Which pony of the mane 6 would you have as your girlfriend?

[Reaverpony 3]

Based solely on personalities I would want to choose Twilight but would probably end up with Fluttershy considering my record in real life.

[Steel Accord 6,660]

If i could have any of them..Fluttershy would be my top choice. Sure she's a bit withdrawn, and she lives amongst animals, but behind that shy exterior is (hopefully) a sweet, not-crazy sort of girl. Just gotta let her warm up to ya, and you got yourself a nice little relationship.

 

Exactly how I picture her. She suffered from Cutie Mark Faliure Insanity Syndrome ( or CMFIS) at the Grand Galloping Gala, but that's not how she REALLY is!

[VladmireV.S.(Crank) 1,096]

Begone boy! She's mine!

 

No! she is mine!!! i will use my superior intelligence to daze and confuse you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Azura 1,107]

I'd pick Rainbow Dash because she's just so adorable, not in a Fluttershy kind of way though.

 

Dashie has something I just love about her.

[My little pwny 1,392]

I think it would be super funny to have some of the "ask the mane 6" tumblers to react to some of these posts.

____

 

If your reading this Twilight Sparkle, I'd treat you better than any other mare!

[Princess_Molestia 1,460]

I think it would be super funny to have some of the "ask the mane 6" tumblers to react to some of these posts.

____

 

If your reading this Twilight Sparkle, I'd treat you better than any other mare!

 

but how would she treat you?

 

muhauhuaahahahahahaha (sorry)...

[Drehgunklew 136]

Fluttershy or Rainbow Dash I would actually fall in love in seconds if there were two girls exactly like them...

[Forlong 1,726]

If I ever meet a single human female version of Fluttershy, I would totally go for it. Not pony Fluttershy, because that's kind of creepy and weird.

[Steel Accord 6,660]

If I ever meet a single human female version of Fluttershy, I would totally go for it. Not pony Fluttershy, because that's kind of creepy and weird.

 

Same here dude! Except for the second part, really it's an impossible situation to begin with. Meeting the actual, real Fluttershy? If I'm already there what's the point in NOT pursuing a romance. Unless she's scared of me, in which case I would do my best just not to frighten her!

[Mephala 2,633]

Since I'm a girl and straight I couldn't choose one.

But personality wise I'd go for a mixture of all of them but Fluttershy. The other five all have qualities I admire.

 

But if it was a dude...

STEVEN BUCKING MAGNET.

I have a thing for moustaches. Especially ginger ones.

[Steel Accord 6,660]

I'm a straight female, so N/A XD If I were a male, I'd choose Fluttershy

 

Perhaps a compromise m'lady?

 

[FlareChaser0096 142]

Perhaps a compromise m'lady?

 

 

Yes! He's adorable! Maybe a slightly more masculine cutie mark, perhaps. Like moths instead of butterflies :3

[Forlong 1,726]

Poor Rarity has the least votes. Why does no one love her? She did nothing to you, but be generous and kind.

[Steel Accord 6,660]

Poor Rarity has the least votes. Why does no one love her? She did nothing to you, but be generous and kind.

 

Hey! She's my second, following Fluttershy! Rarity is very much my dream girl, Fluttershy only beats her by a tiny margin in compatibility.

[Princess Thunderfire 2]

I'm 100% Female, and 100% straight, but, if I was a colt, I'd go for Rainbow Dash. I get along well with people like myself. Which, Rainbow just happens to fill that personality perfectly.

[Steel Accord 6,660]

I'm 100% Female, and 100% straight, but, if I was a colt, I'd go for Rainbow Dash. I get along well with people like myself. Which, Rainbow just happens to fill that personality perfectly.

 

Again, I offer my beloved pegasisters a compromise!

 

[FlareChaser0096 142]

Again, I offer my beloved pegasisters a compromise!

 

 

The eyebrow scares me xD The rest is awesome!

[Steel Accord 6,660]

The eyebrow scares me xD The rest is awesome!

 

 

Sorry! The last thing I want to do is offend or frighten my fellow bronies *slash* pegasisters. Forgive me m'lady.

[Music Chart Fan 819]

Definitely Twilight. I would have big issues with the other five.

 

Rarity: I don't care at all about fashion, and I hate following arbitrary social rules, i.e. rules that serve no discernible purpose.

 

Applejack: The whole redneck, Southern, unlearned vibe is very offputting, and I do not want to live on or work on a farm.

 

Fluttershy: I dislike animals of all kinds - I would never want a pet (let alone tens of animals living in my house) - and the soft-spoken "cute" factor is too overbearing.

 

Rainbow Dash: I am not athletic, not at all into sports or physical feats, and not really competitive in the sense that she is.

 

Pinkie Pie: She is pretty much the opposite of my personality type (I am an INTJ), I am very anti-social, and I like things to be orderly and non-random.

 

Because of these flaws, Twilight is left as the most compatible with me. I would like to hang out with a fellow intellectual person like myself, and while I'm not that much into reading per se, I do like looking things up and diving deep into subjects in which I'm interested.

[AnonBrony 1,468]

I'd go with Twilight all the way. Me and her are exactly the same except shes not obseesed with videogames... and i never read a library of books.

[Awesomeviking 5]

While Rainbow Dash is my favourite pony, I would say Twilight Sparkle. Simply because that's the type of girl I really connect with/enjoy hanging out with. Which is weird considering I'm personality wise a mix between Aplejack and rainbow Dash.

[Coolius rpi 117]

Really? Twilight Sparkle? She doesnt seem like very good girlfriend material to me. rainbow dash seems like she would be overbearing. Rainbow would be to intense for me. Im more a laid-back kind of guy. FLuttershy all the way! but not just because shes cute, but because isnt afraid to be bold, like when she made a dragon cry and terrozed the woodland creatures!

[Awesomeviking 5]

Really? Twilight Sparkle? She doesnt seem like very good girlfriend material to me.

 

Really? Sure she does seem a bit to analytic, but I she does seem like the kind of pony/person that you could discuss books, hsitory etc with. Which fits me just perfectly Of course I'm basing my choice based on how a person reminding me of that pony would be, not just what we see from the ponies in the show.

 

rainbow Dash being a bit overbearing I completely agree with, and I do see where you are coming from picking Fluttershy.

[Coolius rpi 117]

Really? Sure she does seem a bit to analytic, but I she does seem like the kind of pony/person that you could discuss books, hsitory etc with. Which fits me just perfectly Of course I'm basing my choice based on how a person reminding me of that pony would be, not just what we see from the ponies in the show.

 

rainbow Dash being a bit overbearing I completely agree with, and I do see where you are coming from picking Fluttershy.

 

I guess it all just comes down to your personal preference. I beleive that all the main six are something that make up a dream girl for different guys. FOr example, my dream girl is a mixture between applejack and fluttershy. It makes sense sense. would be one of the mane six. You can find qualties of the perfect woman in each of the main six. Kindness, intelligence, loyalty (o she doesnt cheat), honesty generosity and laughter! maybe Lauren Faust made them that way. As a way of expressing the perfect relationship.

 

Again, I offer my beloved pegasisters a compromise!

 

 

OMG HE IS HARRY POTTER!

get it?because of the scar?

Edited August 12, 2012 by Fanayvea

[Acoustic Cloud 2,202]

Rainbow Dash all the way, she's 20% cooler than the others plus would be a beast to hang out with