Big Macintosh, pony or horse

[Robojot 152]

big macintosh is he a pony or a horse ?

come with reasonable arguments for why / why not he is a horse.

[pondus30 152]

Pony, because the wiki says so!

 

 

http://mlp.wikia.com/wiki/Big_Macintosh

Edited December 20, 2011 by pondus30

[Robojot 152]

i personaly think he is a pony. beacuse if he is not a pony then he is not in family with AJ.

[Lyra Heartstrings1 53]

HORSE.

[Sunnymilk 40]

Pony because his whole family are ponies. And he is far to short to be a horse (assuming Celestia and Luna are horses)

[Street Comedy 327]

Pony! Durr... :B

[Crispy 5,565]

Pony should pony pony.

 

He's a pony, just an abnormally large and strong one.

[83awsm 234]

Makes sense that he'd be a pony because of the family ties to AJ that were mentioned, plus it’d be a little odd if he were considered a horse when just about all the main and most background characters in ponyville are ponies.

[Anonymous~ 591]

Naah, he's just adopted from a horse family. That would explain his hooves... yes?

[TomokoKuroki 1,707]

I say he's a pony because he has the frame and size of a pony (I personally feel) but as a farmer pony, he's build up some muscle as he tends the feilds and bucks the trees.

 

That is how I see it. Plus there is the relations to the Apple family which is all pony.

[pondus30 152]

Pony should pony pony.

 

He's a pony, just an abnormally large and strong one.

 

eeyup!

[Goodra 533]

He's a stallion like Prince Blueblood because that's what Rarity calls the prince and they have the same body mass.

[Marshmallow 1,137]

Horses and ponies are two completely different species.

There's been no horses in the show so far.

 

Therefore, Big Mac is a pony.

[Lady Rarity Pony 4,894]

The Big Mac (introduced in Pennsylvania in 1967 and nationwide in 1968) is a hamburger sold by McDonalds, an international fast food restaurant chain. It is one of the company's signature products. It consists of two 1.6 oz (45.4 g) beef patties, special "Mac" sauce (a relish variant), iceberg ​lettuce, American cheese, pickles and onions, served in a three part sesame seed bun. Edited December 20, 2011 by Lady Rarity Pony

[Goodra 533]

The Big Mac (introduced in Pennsylvania in 1967 and nationwide in 1968) is a hamburger sold by McDonalds, an international fast food restaurant chain. It is one of the company's signature products. It consists of two 1.6 oz (45.4 g) beef patties, special "Mac" sauce (a relish variant), iceberg ​lettuce, American cheese, pickles and onions, served in a three part sesame seed bun.

ლ(ಠ益ಠლ)

 

lol, ok he's a pony.

 

Eeyup!

[Marshmallow 1,137]

The Big Mac (introduced in Pennsylvania in 1967 and nationwide in 1968) is a hamburger sold by McDonalds, an international fast food restaurant chain. It is one of the company's signature products. It consists of two 1.6 oz (45.4 g) beef patties, special "Mac" sauce (a relish variant), iceberg ​lettuce, American cheese, pickles and onions, served in a three part sesame seed bun.

 

Eeyup. It's clearly a hamburger.

I don't see why anypony would think that it's a horse! :3

[Finesthour 7,289]

He is a pony.

 

Horses are much bigger, and have more definite bodies.

 

His body... is rounded, and more pony like.

[Anonymous~ 591]

He is a pony.

 

Horses are much bigger, and have more definite bodies.

 

His body... is rounded, and more pony like.

 

Y U calling him FAT ? http://mlpforums.com/public/style_emoticons/default/dry.png

[Finesthour 7,289]

 

Y U calling him FAT ? http://mlpforums.com/public/style_emoticons/default/dry.png

 

I am saying his body is round.

 

Not once did I say fat c:

[Marshmallow 1,137]

This is a horse

 

 

 

This is a pony

 

 

 

And this is Big Macintosh

 

 

 

He looks more like the pony to me :3

 

(No seriously, he really is a pony though. For the reasons I said in my first post)

Edited December 20, 2011 by Marshmallow

[Kaela PopTart Patton 1]

im guessing he is a cross between a horse and a pony...

[Anonymous~ 591]

I am saying his body is round.

 

Not once did I say fat c:

 

Oh.... Ok....Good.... But I got My eye on you from now on. so careful

[Finesthour 7,289]

Oh.... Ok....Good.... But I got My eye on you from now on. so careful

 

I would not mind that.

 

Your avatar is gorgeous.

 

And on topic:

 

It is my little pony after all.

 

Why would you have a horse?

c:

[Anonymous~ 591]

I would not mind that.

 

Your avatar is gorgeous.

 

And on topic:

 

It is my little pony after all.

 

Why would you have a horse?

c:

 

Awwwww, Thanks. Yuor avatar is cute too. PP ftw. :3

 

And indeed, you got a point there. It's MLP after all.

[ggg-2 3,555]

he's a pony, that just so happens to have the feet (and strength) of a clydesdale