Sindle

Maybe the Mane 6 will need her talent in stage magic to launch some kind of diversion for... Something. I dunno it ain't perfect.

The fish she feeds to the bears could very well just be fish who died of old age and she picks them out of the streams to keep them clean and fresh for drinking water.

A new cast of characters, by the time G4 will end the character arcs of the Mane 6, CMC, and Spike will most likely be done with, and continuing with them in a new generation after they achieved their destinies wouldn't be the smartest idea. Plus this is a long shot but by George I want a male lead in G5, I mean G2 had male leads, even if they were complete jerks to the girls. In terms of plot, I want would like G5 to be set many many years after G4 with a sense of time progression, new city states have sprung up, Twilight or a new duo of rulers now govern Equestria. New Guardians of Harmony have been selected, some being descendants of the original Mane 6 some not. Above all else, I want to see the same art style of G4 just updated and touched up. As much as I like this gen's looks having it repeat twice would just be stale and old. Maybe even get Rebecca Sugar to do G5, she'd do it just right.

Nightmare Moon exists because of reasons.

While Twilight's new castle does have a bad design if G4 is going to run for quite a while then we need changes like this to keep everything fresh. Plus once Rarity gets to work on that palace it will look exponentially better than it does now. As for the song, it's all four princesses singing what more could you ask for.

I would imagine Twilight is a huge fan of Classical music like Rarity. As for Pinkie I would say she loves J-Pop and K-Pop since it fits her the best.

In a rule 63 world. (Which I love the idea of) I think the CMC would be the ring bearers rather than flower boys.

I think that ponies tend to have fairly long lifespans stretching as far as 170. But I think the Mane 6 are immortal if they chose. If they chose to be mortal their element will be passed onto a new pony. Besides Equestria without the mane 6 it's a miracle they survived 1000 years without them with all that goes on in the modern era. I mean are we supposed to believe that nothing that chaotic like what goes on now didn't happen in the 1000 year period? Without the elements or Rainbow Power now I'd give them 2-28 minutes tops.

Pinkie Pie obviously gets her money from Hasbro themselves, they pay her to not cross into our reality otherwise the mane 6 would love their collector's value and they won't make anymore money off of Pinkie toys. I think I speak for all of us when I say; Hasbro give us out Pinkie.

Fascinating timeline except there's just one problem, seasons 1-3 take place in the same year and your timeline suggests they take place over the course of 10 years. Other than that it's amazing.

Oh he will be back. Do you think he'd just fly out of his owner's hooves only to not come back? Twilight cares for him and though their relationship hasn't been iterated on much, or at all, since his debut but Owlicious will take comfort in the giant crystalline tree castle.

When I first viewed the episode that character screamed OC to me. But I'm glad that he got his wish to be in an episode of MLP and hope he recovers. Plus we get another stallion in the show that played at least a minor part and those are few and far between.

It is fairly common for someone to experience a form of relapse, it happened to my brother after he quit smoking only for him to go back. So it isn't entirely OOC for Discord to go back to being a conqueror rather than the trickster. But I guess even Fluttershy wasn't enough for him to not Relapse. Frankly i'm surprised he didn't ask her to join him, as even when he went into it he struggled to want to lose their friendship.

Celestia has a lot of royal duties she's still getting used to Luna being around and being able to do some of the governing so Celestia takes on the tasks of ruling the nation even though she's more than capable of having help, Twilight who has done literally nothing with her wings and crown and Luna who is still catching up on modern Equestria. Then I dunno why Twilight called Cadence, I think she got there just before the job was done and just did a little while spreading love in Ponyville.

I think this was a good overall episode, Spike actually shined as a character a bit instead of being the universe's punching bag. He showed that he's devoted to Rarity and will do anything to make her happy again after she put her best work forward only to have it rejected by a complete jerk. And then there's Rarity she was able to really express for extravagance in this episode. She also went totally which is a plus. But the control of the book showed her at her worse she full on ruined a little filly or colt's birthday party and even left Pinkie Pie dumbstruck which you have to really do a lot to do that. Now then again this was all because the book had her under its control and we've seen what dark magic does to a pony, Sombra and Ttixie anyone? Then the lesson isn't half bad either, tell your friend the truth even if you think it will hurt them. But then there's the bad of the episode, the conclusion felt a little forced and rushed kind of like the ending of Equestria Girls, Spike just said the truth and poof no more changeling magic in Rarity now I know they actually alluded to it when Rarity was casting the spell early on but I can't help but feel it was wedged in. Final rating is: 4/5 stars

*Blushes* You can't prove that I've seen that!

But then how do ponies hide their "business" if they don't normally wear clothes. If stallions don't where clothes then shouldn't we be able to see their "stallion hood" plopped out. Maybe that's why we don't see a lot of stallions but then did the stallions we do see all get snipped? And where do mares fit into this do they just hide it with their tail and only a well angled look cann reveal their pieces of the puzzle?

Her key is gonna be her new crown. Called it.

Quick alert Hasbro! They've got 2 year old toy ideas to recycle and a stallion to make Twilight's husband! They're not out yet but people want it go to your store and throw money at them because you need this novelty playset of Twilight in a dress. And all the while shippers of Twilight and other ponies cry as their fanfics and fanart is destroyed with a lone commercial advertising a second royal wedding. But in all seriousness I don't think the Mane 6 need romance at all, it's an interesting concept but we wouldn't lose anything if any of them had a handsome stallion by their side.

You can also buy the toys separately from the happy meals for only a dollar.

Twilight would just be a normal unicorn who went to Celestia's school, her and her friends wouldn't know each other, Nightmare Moon would have succeeded in taking over Equestria and plunging the entire world into eternal night. Everything would be in turmoil since food can't be grown without the sun. Tyranny and Marshall law would reign. Basically the world's @$&%ed without Twilight being Celestia's student.

They have cutie marks for having cutie marks pertaining to their name. Just like a person in the real world can be famous for being famous.