if i may, twilights not exactly princess material.

[Flight 11 89]

-snip-

I... don't even know why or how, but I like it.

[FNGRpony 658]

I... don't even know why or how, but I like it.

it's the definitive snip i'll tell you that much.

[Sunny Fox 5,952]

....on risk of sounding terribly smug

mind telling me on the moon where royal princess school is?

 

I'm not quite sure what you mean here. I agree that Luna has had LESS time to learn how to be a Princess than Celestia, precisely because she was banished to the moon for 1000 years.

[FNGRpony 658]

I'm not quite sure what you mean here. I agree that Luna has had LESS time to learn how to be a Princess than Celestia, precisely because she was banished to the moon for 1000 years.

I didn't think to make that argument until you said "she had over a 1000 years to get good at being a princess,"

 

and honestly... she kinda didn't.  I didn't even notice it till i had to think about it.  What could she have learned up there?

1

there's nothing there

2

she wasn't in control of her body to learn it if there was.

[Sunny Fox 5,952]

I didn't think to make that argument until you said "she had over a 1000 years to get good at being a princess,"

 

and honestly... she kinda didn't.  I didn't even notice it till i had to think about it.  What could she have learned up there?

1

there's nothing there

2

she wasn't in control of her body to learn it if there was.

Ah, I see now. Well, what I meant is that we don't truly know how old Celestia and Luna are. They might have had many years or thousands of years as rulers before Luna became Nightmare Moon to learn the art of being Princess. Indeed, the fact that their castle is called The Castle of the Royal Pony Sisters and that it has a number of childish gag traps built in, implies that they were already princesses for a while before we see them in the flashbacks in "Princess Twilight Sparkle". There is also no way of knowing how many years come between the flashback of beating Discord and the one with the creation of NMM.

Edited December 9, 2013 by SolarFox

[FNGRpony 658]

Ah, I see now. Well, what I meant is that we don't truly know how old Celestia and Luna are. They might have had many years or thousands of years as rulers before Luna became Nightmare Moon to learn the art of being Princess. Indeed, the fact that their castle is called The Castle of the Royal Pony Sisters and that it has a number of childish gag traps built in, implies that they were already princesses for a while before we see them in the flashbacks in "Princess Twilight Sparkle". There is also no way of knowing how many years come between the flashback of beating Discord and the one with the creation of NMM.

 

Again with totally respect,

you keep digging a bigger hole,

 

a castle filled with childish gags and traps.  It's highly possible Celestail and luna might have been immature and very unprincess like in their youth.

Which would explain the head canon that Celestail use to be friends with discord at some point and time, but lets not open that can of worms up (Yet)

It's highly possible after banishing her sister, and only than Celestail had to harden herself from practical joker to serious ruler.

 

Damn now i suddenly feel bad for her.  keep in mind when i said luna I stated "I assumed" she was princess like because it was the only reasonable explanation.

 

after having this discussion, you've kinda opened an alternative spin.

 

I mean yes luna talks the talk (the canterlot speech)

but like she never makes any royal decisions.

Edited December 9, 2013 by FNGRpony

[Sunny Fox 5,952]

Again with totally respect,

you keep digging a bigger hole,

 

a castle filled with childish gags and traps.  It's highly possible Celestail and luna might have been immature and very unprincess like in their youth.

Which would explain the head canon that Celestail use to be friends with discord at some point and time, but lets not open that can of worms up (Yet)

It's highly possible after banishing her sister, and only than Celestail had to harden herself from practical joker to serious ruler.

 

Damn now i suddenly feel bad for her.  keep in mind when i said luna I stated "I assumed" she was princess like because it was the only reasonable explanation.

 

after having this discussion, you've kinda opened an alternative spin.

 

I mean yes luna talks the talk (the canterlot speech)

but like she never makes any royal decisions.

 

My point is simply this. If Luna has had X years to learn being a Princess, Celestia has had X+1000 years. X could be in the range of millions of years itself, we just don't know until more is revealed about the timeline. QED. Anything else you think I'm saying, I'm probably not.

[UserNotFound 964]

But she does help people... She helped Scootaloo in her dreams... I think the reason why we don't see so much of Luna is because she's the princess of the night and most of the massive pony events take place in the daytime... Plus she turned on her sister as NMM... It may take a while for the ponies of Equestria to trust her again... Like on nightmare night... It was all about gaining trust... And understanding them...

[FNGRpony 658]

 

My point is simply this. If Luna has had X years to learn being a Princess, Celestia has had X+1000 years. X could be in the range of millions of years itself, we just don't know until more is revealed about the timeline. QED. Anything else you think I'm saying, I'm probably not.

 

Your being the inspiration to thought i hadn't considered as a viable path.

My point A was

FNGR

"princess knows how to be a luna because what else would she be."

Solar fox

"back when luna was a practical joker."

FNGR

",,,,,, go on."

 

All i heard in that episode was "trap door slide" and than never got to see it.  It went over my head on what that might have implied.  The juvenile immature luna till than (And it went over my head) was the work of fanon.

I like what your cooking,

 

namely because i'm starving for luna content LOL.

But she does help people... She helped Scootaloo in her dreams... I think the reason why we don't see so much of Luna is because she's the princess of the night and most of the massive pony events take place in the daytime... Plus she turned on her sister as NMM... It may take a while for the ponies of Equestria to trust her again... Like on nightmare night... It was all about gaining trust... And understanding them...

Now i'm about to suggestion something and it's not a dig.  in nightmare night and in scoots dreams she helping out and interacting with kids.

 

it's a likeable trait.  (might be part of the inspiration for that children of the night video 

 

but that's having an affinity for philies.

 

heh sounds like a column, not necessary a royal thing.  it is cool.

 

I mean day one alicorn pinkie pie would just as easily be doing all those same things that luna helped with.

0 training.

Edited December 9, 2013 by FNGRpony

[Gary S. 102]

Twilight will get used to it. She already learned to give orders to guards. ;-) So far she doesn't feel less princess material than Cadance to me, because you never saw her around with a scepter or something as example. The pony nobles look like sycophants. They won't ever disrespect Twilight to the level they want to overthrow her. Im sure there won't be much trouble.

 

Ah, besides i got it now. At least all this misspelling of names does affect your disliked ponies only. Though it still gives me a headache.

[Nerdy Luigi 2,065]

I was reading this, and I was like: "Dude, like, what is like going on right now? *tokes on doobie*"

 

So, Twilight Sparkle is not princess material? I say HOOPLA! Twilight Sparkle's main goal in life was to destroy level 70 charcoal and rescue the propane mistress from the evil castle of the Home Depot.

 

Twilight Sparkle worked hard in her career at Menards as Glass Cleaner. And she deserves to be the fuckin' Princess of Glass Cleaner. I mean really guys. If Twilight Sparkle wasn't the Princess of Glass Cleaner, how could we clean the windows on our houses, our vehicles, our Grandmother's face, our propane tanks and most importantly, our doorknobs!

 

I mean, seriously. If there is no Princess of Glass Cleaner, there is nobody to control how the great liquid of glass cleaner is used among our wonderful society! Without the proper distribution of glass cleaner, the world would slowly crumble and send us all into a spiraling downfall which will eventually suck us all in and basically eat us alive.

 

I cannot imagine a world without Twilight Sparkle as our wondrous Princess of Glass cleaner. I mean really, if she didn't do it, who would? Fuckin' Fluttershy? Hell no. Fluttershy would really fuck shit up. I mean really, Fluttershy would pretty much destroy the whole free world if she had her hands on the magical abilities that glass cleaner can inflict.

 

I say yes, on with  Twilight and on with Glass Cleaner!

Here we go with the princess of Glass cleaner again. It's like Dale except not as funny and fanon.

[FNGRpony 658]

Twilight will get used to it. She already learned to give orders to guards. ;-) So far she doesn't feel less princess material than Cadance to me, because you never saw her around with a scepter or something as example. The pony nobles look like sycophants. They won't ever disrespect Twilight to the level they want to overthrow her. Im sure there won't be much trouble.

 

Ah, besides i got it now. At least all this misspelling of names does affect your disliked ponies only. Though it still gives me a headache.

 

no.  That's a fantastic head canon.  Oh my God i'm important enough to have a head canon about.  woot.  I have shittie spelling.

I like candice (or how ever it's spelled).

I like the main villain from Daring don't.

 

I'm not even gonna attempt to write that nightmare of a name. (owwie zodo)?

but not your not the first (or last) person to suggest my typoes are a troll  They are not.  It's been tried back words and forwards in several forums,

i just have shitty spelling

 

and me being ammused at you being bothered by my typos is me handeling it politely.

 

the alternative is to get offended and come at you for being a dick.

Edited December 9, 2013 by FNGRpony

[Gary S. 102]

Okay, it's a bit hard to believe that Twilight Sparkle is easier to spell than Cadance, but if that's really so, then i'm sorry.

 

 

Oh well, therefore my grammar is often shittier.  ;-)

[UserNotFound 964]

What about Celestia? You always put an L on her name xD not exactly the hardest name to spell xD

 

Anyway... I think that different types of princess are needed in Equestria... There's my two bits

[King Sejong 859]

   Very few, if anyone is ruler material, whether it's noble or common, historical or fictional, we chose and support our leaders to represent and speak on public issues, at least for those who are active in politics, however there is more to higher position than politicking, a leader is also the figurehead of the nation, keeping up with appearances can be as difficult as legislature. While I was in the navy, we had a lot of COs and NCOs that were promoted beyond their initial ability, they had to learn over time how to lead by example, they had to do a lot of watching, as to learn their job then teach the person below them in rank, whether it's the Equestria, the military or ordinary life, we are not leadership material, not in human or nature, a wolf pup does not grow up knowing how to be alpha, it's through trial and error they assume the position when the time comes, Twilight Sparkle may not be princess material, but that depends on what you think is princess material, or what your ability to inspire those to lead, and that is the goal of good leadership.   

Edited December 9, 2013 by Emperor Peter

[FNGRpony 658]

Okay, it's a bit hard to believe that Twilight Sparkle is easier to spell than Cadance, but if that's really so, then i'm sorry.

 

 

Oh well, therefore my grammar is often shittier.  ;-)

twilight

and sparkle are two fairly common words.  unless you practice music Cadance, (which by the way firfox is showing your spelling as in correct, i don't know) is not.

 

just cause the name is long doesn't make it harder, if that long name is made up of easy words.

What about Celestia? You always put an L on her name xD not exactly the hardest name to spell xD

 

Anyway... I think that different types of princess are needed in Equestria... There's my two bits

I could start calling her tia so you leave me alone,

but her fans call her tia and I would not want to give the wrong impresion.

Normally i would sound it out

Sell Es ti uh.

so flip the S to a Cellestia (i know it's not spelled with a uh at the end so it's partially memory.  the typo is not a troll.

a troll would be calling her molestail, or trollestai).

 

oh?  why types are there?

[Noodles 109]

Princess Twilight has the core of a good princess, she need a long way to go to effectively rule.

she can take command when needed but she really need to get over or learn to cover her insecurities I believe she can do the right thing for the Lands but have a very hard time getting everypony behind her. she lacks grace under.. heck she lacks grace. so currently she really is not a overall good princess. but becoming one would be a great thing for the final season.

 

for now she is our Lovable award paranoid Twi. and face it most of us would not want it any other way.

[UserNotFound 964]

Well when I look at the royal family of my country, although they don't hold any political power... They all vary in their roles and personalities... Prince William's wife, Kate is different to her mother in law, Prince Charles's wife, Camilla... Diana was different to Camilla and the queen... And the queen was different to all her daughters and granddaughters and her mother too... They all have parts of our community that they wish to establish... For example the duchess of Cornwall established literacy awards for helping raise literacy skills... They all aim to help the community in some way.. They just do it differently... Same with the princesses... Celestia pretty much has the ruling of Canterlot and the majority of Equestria covered... She delegates roles to her sister, niece and I'm sure now to twilight as well... For when she can't be in two places at once... They are all important... For if celestia fell for whatever reason... They would step up to the plate to help maintain harmony in Equestria...

[Chevette 1,052]

Here we go with the princess of Glass cleaner again. It's like Dale except not as funny and fanon.

 

Ouch man. That burns... 

 

You are over there accusing my post of being not funny? Well, I'm glad you got whats going down, home dawg. I was trying to get a serious point across and I definitely couldn't do that with humor.

The fandom must know how Twilight's royal authority over glass cleaner could have either made or broke Equestria.

 

This is no laughing matter, sir.

[Scootalove 10,689]

Twilight has a long way to go but, she has shown she is able to take charge and be able to handle leadership. It's usually hard to try to adjust when it comes to learning about leadership, Twilight does have some schedule and being able to handle issues that might cause some issues, I think that Twilight is as important as the other princesses when it comes to maintaining harmony.

[Princess Lona 382]

Maybe Twilight's lack of poise and courtly demeanour was part of Celestia's plan all along. We still don't know what Twilight is going to be princess of, but I could take a wild guess and say...friendship? Or something like it. And if she's going to represent friendship for all of Equestria, she has to be amicable. The major drawback of "normal" royal behaviour is that it can separate the royalty from their subjects. (see "Luna Eclipsed"). Even if a princess is well beloved by the people, if she is put too high up on a pedestal, they can have trouble relating to her or feeling comfortable around her like a true friend (see the Cakes' treatment of Celestia in "A Bird in the Hoof"). As Princess of Friendship, it is absolutely necessary that Twilight not act like typical royalty. Celestia did say in the season 3 finale that Twilight had created new magic. Perhaps that new magic will be reflected in her style of princessing.

 

Side note, I think when people spell "Celestia" like "Celestial", it's because "celestia" isn't a word but "celestial" is. Darn spellchecker!

[Yamato 1,348]

Here we go with the princess of Glass cleaner again. It's like Dale except not as funny and fanon.

 

Dude, that's like totally not groovy, bro...

[Nerdy Luigi 2,065]

Ouch man. That burns... 

 

You are over there accusing my post of being not funny? Well, I'm glad you got whats going down, home dawg. I was trying to get a serious point across and I definitely couldn't do that with humor.

The fandom must know how Twilight's royal authority over glass cleaner could have either made or broke Equestria.

 

This is no laughing matter, sir.

Not exactly what I said. I said NOT AS. It still was pretty funny.

[FNGRpony 658]

Maybe Twilight's lack of poise and courtly demeanour was part of Celestia's plan all along. We still don't know what Twilight is going to be princess of, but I could take a wild guess and say...friendship? Or something like it. And if she's going to represent friendship for all of Equestria, she has to be amicable. The major drawback of "normal" royal behaviour is that it can separate the royalty from their subjects. (see "Luna Eclipsed"). Even if a princess is well beloved by the people, if she is put too high up on a pedestal, they can have trouble relating to her or feeling comfortable around her like a true friend (see the Cakes' treatment of Celestia in "A Bird in the Hoof"). As Princess of Friendship, it is absolutely necessary that Twilight not act like typical royalty. Celestia did say in the season 3 finale that Twilight had created new magic. Perhaps that new magic will be reflected in her style of princessing.

 

Side note, I think when people spell "Celestia" like "Celestial", it's because "celestia" isn't a word but "celestial" is. Darn spellchecker!

 

I think we have a winner.`  Well played sir.

[TailsIsNotAlone 3,696]

Basically I agree. I don't think Twilight would have answered "princess" to the "what do you want to be when you grow up?" question, even right before the change. I think it would have been better to make her a prime minister, or a scientist, or a royal scholar or sorcerer like Starswirl the Bearded. As things stand now, she's basically Equestria's President Pro Tempore, who takes over when Celestia and Luna are both unavailable, but otherwise she's not doing much of importance in the castle, and she's certainly no diplomat or politician.

 

But if we keep lamenting what might have been with Twilight's character, we'll never appreciate the good things that are being done with her post-S3. Let's see what she can make out of this.