Least Favorite Brony reviewer

[WsConanRoyal 63]

I added TBBBAP. I don't know how I forgot them, lol

[(MARVEL) Blue Blood 991]

Digibrony is just totally pretentious, arrogant, and elitist, as well as boring and honestly, he just talks out of his ass. I'm kind of glad he's gone (at least, I heard he was) because he was really a rotten fella. 

I think Digi is past his prime. I remember when he used to make some pretty interesting videos, like the age differences between the Mane 6, and was one of my favorite reviewers for a while. Season 4 is when his prime fell. I couldn't help but feel that he started to get tired of reviewing, and if that's all he needs, that's fine. 

[WsConanRoyal 63]

Also, I'm glad to see no one put me on this, lol

[LZRD WZRD 1,929]

I think another big problem is reviewers choosing to review EVERY episode. What you end up with is a lot of boring, uninspired reviews or completely over-the-top nitpicky rants. Some, like MrEnter, can do this because they have an engaging format and keep it short if there's not a lot to say. However, most cannot and this is why I think people should only review episodes they feel passionately about (either them being bad or good).

[WsConanRoyal 63]

I think another big problem is reviewers choosing to review EVERY episode. What you end up with is a lot of boring, uninspired reviews or completely over-the-top nitpicky rants. Some, like MrEnter, can do this because they have an engaging format and keep it short if there's not a lot to say. However, most cannot and this is why I think people should only review episodes they feel passionately about (either them being bad or good).

 

I never tend to have a problem with reviewers who do every episode. I rarely find them getting "boring" or "uninspired". And rarely do I ever hear any "over-the-top nitpicky rants". To be honest, the ONLY review I've ever actually disliked was Tommy Oliver's Equestria Girls review. Not because he didn't like it (and I consider it one of my all-time favorite movies), but because he just didn't seem like the same reviewer. He went from respectable, professional, and collected to severely one-sided rage and ranting. It was TOO biased and hateful. It's funny considering he's one of my favorite reviewers overall, lol.

[FoxyCryptid 4,330]

He's not "officially" an MLP reviewer but I'm going to bend the rules and say Chad Rocco because he bitches about the show enough on his Twitter and Tumblr to be an honorary one. 

 

Not only does make horrible criticisms, but he's directly attacked the shows staff and accused anyone that liked season 3 onward of "ruining the show" and being everything wrong with the community. 

 

He's usually very well spoken, mature, and rational in reviewing but that all flies out the window and he starts acting like a fanbrat whenever he talks about MLP. 
 

[Moved to Elsewhere 11,331]

I never tend to have a problem with reviewers who do every episode. I rarely find them getting "boring" or "uninspired". And rarely do I ever hear any "over-the-top nitpicky rants". To be honest, the ONLY review I've ever actually disliked was Tommy Oliver's Equestria Girls review. Not because he didn't like it (and I consider it one of my all-time favorite movies), but because he just didn't seem like the same reviewer. He went from respectable, professional, and collected to severely one-sided rage and ranting. It was TOO biased and hateful. It's funny considering he's one of my favorite reviewers overall, lol.

I'm just curious since I didn't watch it, what was so biased about it

He's not "officially" an MLP reviewer but I'm going to bend the rules and say Chad Rocco because he bitches about the show enough on his Twitter and Tumblr to be an honorary one. 

 

Not only does make horrible criticisms, but he's directly attacked the shows staff and accused anyone that liked season 3 onward of "ruining the show" and being everything wrong with the community. 

 

He's usually very well spoken, mature, and rational in reviewing but that all flies out the window and he starts acting like a fanbrat whenever he talks about MLP. 

 

I'm curious what some of his criticisms were on episodes. Like some examples

[WsConanRoyal 63]

I'm just curious since I didn't watch it, what was so biased about it

 

It was complete one-sided hatred of it. He only seemed to go off of that and not even try to look at all the good in it.

[KokuraiNoSenshi 3,465]

I think another big problem is reviewers choosing to review EVERY episode. What you end up with is a lot of boring, uninspired reviews or completely over-the-top nitpicky rants. Some, like MrEnter, can do this because they have an engaging format and keep it short if there's not a lot to say. However, most cannot and this is why I think people should only review episodes they feel passionately about (either them being bad or good).

I have a worst time when people don't review all of them... I feel like they are copping out... "Oh, just because you have a different opinion on this episode you don't want to review it because you don't want to upset everyone? What kind of critic/reviewer are you!?"

 

He's not "officially" an MLP reviewer but I'm going to bend the rules and say Chad Rocco because he bitches about the show enough on his Twitter and Tumblr to be an honorary one. 

 

Not only does make horrible criticisms, but he's directly attacked the shows staff and accused anyone that liked season 3 onward of "ruining the show" and being everything wrong with the community. 

 

He's usually very well spoken, mature, and rational in reviewing but that all flies out the window and he starts acting like a fanbrat whenever he talks about MLP. 

 

I agree with this whole-heartedly. Either sit down & review it or ignore it, don't just rant or praise it for no good reason

[LZRD WZRD 1,929]

I never tend to have a problem with reviewers who do every episode. I rarely find them getting "boring" or "uninspired". And rarely do I ever hear any "over-the-top nitpicky rants". To be honest, the ONLY review I've ever actually disliked was Tommy Oliver's Equestria Girls review. Not because he didn't like it (and I consider it one of my all-time favorite movies), but because he just didn't seem like the same reviewer. He went from respectable, professional, and collected to severely one-sided rage and ranting. It was TOO biased and hateful. It's funny considering he's one of my favorite reviewers overall, lol.

And there lies Oliver's biggest problem imo. EqG gave him the perfect opportunity to go full Plinkett (literally lol) because of the big backlash. From what u can tell, he doesn't seem to be able to tell the difference between nitpicking for jokes (like Plinkett/RedLetterMedia and Nostalgia Critic do) and nitpicking for criticism. Also I'm not sure what he was going for by literally doing Plinkett's style. I guess you could say he was paying homage as opposed to ripping off, but it was a bad tribute because he seems to have missed why Plinkett is good

[NightGuard 251]

Also, I'm glad to see no one put me on this, lol

Oh you...your reviews are so...Kawaii..I WUV YOUR WORK!

 

Anyways I am so surprised nobody said..

 

KIMI FUCKING SPARKLE!!

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-lgqdPdXbOl0/Upercp9ycVI/AAAAAAABnSk/LoXJCZcwwC0/s1600/1.PNG

She is worst PONY! WORST REVIEWER AND AND....*sigh* ~_~ she is just the worst of the worst...

Edited July 12, 2014 by NightGuard

[Squidi 41]

I don't really even watch any reviewers and when i do occasionally because of boredom i kinda feel that they just shove their words down your throat.

Ill side with all those that go with the forming my own opinion.

[WsConanRoyal 63]

And there lies Oliver's biggest problem imo. EqG gave him the perfect opportunity to go full Plinkett (literally lol) because of the big backlash. From what u can tell, he doesn't seem to be able to tell the difference between nitpicking for jokes (like Plinkett/RedLetterMedia and Nostalgia Critic do) and nitpicking for criticism. Also I'm not sure what he was going for by literally doing Plinkett's style. I guess you could say he was paying homage as opposed to ripping off, but it was a bad tribute because he seems to have missed why Plinkett is good

 

Well, I went for the regular audio version, because I couldn't stand the Plinkett style review just because of the style, so I can't say on that one. I personally find nothing wrong with nitpicking. Those kinds of things stick out to him and are important to his viewing experience. Everyone nitpicks at some point. Meh, I just wan't a fan of that particular review though. I LOVE the rest of his stuff.

[LZRD WZRD 1,929]

I have a worst time when people don't review all of them... I feel like they are copping out... "Oh, just because you have a different opinion on this episode you don't want to review it because you don't want to upset everyone? What kind of critic/reviewer are you!?"

That's not what I meant. I meant that it seems like a lot of reviewers who do a lot of nitpicking or poor analysis are doing so because it is the only thing they can think of when reviewing it. If you don't have anything intelligent to say, then perhaps you shouldn't do it at all. For example, MrEnter had nothing to say about Simple Ways and took like 6 weeks to review it out of obligation.

[KokuraiNoSenshi 3,465]

That's not what I meant. I meant that it seems like a lot of reviewers who do a lot of nitpicking or poor analysis are doing so because it is the only thing they can think of when reviewing it. If you don't have anything intelligent to say, then perhaps you shouldn't do it at all. For example, MrEnter had nothing to say about Simple Ways and took like 6 weeks to review it out of obligation.

Oh... My bad! I didn't realize you meant it like that, thought you were referring to it in a different way... Sowwies!

[WsConanRoyal 63]

 

Also, I'm glad to see no one put me on this, lol[/quote

Oh you...your reviews are so...Kawaii..I WUV YOUR WORK!

 

Anyways I am so surprised nobody said..

 

KIMI FUCKING SPARKLE!!

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-lgqdPdXbOl0/Upercp9ycVI/AAAAAAABnSk/LoXJCZcwwC0/s1600/1.PNG

She is worst PONY! WORST REVIEWER AND AND....*sigh* ~_~ she is just the worst of the worst...

 

Someone actually knows my work! Lol. And Kawaii? I don't really go for that, but ok. I'll take what I can get.

 

I don't consider Kimi Sparkle as a reviewer. I consider her to be in the parody field.

[Megas 28,388]

Oh you...your reviews are so...Kawaii..I WUV YOUR WORK!

 

Anyways I am so surprised nobody said..

 

KIMI FUCKING SPARKLE!!

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-lgqdPdXbOl0/Upercp9ycVI/AAAAAAABnSk/LoXJCZcwwC0/s1600/1.PNG

She is worst PONY! WORST REVIEWER AND AND....*sigh* ~_~ she is just the worst of the worst...

Isn't Kimi Sparkle a parody of brony reviewers/analysts?

[NightGuard 251]

Isn't Kimi Sparkle a parody of brony reviewers/analysts?

I DON'T CARE..but she is reaaalllly bad.

 

Anyways my least favorite has to be Stupid Private or Byter.

[WsConanRoyal 63]

I DON'T CARE..but she is reaaalllly bad.

 

Anyways my least favorite has to be Stupid Private or Byter.

 

I've seen Byter mentioned quite a bit. Never heard of him before. Also, I don't know Stupid Private either. Lol. Not sure if I want to look them up.

[Moved to Elsewhere 11,331]

I've seen Byter mentioned quite a bit. Never heard of him before. Also, I don't know Stupid Private either. Lol. Not sure if I want to look them up.

Byter is probably the most negative of the brony reviewers. He hates almost every episode after season 2. I'm serious, I looked through most of his season episode "reviews" and he liked only like 2 episodes. Even people who say that season is their least favorite at leas liked more than 2. Also, he seems to be one of those people who you think would of left the fandom by now since he seems to hate the new episodes.

[KokuraiNoSenshi 3,465]

Byter is probably the most negative of the brony reviewers. He hates almost every episode after season 2. I'm serious, I looked through most of his season episode "reviews" and he liked only like 2 episodes. Even people who say that season is their least favorite at leas liked more than 2. Also, he seems to be one of those people who you think would of left the fandom by now since he seems to hate the new episodes.

It's not even that. I don't MIND critics, who build their entire lives around nitpicking & everything (see ZeroPunctuation or Nostalgia Critic), but when they seem to just not know what they are doing... Grrrrrrr it makes me crawl up a wall!

[NightGuard 251]

I've seen Byter mentioned quite a bit. Never heard of him before. Also, I don't know Stupid Private either. Lol. Not sure if I want to look them up.

He always is the first 3 people to review an episode. He has some weird Robotic voice thing as a co-host...it's horrible..

My Little Pony Maud Pie Review:

[WsConanRoyal 63]

Byter is probably the most negative of the brony reviewers. He hates almost every episode after season 2. I'm serious, I looked through most of his season episode "reviews" and he liked only like 2 episodes. Even people who say that season is their least favorite at leas liked more than 2. Also, he seems to be one of those people who you think would of left the fandom by now since he seems to hate the new episodes.

 

Well, everyone's entitled to their own opinions. Does he give actual reasons to why he doesn't like the newer episodes though?

He always is the first 3 people to review an episode. He has some weird Robotic voice thing as a co-host...it's horrible..

My Little Pony Maud Pie Review:

 

I'm not a fan of the "changing static image" style (unless it's done well), and I feel this is just...meh. I've heard worse, but I've obviously heard A LOT better.

[Moved to Elsewhere 11,331]

Well, everyone's entitled to their own opinions. Does he give actual reasons to why he doesn't like the newer episodes though?

It's not that, I'm ok if someone doesn't like the show anymore. But it's the fact that he continues to watch it. Kind of like CR. 

 

Also some of his reasons for hating episodes are like Wondebolts Academy for the Wonderbolts not being like the military before (even though they have in like Secret of My Excess.)

[WsConanRoyal 63]

It's not that, I'm ok if someone doesn't like the show anymore. But it's the fact that he continues to watch it. Kind of like CR. 

 

Also some of his reasons for hating episodes are like Wondebolts Academy for the Wonderbolts not being like the military before (even though they have in like Secret of My Excess.)

 

CR? 

 

Maybe he just has hope that it'll get better in the future? IDK, I guess I just can't say since I don't really know him, lol.