Scariest Creepypasta Monster?

[Sugar Pea 2,682]

If you need have any scary, or at the least creepy pastas you would like me to add, please comment below. Or if you are willing to give a background story for these creepypastas, let me know :3

Edited May 8, 2013 by Candy Celebration

[WarGrowlmon1990 94]

I'd say that in terms of scariness, the Rake and Slenderman are tied. Rake does look a bit scarier though due to his claws and black eyes. Slendy is scary in terms of the psychological mind fuck that he puts his victims through, but in terms of physical appearance, he isn't all that scary looking. I'd be more afraid of him possessing me and killing my fiance and baby than his overall appearance. Another creepypasta monster that scares me is Bubby the clown. 

 

http://creepypasta.wikia.com/wiki/Bubby_the_Clown

Edited May 7, 2013 by WarGrowlmon1990

[Cuhpcakes 15]

Slenderman hands down! I was terrified of that diety for weeks, so scared I was always watching my back at night.

 

However, I don't fear anything for more than a couple hours. CreepyPasta is completely fake, well some stories may be true; but; some stories are just obviously made up. Hypno's Lullaby was rather interesting.

[Thrashy 2,800]

I honestly never thought Slenderman, the Rake or Jeff were that scary at all. The scariest creepypastas to me are those that actually could be true, so for me it came down to a choice between Mr. Mix and Smile.dog, and ultimately I chose the former.

[Aeon Of Dreams 115]

The lack of SCP Foundation disturbs me...

 

But out of all these I am not totally sure, seeing as I tend to love Slenderman stuff more then get terrified by it. Jeff the Killer can't be taken seriously after you see this.

 

[Celtore 2,770]

It was really down to squidward or smile dog. The squidward's suicide creepypasta was incredibly difficult to read and was deeply disturbing. Smile dog just scares me, I mean, just look at it! The story does feel a little cheesy though I will admit.

 

Slenderman and jeff have both become rather cliche in my opinion (plus Cabadath is a heck of a lot more scary than slenderman) and I just can't find them scary anymore.

Edited May 7, 2013 by Celtore

[Skeletor Brony 703]

The only Creepypasta I was ever scared of was Jeff the killer. But after I saw that Go To Potato pic, I just laughed at him.

#GiggleAtTheGhosties

[Jokuc 8,173]

Neither of them. I never read creepypastas anyways. Horror movies is the way to go you know.

 

Anyways.. I'd say the one at the top. Jeff.

 

 

 

But this guy from Pan's Labyrinth is so much sexier

 

 

 

[Thrashy 2,800]

 

 

The lack of SCP Foundation disturbs me...

You know, I was going to say the same thing. Even if SCP-173 was the only option, that'd still be scarier than the trio of lameness known as Slendy/Jeffy/Rakey.

 

...And yeah, that pic kind of destroys all of Jeff's cred, I must say.

[Cocodrillo 1,565]

I don't know all of them, but from what I know it's Jeff the Killer.

Thank you for posting his face, anyway. I saw it when I scrolled down..Oh well.

[angrysalamence 49]

I say Pinkamena, after playing the Luna game... Never again will I be able to play a platform game without remembering that game...

 

Also, Slenderman is not scary, he is misunderstood. I read this 'creepypasta' about an orpan in who was poor and suffering. On a winter day, he started getting a headache, and there, he saw Slendie. Slendie got closer, and closer, whilst the child's headache got worse, until he blanked out. He later woke up, he looked outside, and he saw a car. He ran downstairs, and there were his parents. He spoke 'Thank you...'

 

This is why I believe Slenderman is a good guy, helping the poor and giving them better lives. =)

[FoxyCryptid 4,330]

If any of you people are afraid of Jeff, you've never seen the narmful nightmare retardant that is FurBearingBrick's Jeff headcannon(complete with fangirlish pictures)

 

But I can't make fun of her to much because she's the head admin of the Pasta wiki and I don't want to get banned... 

[Cuhpcakes 15]

Neither of them. I never read creepypastas anyways. Horror movies is the way to go you know.

 

Anyways.. I'd say the one at the top. Jeff.

 

 

 

But this guy from Pan's Labyrinth is so much sexier

 

 

 

Yeah, I feels you bro. Creepypastas are just too bizarre and irrational to actually have me believe any of them. Some stories show quite an interesting sense of creativity, but still lack creditable evidence or proof.

[Aeon Of Dreams 115]

You know, I was going to say the same thing. Even if SCP-173 was the only option, that'd still be scarier than the trio of lameness known as Slendy/Jeffy/Rakey.

 

...And yeah, that pic kind of destroys all of Jeff's cred, I must say.

Admittedly the SCP that has thus far terrified me the most was SCP-087. Rather impressive considering I discovered it from watching an "11 drunk guys" playthrough.

Edited May 7, 2013 by The Oneiromancer

[Rotatingllama 5]

I believe that the scariest one for me is Jeff, because I've seen many animations/Screamers with him in... Im not so good with jumpscares

[Stellafera 3,836]

SCP Foundation wins it for me easily. Usually, I end up really enjoying the stuff I find out about on TV Tropes.

 

I clicked on a link to that website.

 

 

It was night.

 

 

I was alone.

 

 

I will never be able to look at the word [REDACTED] again.

 

[-BleachedOne- 233]

I...was actually just a tad bit chilled to the bone about the whole Zelda BEN story. Seriously. Majora's Mask to this day remains one of my favorite videogames of all time (if not THE most) and the whole storyline behind the haunted Elegy statue just...*shudder*

 

I realize it was just a glitched out game, but man, the first time I heard the Song of Healing backwards, I felt a chill run up my spine. I think BEN deserves just a little bit of recognition.