What if Nightmare Moon Took Twilight Sparkles as her Student instead of celestia?

[Scootaloo9074090 502]

 what if Nightmare Moon Defeated Celestia and send her to the moon and Nightmare rule over equestria  and maybe take Twilight as her student when twilight was a filly 

and Twilight sparkles could have  become a Knight of darkness or The Dark Knighta Fearless warrior Twilight sparkle s could have become if Nightmare moon would have won when she return

I see nightmare moon as a more stronger and powerful than celestia  herself so  that why she use the element of harmony to banish nightmare moon and on the other hand  nightmare moon doesn't seen like a bad ruler but a more ruthless one equestria need a Powerful Ruler to handle any threat without using the element of harmony but with lethal forces against a enemy  

Nightmare Moon is the safest choice because at least she keeps her people safe even in her ruthless ways.   and nightmare moon is more Lawful Evils and even Evils Have standard

Nightmare Moon is motivated first and foremost by a desire for real admiration (as opposed to ponies pretending to admire her out of fear, as one tends to get with actual tyranny). And that curing disabled ponies such as Scootaloo would be a highly effective PR move (assuming her magic is actually capable of that - which if it were, would raise the question of how come Celestia never bothered to try it).

Plus it would have made the movie way shorter - "You want a new horn? Here you go! [zap] Now why don't you ditch that stupid ape and hang out with the cool kids?"

Failing that, i suppose she could just put a few more bits into prosthetics research.

Plus it would have made the movie way shorter - "You want a new horn? Here you go! [zap] Now why don't you ditch that stupid ape and hang out with the cool kids?"

Failing that, i suppose she could just put a few more bits into prosthetics researc     

maybe she would teach Twilight sparkes as her studant and Nightmare moon would make Twilight into a Knight Of the darkness

 

 

Twilight sparkles would take any Threat from villain 

 

Tirek would remain in Tartarus

 

Chrysalis would surrender

 

King sombra would retreat and get Killed off again

 

storm king would escape if his army was taken out by Twilight Sparkles/ The Dark Knight

Pony of shadow and the pillar of old would remain in limbo and discord is still turn to stone because the element of harmony are still   connected to Nightmare moon/Luna and Celestia

 

cozy glow would be scare to overthrow nightmare moon

Edited December 11, 2021 by Scootaloo9074090

[ExplosionMare 26,358]

Man I would have LOVED to see a batpony/batmare Twilight in the show! I also agree with you on Nightmare Moon’s leadership style, I feel like she would be a lot more aggressive, but she wouldn’t go around hurting her own citizens or do anything most stereotypical villains would do.

[ExplosionMare 26,358]

Moments ago, Starforce said:

Hehe, we are doing just that aren't we?

Yup  It’s so awesome to explore Nightmare Moon that way

[Scootaloo9074090 502]

9 hours ago, Starforce said:

Nightmare Moon is a great leader tbh. She may rule with fear, but she cares about her ponies.

yeah imagine Twilight sparkles as a student to Nightmare moon instead of celestia

 

Twilight would be a Fearless and strongest warrior 

a Knight of shadow twilight would have become

[Scootaloo9074090 502]

well there is one villain that nightmare moon or Twilight sparkles can't defeat. is the batman who laughs 

 

seriously this villain can do so much destruction to equestria and would defeat nightmare moon and twilight sparkles

[Clawdeen 25,256]

Just imagine Twilight jumping out from the shadows and saying in a deep voice “I’m Batmare.”

[Scootaloo9074090 502]

1 hour ago, Mammon said:

Just imagine Twilight jumping out from the shadows and saying in a deep voice “I’m Batmare.”

that is funny and terrifying