Thoughts on G5

[Sparklefan1234 170,771]

I prefer the slice of life nature of "Tell Your Tale" to what I guess will be the more serious "Make Your Mark".

I'm glad we have a choice because I always enjoyed the slice of life stories in Friendship is Magic over the "EPIC" season premiers and finales.

[Rosy Moonlight 369]

I can imagine that the upper-ups were like "Why not make G5 Make Your Mark 3D? We know it's unlikely will be able to measure up to G4, and the people will have something new to chat about anyway."

[Rosy Moonlight 369]

I do hope G5 will be decent for its run, and it will give us enough material for good fan-content.

[Savy 5,077]

I feel like G5 will improve as it goes on, like how FiM did(it really improved from the first 3 seasons imo). I honestly DO like it so far, but would love some improvement.

I just like TYT a bit more than MYM. Just my own opinion and preference though.

[Splashee 28,564]

I really love the town ponies in Maretime Bay, not just Earth ponies, but even the animals. It is a good setting to be in and G5 has a lot of potential when it comes to having such a great main place to be at.

[ExplosionMare 18,062]

While it hasn't hit the "great" mark for me yet, it has never stopped being adorable and colorful.

[Rosy Moonlight 369]

1 hour ago, PrettyInPipp said:

I just like TYT a bit more than MYM.

The same for me.

I find the backgrounds pretty, the animals cute, and the ponies adorable (even in their unique/strange way).

[Rosy Moonlight 369]

I found MLP:ANG too anvilicious, like if they were going to be isolated from the other pony races for centuries, wouldn't it make sense that they would not want to see illustrations of them that much?

Edited May 30, 2022 by Rosy Moonlight

[Sasoriman 136]

Last night I watched MYM Ch. 1, and it was... acceptable. The animation was stiffer than the movie, the climax was like a callback to Friendship Games, but on the whole, while it was a good start, I'm just not sure if I'll be watching it the rest of the way. 

Edited May 30, 2022 by Sasoriman

[Mallow Gloom 26]

I enjoyed the movie, but MYM... I don't really think I cared for it, and the animation kept throwing me off

I really want to like it though.. so I'm hoping it grows on me 

Edited May 30, 2022 by Mallow Gloom

[AlbaTross 1,586]

Wow, judging by most of the comments it sounds like I was just ahead of the curve on my criticism of G5.  Yeah...two pilots in and I still don't know what this show is about.  FiM only needed one pilot to set up its premise for Season 1.  I suppose we can expect mostly slice of life stuff with the occasional bit of plot, which on paper doesn't sound too far off of FiM...but, how do I put it...this series feels way more disjointed, and FiM had structure and a flow to it that helped it feel like there was rhyme and reason to it all.  Here...I really don't know where this thing is going.  Sometimes that can be fun, especially in a thriller type of show.  However...again, there's a flow to those kinds of storylines.  I don't know...for me this feels too much like an attempt to cash in on FiM while completely missing the mark on what made FiM so engaging.  With that said...there's still enough going on with it to keep me watching for now.  That could change at any time though.  

On 2022-05-27 at 6:31 PM, CastletonSnob said:

FiM was a great show, but let's not pretend it was some 10/10 masterpiece or the best cartoon ever.

Whoa, do you feel brave enough to take that by the FiM discussion boards?   Of course, I'm of the opinion that there's no such thing as a perfect show, but I'll give 10s out to ones that resonate with me on a deeper level than most, and I can confidently say that few shows have became the obsession that that series was for me.  The spell it had over me has lifted considerably since it ended, but credit where it is due.  I'll take an imperfect series that hits all the right marks to ignite a fandom like this one.  Call it subjective if you would like, but from where I'm standing, G5 has a real uphill battle if it wishes to capture even a fraction of the magic of that series.  

On 2022-05-28 at 3:49 AM, Rosy Moonlight said:

For me, G5 seriously feel like a mediocre fanfiction series.

Harsh words.  I wish I could say I didn't see where you're coming from.  TFW I come to revelation that I'm not the biggest critic of this series.  

[Steve Piranha 29,424]

12 hours ago, AlbaTross said:

Wow, judging by most of the comments it sounds like I was just ahead of the curve on my criticism of G5.  Yeah...two pilots in and I still don't know what this show is about. 

I completely agree. It’s been a while since ANG came, and we still hardly know anything about G5’s Equestria. Shorts and the last special remained stagnant with the world building, which is null. Nothing else besides what little ANG showed. Thank goodness MyM implies that will change, and G5 will finally go somewhere 

[Jedishy 3,548]

So far Im really happy with it. I love the songs and two characters have grown on me already. 
So I have high hopes. 

[Skylight Scintillate 2,031]

I don't know yet. I feel very indifferent about G5 so far, but I'm willing to give them a chance to prove themselves.

[Rosy Moonlight 369]

I wish that the Shadowly Alicorn will be a "cold ham" character with moments of self-aware humor.

Hopefully, the writers will have enough power to make her like that.

Edited June 1, 2022 by Rosy Moonlight

[Splashee 28,564]

So I have to wait until fall to say if I like G5? (Because MyM was just a special/pilot/one episode)

 

Then, after having to postpone my feeling for G5 for multiple months, over and over, it is starting to look like I would somehow change my mind at some point, and hopefully that is the case. But how many times should I have to wait in between releases of "G5"?

[Rosy Moonlight 369]

I like the Make Your Mark (May 26) special more than the MLP:ANG movie.

I find the special more earnest than the movie.

[HedonismBot 239]

The movie was good enough to leave me moderately optimistic towards G5 as a whole.

The "Make Your Mark" special felt like it was more concerned with setting the stage for the show proper than telling its own story, but it was still decent.

"Tell Your Tale" feels like a modest step up from "Pony Life" - not terribly impressive, but still entertaining.

So based on what I've seen, I'd say the rest of G5 has a sporting chance of turning out well.

[Misty Shadow 7,872]

Like everyone's likely already guessed, I haven't turned on G5. Tell Your Tale's a good guilty pleasure on its worst day and Make Your Mark's pilot was just a pilot that had normal TV show pilot issues with animation and pacing. If G5 were to hypothetically give me something I feel is legit garbage (other than Izzy's cool song about trash), that's when I would provide a constructive take on why I feel that way. However, I have never been super critical of My Little Pony because I have always been conscious of the fact that it's My Little Pony. I'm not falling for the nostalgia trap, I know that the brony fandom has always been this way. They don't like anything when it first comes out with rare exception, they're notoriously fickle. If you think that Friendship is Magic was great from start to finish in their eyes.....

No, I don't even want to go there. Let's just stick to the easy, recent examples. Everyone thought that the G5 movie was going to suck before it came out and most loved it. Then everyone thought that Tell Your Tale was going to suck when we saw the animation and all it took for us to start being optimistic about it was a 30-second clip. Then people started putting down the comics because of Discord's return. All it took was some evidence that they're actually going to do something awesome with the idea to change people's minds. I always sat on the fence because after following what this fandom has done for over a decade, I know I need to see definitively what the creative crew is trying to do before I judge it. 

[Rosy Moonlight 369]

I find that G5 so far is too anvilicious, and it doesn't leave enough breathing room for little moments to stand on their own.

 

[Bright Honor 2,671]

Been pretty good so far. I like that it has more realistic characters. I hope they don't delve too much into the "what happened to G4?" Stuff. Let G5 be its own show.

[nataalya 42]

A lot of people say that the G5 should go its own and only way. They don't seem to understand why some persons have any expectations about previous generation. As a big lover of FiM, I don't want to judge it blindly... however, I think that the number of things (like posters, Sunny's ribbons, even painting in episode "Foal me once" seems to show RD) tells us that this universe has any deal with the G4 so.  Maybe these are just kind of easter eggs for us or maybe something more... but this can't be doubted. G4 is present in the current generation. The only question is for what? We will find out. So I have some hopes too but nvm, this place isn't about it... I just want to mention that it's justified.


I watched a couple of episodes from TYT and it's pretty cool. They are very short but I start to like more and more the new characters. Especially Zipp and Izzy. I knew these two will be my favorites since watched the movie. But the movie was boring and too fast for me. I stopped following MLP because of this . And that was too short time to like them more then. But the episodes are working on it and every subtle detail allows me to feel the old magic in a slightly different version. Sometimes TYT is even funny, but I miss this mystery from FiM. Far lands, kingdoms, dragons, creatures... that was "mythological"? and wide. But here? The only danger I see is the inter-race fights, each time ending up losing the magic and fixing it. The world is boring. At the beginning of the G4, we had Canterlot, Cloudsdale, Everfree... Maybe it will grow.  I don't know. It's still early...  and Pipp irritates me a lot. (Maybe it's because I don't like influancers?)

But not bad. From technical matters, I would prefer everything to stay in 2D. I fall in love with 3D from movie but when I saw MYM...  I don't want to comment this.  The expression is still epic, the work of shadows and lights is worse and the dynamic (like falling, flying...) is very VERY lame to me. I have seen smoother 3D animation made by one person from fandom here.

btw.  maybe it will be about G5 or not - but recently I found a cool Rainbow Dash concept based on TYT and I want to share it to somepony. She is soo phenooomenaaal but going back  to G5. I finally want to get longer episodes. Still not enough things to judge it

 

[Landi 600]

While it is still too early to really say for sure how G5 is, for now it has not lived up to FiM. G5 isn't necessarily bad, but it doesn't feel much more than just average either. The movie was a decent start to the generation, but it definitely had its flaws. Then there is TYT, which is just constant mindless jokes and gags featuring the generation's main characters for five minutes. The MYM pilot special was fairly mediocre and was a bit lacking in the animation department. And as for the comics so far...

Spoiler

I read the second G5 comic earlier today and has really soured my opinion on the generation. While it manages to have some good humor, that doesn't distract from the poorly written explanation for how the unity crystals were created. It reminds me of The Last Jedi in how it makes all the efforts of the mane cast in FiM seem wasted in the end, and it is sad to see G4 being negatively affected by G5. 

On top of all that, it seems harder to get invested in these main characters than it was to those of FiM. G4 wasn't perfect, but it knew how to have compelling characters and start off very strong. G5's on the other hand, has had a much slower start due to being split up between so many mediums. I haven't played the videogame for this generation, but I doubt that it would affect my overall opinion on the generation in any way. So far, this generation seems fairly mediocre. 

[Rosy Moonlight 369]

For me, it feels that having G5 in the same continuity as G4 is one of the worst and laziest choices ever made in the name of the MLP Franchise.

I don't mean to belittle the good parts of G5, but that sort of opinion seems to be quite common among fans.

Edited July 20, 2022 by Rosy Moonlight

[Evil Pink One 13,506]

DISAPPPPPOOOOOOIIINNNNTTTMMMEEEEENNNTTTT!!!!!