Theory The truth behind 'My little pony'

[Lankman 86]

There is a conspiracy theory that I discovered about my little pony called The truth behind 'my little pony'.

I Tried to make a link but it does not seem to be working, so if you can maybe go on youtube and type in The truth behind 'My little pony' and you should see a thumbnail of fluttershy getting..........eaten by her own animals (sounds morbid) and click on it and listen.

For those who can't find it I will try to explain it but not in detail.

It's just about how the creator of the show came up with the characters, its about real life girls that have the exact same personalities as the one in the show and they all died on the same day and were reborn ponies or something.

I do not believe this theory but I find it interesting IMO.

[Steve 290]

there are tons of creepypasta stories like this. some are very entertaining

[Night Shine 767]

Here is a link to (what I think is) the story you are referencing. For the record, I did not read it and have no interest in doing so (a friend described it to me, so I get the idea, and I do not like creepy-pastas in general), but I thought I ought to provide a link for the sake of the topic.

[Lankman 86]

Thank you for the link, really appreciate it.

I don't believe or even think that this is real but I find it interesting.

Edited May 27, 2014 by Lankman

[Oblivion 20,265]

Yea, I have also watched that, it's a pretty sad creepypasta, and I believe that the Fluttershy and Dashie one really got to me the most, very heart wrenching if you ask me. But at least they are ponies now and are happy!

Edited May 27, 2014 by 0blivion

[Frosty Nerd 833]

Listening to that gave me the chills. This is a much better story than "Ash's Coma Theory". These girls were all so sad and depressing. It breaks my heart even though I know it's fiction.

[Oblivion 20,265]

Listening to that gave me the chills. This is a much better story than "Ash's Coma Theory". These girls were all so sad and depressing. It breaks my heart even though I know it's fiction.

I know, It's so bittersweet though isn't it? I mean it is so sad yet at the same time so happy at the end.

[Bunnyhop123 194]

I'm not a fan of these "truth behind" "theories".  Anyone can come up with something unfalsifiable and emotionally manipulative in moments.  

 

Twilight crashed in her chariot on the way to Ponyville: her adventures and friends are all a product of her subconscious.  

 

Nightmare Moon defeated the mane-six, and, distraught, they took to writing fictional stories about what could have happened.

 

MLP is the world of the past, before an apocalypse killed everypony, and we eventually evolved.

 

MLP is the world of the future, after an apocalypse killed everyone, and the ponies eventually evolved.

Edited September 21, 2014 by TSG

[SaburoDaimando 1,196]

Oh great.  Now the anti-MLP conspiracy theorists are taking cues from that awful Cupcakes fanfiction.

[Buck Testa 5,503]

Meh, its so so on the creepypasta scale for me. The thing with these kind of stories is you need "evidence" to back it up. just slapping "based on a true story" on it is not going to cut it.

 

Give me photos and stuff to immerse in and you got something good.

[Something Floaty 1,333]

The only truth about MLP is that Pinkie Pie is best pony. Everything else is open to interpretation.

[Deathstroke 1,564]

Meh, its so so on the creepypasta scale for me. The thing with these kind of stories is you need "evidence" to back it up. just slapping "based on a true story" on it is not going to cut it.

 

Give me photos and stuff to immerse in and you got something good.

You want a creepypasta with pictures? I recommend watching NES godzilla 

[Venomous 18,813]

I've listened to this creepy pasta before, and it's definitley creepy.

[Twilight Circuits 603]

I read the whole thing and I don't buy it for a minute.

[Buck Testa 5,503]

You want a creepypasta with pictures? I recommend watching NES godzilla

Saw that one sometime ago when I was on a creepypasta bender. Couldn't really get into it for whatever reason. It may sound cliche but Ben Drowned was fantastic for that initial creepy factor. And the evidence, though easily disproven on closer inspection was perfect for that moment you are suspending disbelief.

Another really memorable one for me was one about an eerie mario game that was put online by some sick killer who condemns the plumber for his own act and confesses his crimes in the text boxes as you play on, and if you put all the unused code in the file into a jpg format a murder victims face can be seen

 

Immersion is key for creepy