Jump to content
Banner by ~ Wizard

Is Mrs. Cake a cheater?


SuperUltimateBrony

Recommended Posts

Mrs. Cake in My Little Pony FIM cheated on her husband and bore the children of either a pegasus or a unicorn while her husband is normal pony. Not only did he get nervous at the development, but the other 6 main characters also found it highly strange and unusual enough so to question it.

MLP is showing cuckolding.

 

However,

Mr. Cakes explanation is still perfectly valid. If the mystery stallion that knocked up Mrs. Cake was a unicorn, where did the pegasus foal come from? And vice versa if the stallion had been a pegasus, and yet somehow helped to make a unicorn.

As questionable as pony genetics might be, the whole "Mrs. Cake is a cheater" thing only works if one accepts that said questionable genetics are true, in which case there's little reason to assume that Mr. Cakes isn't the father if any pony can hold the genetic ancestry of more than one race.

I know the whole nervousness of his explanation is meant to be a joke about how two earth ponies somehow made a unicorn and pegasus, but it could just as easily be a jab at fans who ask super serious questions about pony reproduction and this was the show's way of saying "don't think about it too hard".

  • Brohoof 3

Loading signature......

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 2013-01-07 at 9:46 AM, SuperUltimateBrony said:

Mrs. Cake in My Little Pony FIM cheated on her husband and bore the children of either a pegasus or a unicorn while her husband is normal pony. Not only did he get nervous at the development, but the other 6 main characters also found it highly strange and unusual enough so to question it.

 

MLP is showing cuckolding.

 

However,

 

Mr. Cakes explanation is still perfectly valid. If the mystery stallion that knocked up Mrs. Cake was a unicorn, where did the pegasus foal come from? And vice versa if the stallion had been a pegasus, and yet somehow helped to make a unicorn.

 

As questionable as pony genetics might be, the whole "Mrs. Cake is a cheater" thing only works if one accepts that said questionable genetics are true, in which case there's little reason to assume that Mr. Cakes isn't the father if any pony can hold the genetic ancestry of more than one race.

 

I know the whole nervousness of his explanation is meant to be a joke about how two earth ponies somehow made a unicorn and pegasus, but it could just as easily be a jab at fans who ask super serious questions about pony reproduction and this was the show's way of saying "don't think about it too hard".

 

Mr. Cake already explained perfectly how they had Pegasus and Unicorn children silly, don't you remember the episode where Pinkie Pie babysat them? She didn't cheat at all. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 2013-01-07 at 9:46 AM, SuperUltimateBrony said:

Mrs. Cake in My Little Pony FIM cheated on her husband and bore the children of either a pegasus or a unicorn while her husband is normal pony. Not only did he get nervous at the development, but the other 6 main characters also found it highly strange and unusual enough so to question it.

 

MLP is showing cuckolding.

 

However,

 

Mr. Cakes explanation is still perfectly valid. If the mystery stallion that knocked up Mrs. Cake was a unicorn, where did the pegasus foal come from? And vice versa if the stallion had been a pegasus, and yet somehow helped to make a unicorn.

 

As questionable as pony genetics might be, the whole "Mrs. Cake is a cheater" thing only works if one accepts that said questionable genetics are true, in which case there's little reason to assume that Mr. Cakes isn't the father if any pony can hold the genetic ancestry of more than one race.

 

I know the whole nervousness of his explanation is meant to be a joke about how two earth ponies somehow made a unicorn and pegasus, but it could just as easily be a jab at fans who ask super serious questions about pony reproduction and this was the show's way of saying "don't think about it too hard".

 

I was hoping that this kinda of topic ended. Still I am going to do my best to show you are wrong.

 

First off Mr. Cake explains that he had a unicorn family member on his side and Mrs. Cake has a pegasus family member on her side of the family. Traits can appear at anytime for families.

 

Next, have you looked at Carrot Cake and Pumpkin Cake

mlp.s02e13.cakes_.png

 

As you can see Carrot Cake and Pumpkin Cake have many similarities. 

For example.

Both have the same mane color.

Their coats are similar in color. Carrot seems to have a organ coat, while Pumpkin has a light organ coat.

Even their tales are the same design. 

 

Now it is true that Pound Cake does not have any traits from either parent. The only one he got was the pegasus jean that is on Mrs. Cakes side. Still it is shown not all baby ponies are going to look like their parents. 

 

This may not be a lot, but I feel like this is plenty of info to show Mrs. Cake did not cheat on Mr. Cake.


img-1202916-1-9nQUab7.png

Made by Gone ϟ Airbourne

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 2013-01-07 at 9:46 AM, SuperUltimateBrony said:

OP

 

:huh: Wait, I'm confused.  Are you or aren't you saying that Mrs. Cake cheated on Mr. Cake?  Mr. Cake already explained why Pound Cake and Pumpkin Cake are a pegasus and unicorn, and if the show's producers chose to make them a pegasus and unicorn for any reason, it was solely so that they'd cause even more trouble for Pinkie Pie when she babysat them.

Edited by Batbrony
  • Brohoof 2

CDFuh.gif

"You'll hunt me. You'll condemn me, set the dogs on me. Because that's what needs to happen. Because sometimes... cupcakes aren't good enough. Sometimes ponies deserve more. Sometimes ponies deserve to have their faith rewarded... with muffins!!!"

-The Muffin Mare

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well normally genetics show up even from much earlier relatives I think. Plus it was explained as that way, I guess it is a bit strange with the way it was said, but Pumpkin and Poundcake represent their parents pretty well.

 

Plus I think it would've been pretty obvious to the both of them once they saw the children, so I doubt it would've gone unnoticed.

 

Childbirth (Or in this case fillybirth) Is a bit of a dark thing for a show like MLP, and being cheated on like that is even darker, so obviously I don't know if it would've been intended anyways seeing as that wouldn't have made sense.

 

So I don't think there was any cheating involved, their explanation while nervous seems to make sense. And they bare resemblance to their parents pretty well.

  • Brohoof 1

Ru8aWjK.png

Thanks to Gone Airbourne for the awesome sig!

My Oc's,

Ponysona, Bella

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't really get why people think Mrs. Cake cheated on her husband. I seriously doubt it and the fact the kids are both a pegasus and unicorn despite their parents being Earth Ponies  proves nothing. Genetics is completely different in Equestria so stop trying to compare our genetics with theirs as the hold little similarities. Sure Pound cake looks nothing like his parents big deal who's to say foals have to look like their parents?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 2013-01-07 at 9:46 AM, SuperUltimateBrony said:

Mrs. Cake in My Little Pony FIM cheated on her husband and bore the children of either a pegasus or a unicorn while her husband is normal pony. Not only did he get nervous at the development, but the other 6 main characters also found it highly strange and unusual enough so to question it.

 

MLP is showing cuckolding.

 

However,

 

Mr. Cakes explanation is still perfectly valid. If the mystery stallion that knocked up Mrs. Cake was a unicorn, where did the pegasus foal come from? And vice versa if the stallion had been a pegasus, and yet somehow helped to make a unicorn.

 

As questionable as pony genetics might be, the whole "Mrs. Cake is a cheater" thing only works if one accepts that said questionable genetics are true, in which case there's little reason to assume that Mr. Cakes isn't the father if any pony can hold the genetic ancestry of more than one race.

 

I know the whole nervousness of his explanation is meant to be a joke about how two earth ponies somehow made a unicorn and pegasus, but it could just as easily be a jab at fans who ask super serious questions about pony reproduction and this was the show's way of saying "don't think about it too hard".

Well no they explained it with the recessive traits to make it perfectly normal (though adding in the "right?" made it adult humor hidden among the innocence.) But there is always the chance of that being the case, though highly unlikely, but I think we know who the most likely culprit is.

9e7d452f08b02cc70e986965449d10df977e1fee

  • Brohoof 3

eeyore_by_joshuawickett-d7otl2o.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 2013-01-08 at 4:56 AM, Rainbow Dashey said:

Well no they explained it with the recessive traits to make it perfectly normal (though adding in the "right?" made it adult humor hidden among the innocence.) But there is always the chance of that being the case, though highly unlikely, but I think we know who the most likely culprit is.

9e7d452f08b02cc70e986965449d10df977e1fee

I must agree on the Molestia thing there...

tumblr_ly2h1tLGuq1r3xauuo1_500.png

 

Now ever since seeing this image I now have the head cannon that Molestia and the Cakes had a three-way...

And somehow Mares in the show can get other Mares Pregnant 0_o

  • Brohoof 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Everypony here is going always for the worst willed reasons. There is a total logical explanation that goes through all this misunderstanding and left the always untouchable honor of the mare intact. Lets take the theory, just theory, that:

  • Mr. Cake is in fact sterile.
  • Both love each other too much and he is terrible devastated for not being able to fufill his duties as a male.
  • Ms Cake want to have their own foals not adopt ones.
  • They go for a medical solution and they both get to choose what kind of kids they have.
  • Magically Ms Cake got to carry both foals. Because buck it is a cartoon show
  • That’s why Mr Cake is so nervous about his explanation he doesn’t want to everypony know his terrible nut cracking secret.

 

So there you go…BOOM CONCLUSION!!!  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There is only one true way of finding this out! Let's get them to the Maury Povich show!

 

Maury: Mr.Cake, you ARE the father!

 

But nah, I doubt that either of them cheated, but rather their ancestors just had a bit of pegasus/unicorn/ *alicorn fever.

 

 

 

* wow Celestia and Mr. Cake!? That has FimFiction.com written all over it!


Check me out! No, seriously, check me out.


Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree that Mr. Cake's explanation was delivered nervously, perhaps as a tongue-in-cheek thing that would go over the heads of younger viewers, but that's it. My Little Pony is not going to depict marital infidelity.

Edited by TailsAlone
  • Brohoof 1

"Human beings fascinate me

Being just the way they are..."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm sure that Mr. Cake explained this in the beginning of the episode.

 

Something about his great-great-great-great-great grandfather being a unicycle. 

 

Let's see who gets the reference.

  • Brohoof 1

ShyForever5_zps283bbbec.png
 


 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 2013-01-07 at 9:46 AM, SuperUltimateBrony said:

I know the whole nervousness of his explanation is meant to be a joke about how two earth ponies somehow made a unicorn and pegasus, but it could just as easily be a jab at fans who ask super serious questions about pony reproduction and this was the show's way of saying "don't think about it too hard".

Precisely.

 

Within the creation of new characters like that, the only way that they could create the drama necessary is having a bit of a "fantastic baby". If it was only a boring little creature just like a regular baby, then there would be an episode that's already been done a dozen times before. But add magic and flying, ho, that's a new story.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hopefully Equestria has no equivalent of things like the KKK or the Nation of Islam.  If they did, they'd boycott the Cake's bakery because of the "race mixing" in their family. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Science Show!

 

  Reveal hidden contents

 

EXPLAINED!


"You really are fond of chatting with me, aren't you? If I didn't know better, I'd think you had feelings for me!" Solaire of Astora.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Its just long line genetics like I have a lot of ginger in my beard but my mother has dark brown hair and my fathers is black. my uncle on my mothers side also gets ginger in his beard so the D.N.A that causes my beard to be ginger came from my grandfather not my mum or dad. hence the reason 2 earth ponys can give birth to a pegasus and a unicorn because genetics are a thing... wow science can be dull.

  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 2013-01-09 at 5:27 AM, Blindshot Predator said:

I'm sure that Mr. Cake explained this in the beginning of the episode.

 

Something about his great-great-great-great-great grandfather being a unicycle.

 

Let's see who gets the reference.

How come one a' them's a pig and the other's John Redcorn?

That's easy! My grer-grer-grer-grer-grer grandfather was a unicycle!

And my father's nephews's brother's former roomate was a grandfather.

*gasp* Two new foals for me to [ ] with? That's-- *gasp* *gasp* That's two two TWO two two TWO two TWO times the FUN!!!

 

Oh my God, Pinkie Pie Discovers Roast Chicken is my favorite pony YTP. Pingascake and Poundcom.

 

But on topic, yeah, Mr. Cake explained it. His nervousness and "That makes sense, right?" was just lampshading the improbable odds that such babies would be born rather than two earth ponies.

Edited by Pumpkinbot
  • Brohoof 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
  On 2013-01-08 at 4:59 AM, CrazyClay said:

I must agree on the Molestia thing there...

img-1063929-2-tumblr_ly2h1tLGuq1r3xauuo1

 

Now ever since seeing this image I now have the head cannon that Molestia and the Cakes had a three-way...

And somehow Mares in the show can get other Mares Pregnant 0_o

 

Or there is a more likely explanation. If you will allow me?

 

Mr. Cakes impregnated them both.

 

Given that one of the twins matches his mane and body color, Mr. Cakes definately was the male genetic donor. Given that 2/3 of the party were female, it isn't much of a stretch to say that he may have shot more than once. What's a deity to do with a bun in the oven? Why, teleport the little fellow into the womb of someone who is already carrying their half-sibling anyway.

 

Would explain the lustful eye Molestia kept giving Mr. Cakes....

 

So yeah. Mr. Cakes as stud to the gods....who knew!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 2013-01-07 at 9:50 AM, Alex-Kennedy said:

There is no infidelity in My Little Pony. Never. That implies all sorts of things I don't want to think about in the context of the show.

"Because I don't want to see anything like it, that automatically means it never has nor ever will happen."

 

Seriously, people, if it happens, it happens wether you want it to or not so quit your whining! Seriously!

Twilicorn happened despite the protests and FOR SOME REASON THAT IS EXTREMELY STRANGE, ODD AND OTHER SIMILAR WORDS, the show continues and life goes on. Same goes for equestria girls.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 5 months later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Join the herd!

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...