Who is the nastiest member of the Mane 6?

[Applejacket 185]

Who's the rudest? Who starts the most arguements? Who hurts ponies' feelings the most? Who's more ignorant towards other people's feelings and emotions all the time? Who's the most inconsiderate and brash?

 

I have a solid answer. One of the reasons I hate her actually.

 

Rainbow Dash. Followed by Rarity, followed by AJ, followed by Twilight, followed by Pinkie, followed by Fluttershy.

[Zachary 5,521]

No One,

 

Because I really love the Mane 6!

[Applejacket 185]

Okay. If someone held a gun to your head and said you must honestly choose a meanest member of the Mane six or you die, who do you choose?

[cmarston1 5,959]

Rainbow Dash and Applejack are probably the most argumentative.

[Nerdy Luigi 2,065]

Top 6 Nastiest Mane Six Members in my opinion:

 

1. Rainbow Dash- To be honest, she can be absurdly rude and obnoxiously self-centered. Still not a BAD pony though. Even though she's basically a friendlier version of Garble...

------------------------ (This is a fairly)

------------------------ (significant gap)

2. Applejack- At times, she starts arguments and can be somewhat brash. Though I guess that's part of being the Element of Honesty. Being brutally honest.

3. Pinkie Pie- At times she can be absurdly obnoxious and not really care that nobody cares.  

______________ (Less than the first, but still there)

4. Rarity- Somewhat self-centered for being the Element of Generosity, but not nasty by any means.

5. Twilight Sparkle- She's had nasty moments here and there.

6. Fluttershy- I can hardly think of a time where Fluttershy was completely rude (aside from the Iron Will episode...).

[Starlighty 976]

Ha Rarity starts a lot of crap but this one has to go to RD.... She always doing stuff to get on people nerve.

 

With that said Rarity just annoys the hell out of everyone and says things without thinking sometimes. 

[GrimGrimoire 4,973]

That is like asking which one is the most purple or which one has the best chance of passing a reading test.

 

I think there is only one obvious answer by some of what you ask. RD is the rudest and most often the most inconsiderate... but she is also absolutely loyal to her friends, and the first to stick up for them when they are in trouble. She is not truly nasty or hateful to anyone though. Rarity has been more hateful and spiteful then RD has at times.

 

Honestly all of them have at one point or another acted poorly towards one or more of the others for usually either selfish or misunderstood reasons.

[Megalomaniac 100]

Fluttershy is awful though.

 

She's manipulative, passive-aggressive and likes to play the victim with emotional blackmail.

 

I like Twilight because she's the most intelligent one and the only one who always saves the day along with Rainbow.

[VinylWubs 1,252]

Definitely Rainbow Dash with Rarity being in second

 

Apparently RD is too focused on her dreams about becoming a wonderbolt and she's too rude to ponies! Seriously, in Tanks for the Memories she shouted at the rest of group all because she couldn't let her let go into hibernation. Talk about rude. But that's not all! She's quite self-centred and doesn't give a toss about her friends opinion unless they're in danger. At least she's WAYYY better than Glida and that dragon Garble combined. Rarity is just too focused on her own work and she doesn't like anything out of place otherwise she throws a big tantrum. Drama queen

 

You get my point

Edited December 27, 2016 by VinylWubs

[Kyoshi Frost Wolf 41,689]

Echoing RD here. She has shown plenty of times that she will get far too carried away and she has a tendency to sometimes either brush other ponies away entirely or say things she shouldn't.

 

 

Fluttershy is awful though.

 

She's manipulative, passive-aggressive and likes to play the victim with emotional blackmail.

 

I like Twilight because she's the most intelligent one and the only one who always saves the day along with Rainbow.

Agree about the Flutters thing. I have also noticed her being a bit passive aggressive lately, kinda hoping that doesn't continue.

[The_Gobo 36,257]

#BlameSpikeForEverything

[leonbrony17 1,216]

#BlameSpikeForEverything

Best answer ever!!!

 

Besides, i would choose death.

[Lucky Bolt 35,072]

I love all the Mane 7, but if I had to choose ONE of the ponies... it would be Rarity, I guess

[The_Gobo 36,257]

I can understand picking any of them, with the exception of Twi' or Fluttershy.
The concept of using 'Fluttershy' and 'nasty' in conjunction with one another just seems...

I dunno, wrong I guess.

[Ganondorf8 11,336]

Rainbow Dash would definitely be the one who is the nastiest given how her attitude and personality have a tendency to rub the others the wrong way. Fluttershy would be the least nasty as she doesn't really assert such opinions, excluding the events of "Putting Your Hoof Down" where she actually acted just as bad, if not worse, than Rainbow.

[Luminance 2,186]

Twilight during season one was pretty nasty, in the sense that she's still learning about friendship.

 

...and what about now?...

 

Rarity.

 

Even though she's embodies Generosity, there are times when her bad side latches on to her explicitly.

[Splashee 28,566]

Rainbow Dash has been pretty nasty over the years, yes

[Tom Gallagher 33,593]

I wouldn’t call any of them nasty.  Unless it was the Mean Six or something. 

[EpicEnergy 23,223]

I refuse to label any one of the mane six as "nasty", it's just that I don't think any one of them are.

[Cagey 4,248]

Definitely Dash. She has a lot of flaws. But there are positives about her character, too, and her argumentative, impulsive nature makes her interesting from a character-dynamics perspective. 

[Vefka 1,499]

Definitely Rarity. Annoying, self-centered, I have no idea why she's the element of generosity, she's the opposite!