What religion would each of the Mane 6 be?

[AveryGamerDude 4,640]

I hope this isn't a controversial concept, but it's something I've genuinely wondered. If the Mane 6 were people in the real world, what religion, or lack thereof, would they have? Realistically, they could be any religion. But if we're going off of their personality and what not... I'd say Applejack and Fluttershy would most likely be Christian, because Applejack is a cowgirl, (Or cowmare.) and cowgirls are typically associated with the American south, which is the most Christian region of the US. As for Fluttershy, I'm kinda just going off my personal experience, because I've met a lot of girls that were like Fluttershy, and they were all Christian. (Maybe that's because I live in Arkansas, I don't know.) As for Twilight Sparkle, I'd say she'd be agnostic or an atheist, considering she's very scientific and skeptically minded, (Though you can still be religious and both of those things.) and she's quick to point out when things are "unscientific." As for the other 3, I'm not totally sure. What do you think?

[EpicEnergy 23,221]

Twilight Sparkle - atheist

Rainbow Dash - Mormon

Fluttershy - Buddhist 

Applejack - Christian

Rarity - Roman Catholic

Pinkie Pie - agnostic

[AveryGamerDude 4,640]

2 minutes ago, EpicEnergy said:

Twilight Sparkle - atheist

Rainbow Dash - Mormon

Fluttershy - Buddhist 

Applejack - Christian

Rarity - Roman Catholic

Pinkie Pie - agnostic

Interesting. 

[Oleks 1,993]

Twilight – agnostic atheist (she was gnostic atheist before Feeling Pinkie Keen).
AJ – something traditionally Christian.
Rarity – I wanted to write “Judaic”, but than I remembered she likes caviar according to the official MLP web-site, so I’d say Christian as well.
Fluttershy is probably in a pagan nature-worshiping cult, and Pinkie is in a Lovecraftian one.  
Rainbow Dash only worships herself.

Spoiler

Spike is devoted believer in Talos.

 

[The Kaeya Simp 13,989]

Twilight - Idk, I'm thinking agnostic though I do know quite a few critical thinkers that are also really religious (mainly Catholic) so I honestly dont know

AJ - Definetly Christian

Rarity - Spiritual athiest if I had to guess

Fluttershy - "Neo-Pagan"

pinkie - Gypsy I mean probably somewhat spiritual but I'm thinking athiest

and RD worships this

[Thuja 3,659]

Rainbow Dash- herself

Rarity- hmm...  I want to say taoism?  Ooo, maybe Shinto?  She seems like the type to want things in a particular order?

Fluttershy- Jainism(idk that one came to me and has stuck since reading this thread)

Applejack- I think she's agnostic, she might believe there's a god but I don't think she's the type to believe in things she can't touch or speak to.  So she doesn't prescribe to one religion over another.

Pinkie Pie- she's probably christian???  Seeing the Sonic Rainboom when she was younger probably would've made her believe in Miracles, especially how unhappy she was before then.

Twilight Sparkle- Paganism

[Splashee 28,566]

I don't know enough religions to give unique ones to each Mane 6 member

[AveryGamerDude 4,640]

1 hour ago, Splashee® said:

I don't know enough religions to give unique ones to each Mane 6 member

Well they don't ALL need to have unique religions.

[Splashee 28,566]

Just now, AveryGamerDude said:

Well they don't ALL need to have unique religions.

But I don't want to fall into a trap and say one specific religion. I'd rather have everypony have a unique one to not favor any religion

[Fluttershutter 2,501]

They're all jedi.

sith

[Rebel the Wolfgirl 5,605]

Twilight - agnostic atheist

Rarity - probably Christian, though she'd consider herself irreligious

Fluttershy - Wiccan

AJ - Southern Baptist

Pinkie - probably something like Discordianism or Pastafarianism; definitely a more humorous faith in the loosest sense of the word.

Rainbow Dash - LaVeyan Satanist.

Edited September 17, 2020 by Renegade the Unicorn

[cuteycindyhoney 13,308]

All I know is that Rarity would look wonderful in Shinto robes!

[Miss 6,230]

Fluttershy: Native American Church/Peyote Religion

Rainbow Dash: secular deist

Twilight Sparkle: secular atheist

Applejack: Sikhism

Pinkie Pie: secular agnostic

Rarity: Ojibwe Spiritual Beliefs

Neat topic

[RDDash 19,190]

Strong Amish values 

Catholic and maybe Orthodox Christianity

Some atheism to boot

Church of Celestia

 

[Goat-kun 2,527]

Twilight: tips fedora

Fluttershy: Wiccan hipster

Applejack: Protestant

Rainbow Dash: also tips fedora

Rarity: rich folk devil worship

Pinkie Pie: Pastafarian

[Pony Flutters 535]

Twilight Sparkle - Atheist, maybe agnostic.

Rarity - Jewish

Rainbow Dash - Daoist

Fluttershy - Buddhist

Applejack - Protestant

Pinkie Pie - Maybe Catholic, though she does seem to have origins from the Equestrian version of the Amish.

Edited April 2, 2022 by Pony Flutters

[Ashen Pathfinder 16,161]

Twilight Sparkle - Open minded, but atheist. She's just too analytical for religion to work for her, imo.

Rarity - I can see her being Catholic, and I can't really explain why. Probably due to the ornate cathedrals and I can see that affecting her worldview.

Rainbow Dash - Narcissist.

Fluttershy - Wiccan or some sort of pagan belief. She's way too nature-oriented for anything else.

Applejack - Southern baptist, or maybe even pentecostal. In any case she's the opposite of Rarity so a protestant belief is fitting.

Pinkie Pie - Amish upbringing, but I can see Buddhism working for her.

[abronymouse 5,513]

they'd be old style religions I think - less abstract and more grounded (in so far as supernatural belief can be - also that is more fun). Let's go with Egypt, given so many of our religious ideas came from there anyway and their religious history is ridiculously well preserved for how ancient it is.

 Horus = Dashie. God of wind and sky. Also snappy multihued plumage.

 

 Thoth = Twilight. Wisdom, learning and the moon. Always has their beak in a book.

 Hapi is Fluttershy. God of the Nile loves giving life. Nice teats.

 

 Ptah is AJ. Practical. Bearded. Down to earth and good with his hooves.

 

 Bastet is Rarity. Kitten Goddess of the home.  Likes shiny things.

 Osiris is Pinkie. Fun-drunk + flamboyant but a serious side.

 

 

 

 

 

 

[ExplosionMare 18,067]

Twilight Sparkle- Atheism 

AppleJack- Eastern Orthodox 

Rarity- Judaism

Fluttershy- Hinduism

Pinkie Pie- Polytheism

Rainbow Dash- Methodism

 

[Scootaloo9074090 501]

twilight Sparkle - atheist

Rainbow Dash - agnostic nihilist 

Fluttershy - Buddhist 

Applejack - Christian

Rarity - Ojibwe Spiritual Beliefs

Pinkie Pie - Jewish

Edited December 22, 2022 by Scootaloo9074090

[cuteycindyhoney 13,308]

I do not wish to contaminate and cheapen Equestria with religion.

[Megas 27,727]

AJ is 100% Christian
Fluttershy is Buddhist
Rarity could be either
Pinkie could....probably be a Christian
RD is agnostic and Twilight is Atheist

[Rebel the Wolfgirl 5,605]

Twilight is a scientific pantheist.

Applejack is Christian, possibly Baptist.

Pinkie was raised Mennonite, but is now likely some form of Christian atheist, possibly Jesusist.

Fluttershy is Neopagan, specifically the Reclaiming path.

Rainbow Dash is Roman polytheist.

Rarity is irreligious, but considers herself Unitarian Universalist.

 

 

[Ice Princess Silky <3 14,196]

I think each mare embodies principles and codes of honor that all religions (and non) are compatible with. So, at this point, I think answers bubbling to mind would be stereotypes or gross exaggerations of said beliefs or general cultures. It's a fun question to think about individually, I suppose XD 

[J.J 923]

The church of friendship, it's my religion to... If this is more so an "if they lived in our world" scenario, if these same identities/cultural personalities were in our world as opposed to their own, they might not even be the same ponies... I don't think Applejack is necessarily religious just bc she's traditional and I don't think Twilight is necessarily unreligious bc she's rooted in recorded facts and less so existential sentiment... But as you see in FiM, her moral sense of authority, and superstition increases, ponies like Pinkie are very superstitious and we see other ponies like AJ respecting these seemingly random rituals that are faith/spiritually inclined... and eventually Twilight come to respect these instances she can't explain... I don't think with the overwhelming lack of evidence to actually disprove god(irl), and Twilight's own realizations on instances that can't be explained in her own world that she would be anything other than agnostic, but accompanied by an experimenters title...

Fluttershy has/has had a lot of lovable pets, my guess is (as a former/current) pet owner myself, that she has a lot of faith based sentiments and wishes comparable to the same type of faith based sentiments "I believe" Applejack's family dynamic would give her..

And fully embracing "loyalty" as part of your core philosophy can lead you to almost religious like ritual behaviors that compliment your sense of obligation toward those you feel it is most owed toward, and I think this could impact rainbow dash potentially, someone less interested in all the details and that only needs to live by baseline facts, sometimes it's easier to explain circumstance by tying it to the idea of destiny, and treating ones own talents/place in the world as more of a predetermined idea, even without calling narcissism out for being an unattractive personality trait, sometimes it's tied in with someone's faith/belief that their individuality is surely a mark of an intelligent designer and that none of their behaviors/personality quirks could be tied to heavily to anyone else, they are "one of a kind" something that less religious ppl try to veer away from bc they aren't sentimental and often times want limited information to bind others with a greater sense of purpose, lust for accomplishment, and sense of individuality to their nihilistic pessimistic limited perspective, it's how a "well versed atheist" feels better about his place in the world by trying to make others come to terms with unproven theories about the universe that make you feel as small as they do, they want you to be comfortable with nihilistic overdrive like them lol ..