenes i felt the anxiety of falling

in the conclusion, the ash added to an atmosphere of dread and uncertainty.  

[powerpuff-tsubasa 448]

no can do m8. making them ponies into 3d models makes it look more ugly. better off when its used for future disney movies

[Dreambiscuit 9,020]

I think making traditional animation into 3D is fantastic. When Disney made Beauty and the Beast, Little Mermaid and Lion King into 3D they took on a whole new life. CG 3D animation is nice and all, but the novelty of seeing cel animation in 3D is too unique to dismiss. It's like walking into the classic cartoons I grew up with. It was like living the movie in a way I never got from CG movies in 3D. In many cases with CG 3D, unless the 3D effect is phenomenal, I usually stop noticing the 3D effect minutes after the movie has started.