Reactions on the new "Smile HD" video

[Courageous Thunder Dash 7,824]

Heard of it, watched a little, had to stop...terrible animation. I just don't get why this person does that stuff...he's a total shock jock. 

[baltoist 303]

smile hd is stupid imo but ill take it over cupcakes

[crazitaco 596]

Wow... People actually liked it?! Some people are psychopaths...

*sneaks up behind MyLittleGLaDOSFalls

*crazitaco silently pulls a blade from behind her back and puts it to her victims throat

*"Shhh" she giggles madly,

and whispers: "Go to sleeep...."

 

 

 

[Nine 707]

The song was good. Killing ponies meets with somewhat less approval however.

[BayoUni2847 528]

My sides, they were in pain once the video ended. It was so weird and stupid I couldn't help but laugh at it.

[Vermillion 613]

Well i liked it for some reason ...

[Seaweed-Headed Dragon 359]

It was totally horrible in my opinion,..yet I watched it like 10 times. Voluntarily so perhaps I actually do like it and I'm lying to myself. Who knows?   

[hawkflame 3,310]

Wow... People actually liked it?! Some people are psychopaths...

 

That's not fair.  It's extremely well made and full of energy, , and I think there can be artistic value in that. 

 

Artistry isn't in the subject matter, but in the style and talent the creator brings to it, IMO. 

[Photon Jet 5,491]

I honestly think when I saw it, the Pinkie we saw does not do any of those gruesome acts to her friends. That was why I did not like Smile HD that much. The music was awesome though.

 

With my imagination, I thought that Pinkie was a pseudo robot. 

[CrystalTheVampony 24]

I seemed to like it for some sick reason.

[Adorkable 2,737]

The video was very well animated, and the remix was nice too. Lots of work was put into this video. Also, the clip art for it, although a troll, is one of the cutest things ever.

 

The actual video made me pee a little, though.

[justice4243 2]

Apparently there's an alternative ending now.   So random.

[SparkleShy 38]

NO. NO. JUST NO. NO. PINKIE WOULD NEVER DO THAT. JUST NO.

[NavelColt 22,880]

Moved to Sugarcube. Pony-related talk goes here, rather than in General Discusion :3

 

Speaking as someone who despises the high levels of pointless grimdark in this dandom, I 'tolerated' it more than any grimdark fanfic, and by extension Cupcakes HD which was based off the most notorious of those fanfics. At least with this, it was animated and done -so- over the top, that to me it felt like it was self-parodying the grimdark themes in the fandom, than anything. Even down to the 'Pinkie killing all her friends' bit xP

[Pastel 7,630]

Though the animation is great, I absolutely hate it... -_-

[SCS 7,537]

Hello, @mlpfiwcat. There was already a topic in existence for discussing Smile HD, so I have merged yours into it. Please use the search function to see if the topic you want to post already exists before posting it. Thanks!

[mlpfiwcat 30]

It was the single most gory pinkie pie video in all of YouTube. Five stars!

[The Crimson Cross 7,532]

My reaction:

 

*Pauses video*

"what did I just watch? This...is..not possible."

"How? What just.."

"Hmmmmm......"

[Zenit 190]

I watched it. It was awful. and its sorta copying dragonball

[Frosty Nerd 833]

I've watched it so many times, I don't remember my reaction except that I was rooting for Fluttershy to win! It's quite funny with that music playing TBH.

[Zhortac 1,474]

I watched it. It was awful. and its sorta copying dragonball

 

Sorta? Seriously? Sorta?

 

Do you even watch DBZ?

[Courageous Thunder Dash 7,824]

I really despise such horrible fanfics/fan videos such as Rainbow Factory, Smile, Cupcakes etc.. I have never watched them, and never will! I really do not understand how some people can enjoy making something like that.  I do admit,  I enjoy the song Rainbow Factory, but that is it! Aren't Bronies supposed to be about love and tolerance, not senseless violence, killing and gore?

Totally with you Scarlet. Why take cute ponies and put them in that situation just for entertainment. Makes me think that MasterDavie's just a senseless person, then again can't judge 'cause God knows his heart. 

[Adachi 772]

Catchy song, but I think it's horrible. I think they were blatantly trying to mentally scar as many kids as possible. I started it thinking that it was gonna be like the original. Even in the first couple of seconds, I didn't think anything was gonna happen, because even though the disclaimer looked creepy, I read it, and the description seemed legit.

 

I once thought that stuff like this should be protected, because nobody's creativity should be denied. But I think MLP fan content (and any fan content based off kid's shows) should always be kid friendly. I am against all clop and gore pics/videos, because no matter what, at the end of the day, countless kids are gonna end up seeing it for one reason or another. Kids should always be considered first, over individual creative expression, because one's expression can mentally scar many kids. Even if there's a warning, because kids will ignore it, and parents for the most part are slacking in their responsibility. Just because there are irresponsible parents, doesn't mean that their kids should end up suffering.

 

Although I admit that if it's in fanfic form, it's perfectly ok. And even the images/video are ok if they are kept under tight lock and key from kids. But currently, there is no way to ensure that, unless they do what adult sites do and require a credit card number to make absolutely sure that little kids can't access that stuff.

[Lizziepadpotato 17]

I was shocked, at first, after awhile I got used to it, because I love Cupcakes XD

I love pinkie/Pinkamena too, but the Fluttershy bad-azz part was still the best

Still, the goriest pony video the fandom has ever seen!

[Luffyiscool 397]

I find it funny how a lot of people overreact to this video.

Personally, i thought it was awesome. DBZ FTW.