"Tell Your Tale" Alternate Art Style Concepts

[bubbleteapony 583]

https://www.equestriadaily.com/2022/05/alternate-art-styles-for-tell-your-tale.html

 

EqD posted an article featuring a bunch of concept works exploring alternative art style and character proportions for Tell Your Tale. Personally, I like the body proportions for what they went with, but I like the top art style a lot better than the official one. I'm curious to know what other people think as well, though from the comments, it's looking like other people prefer the unused style as well

[ExplosionMare 18,007]

It's too bad they didn't go with the first designs. Wonder what changed, there.

[Splashee 28,537]

I wish I could say "wow", but both of those styles are not good.

 

The artist can draw, no problem there. It is just, the ponies are trying to be different looking (and I get that), but not a single one of them are actually looking "cute". And trust me, "cute" goes a long way to getting us to be interested in the franchise.

(Some members here find some ponies cute, or "adorable", and I totally accept that. I like that!)

 

Now, I do like how the artist is leaving the contact information. Was it leaked? Maybe that is not a good thing. I still like the quality of the drawings and the time spent improving character designs. I just think they are not "cute" enough. The 3D ones are cuter.

 

Also, the ones being used in the show are ugly, odd, and not this good quality.

 

 

Also, I feel this is important, but the reveal of TyT's characters were extremely negative:

 

Original Thread

 

[Props Valroa 26,046]

I do not particularly like either of them. Would say the first is better, but the way Izzy is designed - its just...unappealing to look at. I don't like how Pudgy Pipp is in the second one. Wish they just kept with an upgraded G4's style and not did a redesign.

[Savygriffs 5,022]

The first style is ADORABLE!!! Tho Pipp isn't as chubby in that one.

Ehh, I'm totally happy with the designs we got now. 

[Sparklefan1234 161,878]

7 hours ago, PrettyInPipp said:

I'm totally happy with the designs we got now. 

 

Me, too! 

If I had to choose between the other two choices though, I think I would choose the second set of ponies. 

 

Quote

Also, I feel this is important, but the reveal of TyT's characters were extremely negative:

 

@Splashee 

I was a fan of the Tell Your Tales look we have now from the beginning. Even Hitch's "table chin" grew on me. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Edited June 2, 2022 by Sparklefan1234

[Rosy Moonlight 367]

I like the top style better.

The skinny hooves and lankiness of the bottom style does not sit well with me.

[Pentium100 2,057]

Both versions suck, the top one sucks a bit less.

There were G5 leaks with much better style, sadly they went with this one. For me, tell your tale is barely watchable - the stories are OK, but the art style is difficult to get over.

[Northern Star 1,023]

None of those are exactly great or to a point good. They just look generic to me, probably from the overuse of that style over the last decade or so. They don't stand out like G4. They don't really stand out at all.

 

But I suspose when you are trying to make a low budget easy to mass produce cartoon...that's what you get.

Edited June 2, 2022 by TheGleaner

[Evil Pink One 12,990]

I vote for the first design

[The Nth Doctor 652]

Them being chonky beans is far cuter than being lanky noodles

Although the latter's easier to animate for a quick YouTube series, so I get why they went with it

[Props Valroa 26,046]

11 hours ago, Pentium100 said:

Both versions suck, the top one sucks a bit less.

There were G5 leaks with much better style, sadly they went with this one. For me, tell your tale is barely watchable - the stories are OK, but the art style is difficult to get over.

I think I've given up on it. I may watch it once in a great while but I cannot stand this art style. Both of them suck! 

[bubbleteapony 583]

13 hours ago, Pentium100 said:

Both versions suck, the top one sucks a bit less.

There were G5 leaks with much better style, sadly they went with this one. For me, tell your tale is barely watchable - the stories are OK, but the art style is difficult to get over.

I have to say, with all the G5 leaks we got while FIM was still happening as well as the concept art that's been released, I'm also disappointed in what they went forward with. Both the designs and quality seemed (for the most part) to be better in the concepts phase, at least in my opinion. Personally I really liked blue Hitch and inventor Sunny

[Props Valroa 26,046]

1 minute ago, bubbleteapony said:

I have to say, with all the G5 leaks we got while FIM was still happening as well as the concept art that's been released, I'm also disappointed in what they went forward with. Both the designs and quality seemed (for the most part) to be better in the concepts phase, at least in my opinion. Personally I really liked blue Hitch and inventor Sunny

Blue hitch and Pink pipp were a lot better. I do not quite like the design of Izzy either. 

[Skylight Scintillate 1,851]

Eh these styles are very mediocre. The style they have currently is slightly better, but that isn’t saying much. However, the other styles didn’t go for the jellybean mouth style which is something they definitely should have done for this current style.

[Splashee 28,537]

At one point in time, they just became Steven Universe characters instead

[TransPirate 120]

I wish TYT models looked more like SU.