Do you think the Mane 6 are cuter humans than Ponies?

[NocturnalTwilight 32]

Hey all!

 

So, I just got done having another amazing round of Equestria Girls, I'm sure when I wake up from this epic coma due to over amazingness, I'll be able to finish this topic.

 

[3 Weeks Later]

 

Now, where was I? Oh okay, I remember.

 

Throughout the movie, I saw every one of the Mane 6 have super cute moments, I mean sweetness everywhere! Of course, in FiM they all also have their cute moments as well, rest assured. But I was wondering what you guys think? Are the human versions of the Mane 6 cuter than the Pony versions?

Don't get me wrong, I love Twily's cute little Pony face more than anyone who has ever existed in existence, but I think she's really cute as a human too. Could it be because being the same species, you'd have more of an attraction? Possibly, yes. Or, maybe you think otherwise, I dunno. I just think they're all so cute! Let me know what you Bros and Broets think. (

 

Remember though, it doesn't mean you hate the ponies if you like their human forms better! Just asking an opinion!

 

EDIT: This is kind of silly, but it was bugging me for like 20 minutes. I'm totally siding with the Ponies being cuter, have no idea why it was bugging me, just wanted to point that out. I voted No.

Geez, stupid mind! 

Edited September 30, 2013 by NocturnalTwilight

[~Silver Essence~ 2,625]

I personally find them cuter as ponies than humans, but as humans, I'm not going to lie when I say they look a bit more "attractive" this time around....

 

Then again, the human versions is just as adorable as well. X)

[Passion 3,490]

I can't just generalize this and present opinion about all at once.

 

Ergo:

 

Rainbow Dash - Yes

Fluttershy  - Yes

Rarity - No

Twilight Sparkle - No

Applejack - No

Pinkie Pie - Yes

 

...simply put.

[Princess Periwinkle 3,778]

The ponies are what got me into the show. I think... if they were humans I might not have bothered with the show. I don't have a problem with humans in the movie, but I gotta have mah ponies. They're the cutest things ever.

 

My little ponies:

 

 

 

 

[PonyBoy15 428]

The ponies are for sure much cuter than their human counterparts. BUT, their human forms are a lot more attractive in my opinion.

[SomariFeyWright 776]

As has been said, the ponies really do have more of a cuteness factor, but those human forms are GORGEOUS.

 

That's my thoughts, anyhow.

[Scootalove 10,692]

They are cuter when they are ponies but, as humans they do look more attractive in a way. That's my opinion on how they both differ.

[Dusty Soul 2,614]

Humans are more attractive then ponies.  They are both cute in their own right, and honestly the only ones I found cuter were Applejack, Fluttershy, and Rarity.  All the others are cuter as ponies. 

[Rinkitty 589]

No. They looks weird as humans. I mean, weirder than usual cartoon depictions of humans. They kinda give me an uncanny valley effect. I just want them to go away, and never come back...

 

Other artists can make the mane six look good as humans, but not the animators at Friendship is Magic land, or wherever they work...

[CrystalRecord 3]

I think they look better as ponies

I mean their human forms look great and all I just generally prefer their pony forms.

 

 

-RainbowVinyl

[Harmony And Rarity 195]

I can't just generalize this and present opinion about all at once.

 

Ergo:

 

Rainbow Dash - Yes

Fluttershy  - Yes

Rarity - No

Twilight Sparkle - No

Applejack - No

Pinkie Pie - Yes

 

...simply put.

I agree. except for Rainbow Dash. I think my least favorite out of all of the mane 6 is probably Rarity. Its because mane 6 Rarity looks way better. also, Pinkie Pie seems happier in Equestria girls for some reason...

[Malinter 3,065]

Way cuter as ponies. they look too skinny in EQD itself but that's just my opinion. Seen lots of humanized ponies that look really nice though.

[Endblock 4]

It's kinda hard to compare them... They're both cute, but in different respects. The ponies are cute because of their smallness and gentle rounded features. The humans are cute because, as said before, they have a kind of attractiveness about them. In my opinion tho, I find that some of them weren't cute enough in human form. Rarity, fluttershy, rainbow, and applejack weren't as cute as they could have been. I think it was the hair being either badly designed or disproportionate. Twilight and pinkie were adorable. In general I'd say the ponies are cuter, but in a different way.

[Zekromic 1,054]

not gonna vote, Pretty hard choice, each form has it's own cuteness, well, except the "Principal sisters". Not ugly, but they can't compare to the rest of the humanized ladies XD

[Rappy0 338]

Ponies, how is this a hard chose? Have you seen their human designs? If they looked something like this

 

then I can see their human designs looking cute.

[uml4mj4m 134]

Meh. Even though the movie was a giant stain of soap scum, I'll have to admit that the human character models actually potrayed their characters pretty well. But then again, we have these to look at until they go stale:

 

 

 

-Shudder-

[Metemponychosis 1,263]

I have an intense dislike for humanized ponies (but I don't go on deviant art hating pics over this, for example).

I don't know where this comes from because I absolutely like furries/anthro. 

 

Spoiler because... Talking about Rule 34... Don't know who might be reading.

 

 

About the stuff people are saying about humanized being sexier/more attractive, I don't work this way. I don't really think that ponies are physically attractive, but I have some pictures that I think are "sexy", not because of the ponies' appearance, because it's showing genitals, but because of the theme of the picture. That said, when I see anthro ponies, it has to be SPECTACULAR for me to like it. Same goes for the fics.

 

 

[GrimCW 658]

EQG style? Not a chance at all, in any way.
That style art IMO is TERRIBLE when applied to humanoid characters. And its kept me far far away from a LOT of shows as a result.
 
But seeing it as the Ponies.. I actually clung to it like flies on fly tape. It drew me in and won't let go!
 
Now for many pre-EQG cosplays, such as

 

 

 

Yes.
When tastefully done, its cute and beautiful all at once!

Edited October 7, 2013 by GrimCW

[Abstract 832]

I was quite pleased to find that the "no!" option had that exclamation point at the end to more properly express my dislike of humanized ponies.

 

Quite frankly, I find the pony forms to be cute, attractive, adorable and sexy. The human forms? None of those things.

[Felix 1,363]

Quite frankly, I enjoyed their human looks. I'm not gonna lie, I got so used to them being human after a while that when they returned to being ponies it almost seemed impossibly weird to look at. I almost thought I liked the human versions better, but comparing how adorable they are, I would have to go with their pony forms being much better.

[Sweet Dreams 1,893]

I think the pony forms are much cuter. I don't really like their human forms at all, to be honest. I think they look really ugly, but I think it's mainly because they made their skin the colour of their coats in MLP. It just looks weird, in my opinion.

[GrimCW 658]

I think the pony forms are much cuter. I don't really like their human forms at all, to be honest. I think they look really ugly, but I think it's mainly because they made their skin the colour of their coats in MLP. It just looks weird, in my opinion.

 

It makes it even stranger when its taken into consideration that its mentioned the ponies can dye their coat colors...

So tbh I always kinda wondered if anypony actually does that

Edited October 7, 2013 by GrimCW

[Sweet Dreams 1,893]

It makes it even stranger when its taken into consideration that its mentioned the ponies can dye their coat colors...

So tbh I always kinda wondered if anypony actually does that

Fluttershy probably did, you know, to go with her TAIL EXTENSIONS!

But what would be stranger is if they could do that in Equestria Girls....

[BrilliantVenture 335]

I joined for teh ponies, and I'll stay for teh ponies...so...ponies.

 

But really, to be honest, I didn't really like their human forms that much, it reminded me too much of bratz dolls and stuff of that nature...and the facial colours made me flashback to doug on nickelodeon...however, there are a few exceptions...I think applejack and pinkie crossed over well...and vinyl...was pretty amazing...but in the end, I gotta go with the ponies I know and love...

[Lunetiz 4]

When it comes to cuteness, I would have to say that the pony version would have the win on this.

With that said, it's not to say that the human side will never be appreciated to me or others. I guess it's because I'm more used to watching My Little Pony as PONIES!! The human versions in the movie is too recent to be calling a comparison of cuteness or other genre. Some has already has considered the human version better than the pony version, but it might take me time to consider anything like that (especially if they make a spin-off series on this). So for now (which I wont say much), I will have to say that the pony version are cuter.