Jan animations shut down by hasbro/C&D

[Celestial Wish 349]

The issue at large is that they were in the right, they did not violate law. But they cannot argue their position, as doing so would blacklist them, and prevent them from having a successful future in animation. Hasbro is essentially running things like a mafia.

 

Oh man, and I've always LOVED the mafia -sniffle- Al Capone baby..

[Malinter 3,064]

Jan could probably just recolour the ponies in the Videos and boom.

 

Hasbro can't do anything anymore because that isn't button.. its a totally original oc that totally isn't button at all.

[Celestial Wish 349]

this is my head right now...

[Malinter 3,064]

I'm gonna keep saying this. Hasbro are simply protecting their products, nothing more.

 

protecting from what exactly?

[Rarity Paige Belle 1,854]

Jan could probably just recolour the ponies in the Videos and boom.

 

Hasbro can't do anything anymore because that isn't button.. its a totally original oc that totally isn't button at all.

No, they couldn't. If it looks like something that originated from FIM, you're still liable! Even if it is an OC. Edited March 22, 2014 by Pinkie Perry

[Hawk Moth 390]

That kind of makes you a tiny bit of a Nazi... though you have a point on Tiarawhy, you'd think they'd have gone for that first. But then again he's got stuff based elsewhere, theres no real way of stopping his stuff outside of youtube..

No, commiting genocide and/or advocating race-based eugenics would make me a Nazi. Please don't devalue the monstrosity of those people by comparing people like me to them. What I am is a narcissistic asshole with anger problems - not a Nazi.

 

Also Tiarawhy is female. Nonetheless, I'd love it if her vile trolling BS was stamped out for good. Still I don't hate her near as much as I do the FiW people.

Edited March 22, 2014 by Hawk Moth

[Malinter 3,064]

No, they couldn't. If it looks like something that originated from FIM, you're still liable! Even if it is an OC.

 

They've have to prove it first. If the animation never mentions anything from the show or shows no locations from the show then it is NOT FiM.

[Celestial Wish 349]

No, they couldn't. If it looks like something that originated from FIM, you're still liable! Even if it is an OC.

 

Well in that case, let's all just stop creating fan-made anything.

 

Oh what a colorless world you live in... 

 

Do you not even understand that most original works were INSPIRED by fan-work!?

[Malinter 3,064]

No, commiting genocide and/or advocating race-based eugenics would make me a Nazi. Please don't devalue the monstrosity of those people by comparing people like me to them. What I am is a narcissistic asshole with anger problems - not a Nazi.

 

I did say "tiny bit". Maybe the Gastapo getting folks to rat on people might have been more accurate?? 

[Horsy 193]

I'm gonna keep saying this. Hasbro are simply protecting their products, nothing more.

 

From what? From fanwork which brings more bronies who then buy their products? If you take a look at some other fandoms like Star Trek, you will see that fans do big projects similar to JanAnimations and they don't get taken down. 

Edited March 22, 2014 by TheWiseHippo

[Rarity Paige Belle 1,854]

They've have to prove it first. If the animation never mentions anything from the show or shows no locations from the show then it is NOT FiM.

They wouldn't need to. The animation is in the same style of FIM, and uses a cartoon pony. That's all the courts would need to issue a C&D order.

[ParsoOfEquestria 1,490]

No, they couldn't. If it looks like something that originated from FIM, you're still liable! Even if it is an OC.

okay, by your logic, then I shouldn't see all these chinese knock off toys that have accurate images of the character with a different name? news for you bud, they're all over the shop

[Rarity Paige Belle 1,854]

From what? From fanwork which brings more bronies who then buy their products? If you take a look at some other fandoms like Star Trek, you will see that fans do big projects like JanAnimations and they don't get taken down.

 

Alot of these products, such as the stuff sold at conventions are completely unofficial.

[Malinter 3,064]

You can't copyright a style of animation. Places, names, character designs, sure. Thats like someone making a stop motion animation with clay models and being C&D by ardman animatons.

Edited March 22, 2014 by Malinter

[Celestial Wish 349]

And seriously, not everyone can just fork over hundreds to thousands of dollars for copyright approval. Just like how people can't afford to pay for itunes or netflix or cable, so they rely on youtube or other websites that can FREELY entertain the public.

 

But even these days, youtube is becoming a stick in the mud thanks to Google. I just don't see anything wrong with people who truly love something compassionately, put their talents towards a specific entertainment, and get penalized because they can't afford permission. 

Edited March 22, 2014 by Celestial Wish

[Rarity Paige Belle 1,854]

okay, by your logic, then I shouldn't see all these chinese knock off toys that have accurate images of the character with a different name? news for you bud, they're all over the shop

Yes, but because China has no copyright laws, you can do as you please over there, and Hasbro can't do a thing about it.

[M'aiq the Liar 5,804]

And seriously, not everyone can just fork over hundreds to thousands of dollars for copyright approval. Just like how people can't afford to pay for itunes or netflix or cable, so they rely on youtube or other websites that can FREELY entertain the public.

 

But even these days, youtube is becoming a stick in the mud thanks to Google. I just don't see anything wrong with people who truly love something compassionately, put their talents towards a specific entertainment, and get penalized because they can afford permission.

 

You can now, and that is how they control you. Only they are allowed to show you. only they are allowed to tell you. only they are allowed to teach you. Because you cannot afford to do it yourself.

[ParsoOfEquestria 1,490]

Yes, but because China has no copyright laws, you can do as you please over there, and Hasbro can't do a thing about it.

yes, but once imported, Hasbro has ever right to take them from the shelves

[Horsy 193]

Alot of these products, such as the stuff sold at conventions are completely unofficial.

https://www.youtube.com/user/HiddenFrontier/videos

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b-WBKah3uwg

 

Totally unofficial.

 

I haven't watched this but if I did I could have listed you way more. Now I am bored to search for more.

[Celestial Wish 349]

You can now, and that is how they control you. Only they are allowed to show you. only they are allowed to tell you. only they are allowed to teach you. Because you cannot afford to do it yourself.

 

Yeah and that contradicts all the freedom laws in the WORLD.

[Rarity Paige Belle 1,854]

And seriously, not everyone can just fork over hundreds to thousands of dollars for copyright approval. Just like how people can't afford to pay for itunes or netflix or cable, so they rely on youtube or other websites that can FREELY entertain the public.

 

But even these days, youtube is becoming a stick in the mud thanks to Google. I just don't see anything wrong with people who truly love something compassionately, put their talents towards a specific entertainment, and get penalized because they can afford permission.

 

I'm sorry, but tough. If you can't afford to participate in the fandom, then you can't afford it. It gives you no right to illegally download/stream videos. ( which is a form of theft, by the way.)

yes, but once imported, Hasbro has ever right to take them from the shelves

And they do! To be honest I've never seen any proper copycat FIM products.

[Hawk Moth 390]

I did say "tiny bit". Maybe the Gastapo getting folks to rat on people might have been more accurate??

 

People have been snitching on others since the birth of language, yet you choose to call me a Nazi. Also the Gestapo were less notorious for advocating snitching; a more apt analogy would have been to call me an East German Stasi agent - who were truly legendary buzzkills. Sorry for splitting hairs, but it's something that really bothers me when everyone gets called a Nazi to the point where the word means nothing.

[Celestial Wish 349]

I'm sorry, but tough. If you can't afford to participate in the fandom, then you can't afford it. It gives you no right to illegally download/stream videos. ( which is a form of theft, by the way.)

 

I never said download or stream, I said Youtube. Where in the hoof did you pull that from? 

 

[ParsoOfEquestria 1,490]

I'm sorry, but tough. If you can't afford to participate in the fandom, then you can't afford it. It gives you no right to illegally download/stream videos. ( which is a form of theft, by the way.)

 

And they do! To be honest I've never seen any proper copycat FIM products.

then you aren't looking hard enough, I see them in every obvious spot

[Malinter 3,064]

I'm sorry, but tough. If you can't afford to participate in the fandom, then you can't afford it. It gives you no right to illegally download/stream videos. ( which is a form of theft, by the way.)

 

So folks outside the US shouldn't watch streams of a show they can't watch on tv in there own country then? Screw that.