S05:E09 - Slice of Life

[Steel Accord 6,660]

Don't get me wrong though--I love the idea of an episode that focuses on background characters--but I would have liked it more if they had come up with these characters themselves instead of just copy-pasting the fandom into an episode. It felt...insincere?

 

I don't expect "incredibly deep lore", I just expect consistency. ^^'

But they DIDN'T just copy and paste them! We came up with logical extensions and so did they and most of them were different.

 

-The Doctor was NOT a time traveler, to his dismay.

 

-Derpy goofs but isn't catastrophically clumsy.

 

-Secret agent Bon Bon wasn't in ANY fanon as far as I know. (If anything that was Octavia and Pony Joe's thing.)

 

-Speaking of whom, Octavia lives in Ponyville not Canterlot.

 

-Most notably VINYL NEVER SPEAKS! She's often a chatter box in fanon.

 

So . . . no they weren't being insincere.

[Side Bird 566]

Even though those aren't confirmed either

Who said I was shipping them?

I'm just happy to see them together, and they they are probably close.

Edited June 13, 2015 by Snow Berry~<3

[Steel Accord 6,660]

Haha Exactly!

As much as I appreciate the cameos and shout-outs, I think they could have done a lot better with this episode. Especially the pacing.

I might have cared about Doctor Hooves and the others if they each had enough screen time to really develop as characters... If you don't read fanfics, this episode doesn't really do anything for you.

I don't and I still think this might be my favorite episode of all time.

 

The characters felt familiar but they could surprise me. The plot moved around but that was fine, it was more a humorous string of character moments than a proper story.

I was amused that attacks on Ponyville have become so frequent that many of them don't care/aren't surprised anymore.

That's another head canon of mine basically confirmed and this vindicated!

 

Now all I have to do is convince them to make Breaburn and Little Strongheart a thing. <3

[AmberDust 1,118]

But they DIDN'T just copy and paste them! We came up with logical extensions and so did they and most of them were different.

 

-The Doctor was NOT a time traveler, to his dismay.

 

-Derpy goofs but isn't catastrophically clumsy.

 

-Secret agent Bon Bon wasn't in ANY fanon as far as I know. (If anything that was Octavia and Pony Joe's thing.)

 

-Speaking of whom, Octavia lives in Ponyville not Canterlot.

 

-Most notably VINYL NEVER SPEAKS! She's often a chatter box in fanon.

 

So . . . no they weren't being insincere.

*shrugs* Just my opinion. I don't read fanfics, I didn't enjoy the episode. ^^' I assume it's cause-and-effect, seeing as everyone else already loves these characters. When i watched this episode, I didn't care about its characters, because none of them individually got enough screen time for me to really get to know them beyond their face value.

Edited June 13, 2015 by AmberDust

[Critical Mass 178]

I hope to see that changeling at the wedding again.

[Dolphanatic 298]

I just checked the episode's credits to see if Derpy's name is canon again.

 

 

*Sigh*

Edited June 13, 2015 by Dolphanatic

[Steel Accord 6,660]

*shrugs* Just my opinion. I don't read fanfics, I didn't enjoy the episode. ^^' I assume it's cause-and-effect, seeing as everyone else already loves these characters.

If it's not your thing, it's not your thing, I'm just defending the creators from the thought that they put no effort into this because it's all their on the screen.

[Reaver 350]

Golly, I loved this episode, even though I didn't understand most of the references.

They adopted so many fan interpretations, but added some original content, too. Like, I would of expected Lyra to be the secret agent, but it was so good because Bonbon's voice actor changes all the time! SQUEE!

And I loved the science lab! It just adds new depth to MLP! I loved the Doctor/Derpy relationship, it was amazing! It felt like there was content every few seconds being thrown at us. God, I loved this episode.

I have no idea what the bug bear came from, but it was hilarious!

I really, really liked Celestia and Luna's portrayal. Celestia wasn't ridiculously informal, like she was in Make New Friends but Keep Discord, but she was still... casual, I guess. And they bickered! SQUEE!

Plus, OctaVinyl. DEAR GOD, THE OCTAVINYL. Not that I particularly support them as a ship, but the friendship feels~ (which actually brings me to the main problem in the episode, which is that the sounds of a cello were coming out of Octavia's bass. But you know your nitpicking when that's the main problem.)

 

Yeah, honestly, it was probably one of my favorite episodes. It was really funny, added some depth, and the Gummy/Shakespeare thing was just amazing. Yeah, that's my opinion on the episode. I just wanted to gush about it. :3

[AmberDust 1,118]

If it's not your thing, it's not your thing, I'm just defending the creators from the thought that they put no effort into this because it's all their on the screen.

 

I never said they didn't put any thought into it. ^^

[Luna the Great of all the Russias 2,984]

-Most notably VINYL NEVER SPEAKS! She's often a chatter box in fanon.

That was something I noticed as well. I suppose Nowhacking and Vinyl has become so closely associated with one another that they thought it would be safer to not have her speak; this may have been for the best.

 

A Changeling (who have only appeared once, as evil creatures who eat love,) having been invited to a wedding felt VERY odd. Like, seriously odd. Last time we saw changelings, Twilight was blasting them to bits. I bit of explanation would have been nice. ^^'

The way I saw that scene was that he wasn't invited there, but instead that he was a lost Changeling who happened to wander into the wedding without having most guests notice his presence.

[Declen 118]

 

 

Dr. Whooves's science lab felt out of place in the world of magic where the most advanced thing we've seen was a steam-powered apple-picker.

Actually, we've seen more than that, including several electrical devices. It's called "schizo-tech".

[Pastel 7,630]

I just checked the episode's credits to see if Derpy's name is canon again.

 

Muffins.jpg

 

*Sigh*

Muffins? Really? :/

Not only her voice, but her name was changed too.

 

Meh, Derpy 4ever.

[Luna the Great of all the Russias 2,984]

I just checked the episode's credits to see if Derpy's name is canon again.

 

Muffins.jpg

 

*Sigh*

Maybe her name is Derpy Muffins Hooves.

[Thunderlane 550]

Did anyone else catch this yet!? It appeared around 15:46...

Woooow!! I just slowed it down and saw it xD That's amazing

[AmberDust 1,118]

Maybe her name is Derpy Muffins Hooves.

 

Derpy Muffins Ditzy Hooves Do.

 

It's canon.

[Steel Accord 6,660]

I never said they didn't put any thought into it. ^^

No but you did say "it seems . . . insincere" which conveys a similar sentiment if not the exact phrasing.

 

You don't like it, you don't like it. I could personally watch this three more times!

[AmberDust 1,118]

No but you did say "it seems . . . insincere" which conveys a similar sentiment if not the exact phrasing.

 

You don't like it, you don't like it. I could personally watch this three more times!

 Okay cool. Glad you enjoyed it.

[Hashi 323]

nothin here to see just fangasming

Edited June 13, 2015 by bonamb

[Pastel 7,630]

Dammit, I want the old Derpy back ;_;

 

[baltosaa 86]

(pasted over from the other topic:)

 

Yees, finally the episode happened...

 

It was fine, I think.

 

Lots of Ponies talked (Except Button Mash :C  ), which was the highlight of the episode...

 

The Doctor said that "Allons-y" thing,

 

 

Aaand Derpy.

 

The episode did seem a bit short to me, though..

 

 

 

(also, income the shippers. let us pray that we may survive~)

[Night Mist 151]

Haha Exactly! 

As much as I appreciate the cameos and shout-outs, I think they could have done a lot better with this episode. Especially the pacing.

I might have cared about Doctor Hooves and the others if they each had enough screen time to really develop as characters... If you don't read fanfics, this episode doesn't really do anything for you.

Um I have never read a fan fic and I loved this. ._.

[Fl1cker 107]

I GOTTA SAY TODAY WAS A GOOD DAY.

[AmberDust 1,118]

Um I have never read a fan fic and I loved this. ._.

 Fanfics, fan animations, and fan content in general.  I also don't watch Doctor Who, I've never seen the Big Lebowski, and I don't ship background characters. So this epsiode really didn't have nay thing in it for me, except Derpy. 

[Thunderlane 550]

Screenshots from the credits:

We have canon:

So it's a straight up Lebowski shoutout, Stephen Magnet canon, and 'Muffins' for Derpy. 

I'm a happy little Thunderlane

[Steel Accord 6,660]

Screenshots from the credits:

We have canon:

So it's a straight up Lebowski shoutout, Stephen Magnet canon, and 'Muffins' for Derpy.

I'm a happy little Thunderlane

Just in case you didn't notice, go back and check the Dude's cutie-mark and prepare to explode twice.