Not going to disagree here, you made some pretty good points.
But the whole point I was attempting to make was that it bothered me on how much people hold swords (specifically Japanese) in such high regard and often overestimate their abilities, I'm not here to criticize practitioners or hobbyists if I was, I'd be a hypocrite, all I'm saying is that it's a dangerous idea to overestimate a sword and it's limits especially in the increasingly dangerous world where crimes committed using firearms is the norm. If someone thinks they have a decent chance defending themselves with a bladed weapon in the event of an armed home invasion is rather foolish. Universally accepted disciplines, philosophies, and techniques present in various combat arts, both old and new, sword or not, can and are definitely useful today and valuing them as simply offensive savage techniques meant only to bring the death of individual would be ignorant. As a fan and dedicated follower of the sword carrying community, I don't want to see our image tarnished with the arrogant idea that swords are superior and more noble to wield than other defensive tools
Also, this forum's sort of an odd place to discuss this, lol