Who are your favorite & least favorite "key-bearing" characters (so far)?

[Moonlight Magician 494]

My favorite is Cheese Sandwich! (Big suprise)

 

My lease favorite would be Spitfire. She was portrayed horribly in Rainbow Falls. I want Wonderbolts Academy Spitfire! Not Rainbow Falls Spitfire. Soarin would have been a much better key giver.

 

Then again.. I've yet to see the episode where Applejack gets her key. That might change my opinion once I see that episode.

[Forlong 1,726]

Seabreeze is best Breezie!

 

I really don't care for Silver Shill.  He really amounts to nothing.  He just goes with the flow, like a sheep.

[MLPFanatic34 3,234]

Favorite key character would definitely be Cheese Sandwich and his rubber chicken, least favorite would probably be Silver Shill.

[Will Guide 21,360]

My favorite is Cheese Sandwich. Not because he's voiced by Weird Al, but more because of him being in an MLP episode with several songs that are subtly reminiscent of Disney songs. Pinkie's opening song reminds me so much of Belle, the 1st song in Beauty and the Beast; Cheese's intro song is said to be written with Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious from Mary Poppins in mind; Pinkie's Lament starts out sad, but ends on a triumphant note, like Let It Go from Frozen or Poor Old Jack from Nightmare Before Christmas. What can I say? My first and longtime love in media form has always been Disney  and I also enjoy musicals. 

 

My least favorite is Spitfire. While I agree with most that she seemed OOC and the plot of that episode felt a little too similar to Wonderbolts Academy (Done that already), MY main reason for her being my least favorite is that she's the only one in the bunch who's already been introduced and established! I feel all the Key Givers should be have been brand-new characters, even if they'll stay one-shot.

[Nightmare_Shinigami 31]

For me the best Key giver was Coco Pommel... she had a hard life working for Suri, met Rarity and than quit

 

My least favorite one was Silver Shill, who was just a cheap Coco-Pommel-Ripoff

[Ianpiersonjdavis 513]

My favorite would have to be Seabreeze because I enjoyed his attitude throughout the episode and the revelation of his family at the end helped show why he was so short tempered.

 

My least favorite would be Spitfire (who I used to love), my opinion of her (and the Wonderbolts as a whole) declined SIGNIFICANTLY over the course of the episode, making her the only 'key' character so far that I actually HATE. 

 

With that said, Cheese Sandwich was my second favorite, but Coco Pommel and Silver Shill I couldn't really care about one way or the other. 

[Wingnut 6,999]

So far, my favorite is Coco Pommel with Seabreeze and Cheese Sandwich a close second and third.  They call had good moments and development in their respective episodes.  You could see their original motivations and what brought about their change of heart.   

 

On the other hand, Spitfire throwing Soarin under the bus just didn't feel right.  That whole thing rubbed a lot of people the wrong way.  And Silver Shill is almost everybody's least favorite, including mine.  It's easy to see why.  The focus in that ep was on Granny's miracle of the placebo effect.  Because of that, Shill's character got next to no attention.  There was little opportunity for the audience to identify with him in some way.  He was just...there.  :/ 

[ShadowPirateX 600]

To me, it's a tie between Cheese Sandwich (i still can't comprehend that name) and Coco Pommel. Cheese Sandwich was just hilarious and despite looking like an antogonist, he was actually a really nice guy. Also Cheese Sandwich has become my second favorite Season 4 debut character (with the Mane-Iac scoring first place).

As for Coco Pommel, i liked how she was a contrast to Suri. Speaking of Suri, i did feel sorry for Coco having to put up with Suri's crap.

 

For least favorite i'll say Spitfire. Why did she suddenly decide to take jerk pills and conspirate against Soarin? (Not that i care much for Soarin)