Which background pony do you wish was a main character?

[Lifehax 81]

So guys, I know we all have favorite background ponies or fanmade ones. But the question is.. Which of them would you love to be more involved in the show? Or even be one of the main characters in the show in the future..

 

*Cough* VINYL SCRATCH *Cough* *Hack* *Gag*

 

Edit: Added Lyra Hearstrings to the poll. Sorry about that guise

 

*Smacks head*

 

Edit: Added Colgate

Edited October 1, 2012 by Wubmaster Vinyl Scratch

[Lost Profile 644]

Derpy... She had only like 3 lines witch raged people... I'd like Derpy to have more lines... And more aperences...

 

I just don't know why parents got raged about this...

 

Derp dosnt mean retarded... Like really...

[AnonBrony 1,468]

What no lyra? THIS IS MADNESS!!! lol.

I guess i would go with Derpy then. It just sucks that, that whole stupid derpy incident happen. She woulld of been a nice little character that would clumsy and do silly stuff for the humor. WIsh we would see more of her... although we never know what those writers have in store for us heheh.

Edited September 29, 2012 by AnonBrony

[Lifehax 81]

What no lyra? THIS IS MADNESS!!! lol.

I guess i would go with Derpy then. It just sucks that, that whole stupid derpy incident happen. She woulld of been a nice little character that would clumsy and do silly stuff for the humor. WIsh we would see more of her... although we never know what those writers have in store for us heheh.

 

I forgot lyra! Oh dear.. You are right. I will fix that right away, how could I forget Lyra? Pretty popularly loved background pony.. doh!

[Waffles 12]

I don't really know...it was either Derpy Hooves or Vinyl Scratch. I believe they are already main characters for us Bronies but it would be cool if ot was official.

[Zerul 554]

Personally,I never cared too much for Derpy (sue me).But I don't dislike her either

I do however like Vinyl.She was probably the 1st background pony I ever looked into I remember there was this Youtube video with Vinyl and Octavia doing a radio show and that was probably the moment I knew I was a brony

Edited September 29, 2012 by OdinForced

[Vanguard 123]

I voted for Vinyl Scratch but i think if you made her a main character then i think you have to make Octavia one aswell, from the fanfics i have read about them they would make good main characters.

[real_equestrian 30]

Octavia, she's only in two episodes, but she seems so fascinating. I'm just anxious to hear how she sounds like, since some people have suggested possible a Brit. accent or perhaps a sophisticated manner of speaking (rarity-style?).

[Lifehax 81]

Personally,I never cared too much for Derpy (sue me).But I don't dislike her either

I do however like Vinyl.She was probably the 1st background pony I ever looked into I remember there was this Youtube video with Vinyl and Octavia doing a radio show and that was probably the moment I knew I was a brony

 

What a coincidence! That's exactly how I became a brony too!

Vinyl ftw.. hey go ahead send me a friend request if you want. Or i'll send you one.. whatevz :3

Yeah the radio show.. that video was called Epic Wub Time: Musicians of Ponyville, i think.

[Retro*Derpy 3,185]

As much as I like Derpy, I can't choose her. Making her a main character would really take down what Derpy is, like her random appearances. But I also can't choose between Vinyl and Octavia. They are both great ponies.

 

So rather than voting for a pony I know, I voted for Cloud Kicker. I don't know this pony hardly at all, and I think it would be unique how she will be interpreted into the mane 6.

[Vanguard 123]

 

I think it would be unique how she will be interpreted into the mane 6.

 

I dont think of it as the character being part of the mane 6 i would see it as taking the spot of the CMC or just another addition to the story like the CMC is.

[duidamasterXD 9,627]

Well, none. Some of them look pretty cool but there's really nothing to motivate me to like them as characters at the moment and adding any characters to the mane 6 would be a bad idea IMO

[King Tryndamere 100]

As much as I like Derpy, I can't choose her. Making her a main character would really take down what Derpy is, like her random appearances. But I also can't choose between Vinyl and Octavia. They are both great ponies.

 

So rather than voting for a pony I know, I voted for Cloud Kicker. I don't know this pony hardly at all, and I think it would be unique how she will be interpreted into the mane 6.

 

If she was added to the mane 6, her element could be the element of innocence xD

 

All kidding aside, I see what you mean. Derpy is one of those ponies who just randomly shows up, and I do agree that adding her as a main character would take down what she is. Maybe when/if the CMC get their cutie marks, Apple Bloom could join the mane 6? Otherwise I don't really have any idea, other than Vinyl/Octavia or maybe Lyra.

[Cherry Blossom 864]

Octavia and Vinyl scratch would really work out as main characters, but it would be great if there was a separate series to start off.

[silvadel 1,393]

Lyra Heartstrings -- Background pony kind of sealed her as my favored well background pony. Note she is not the "human hunter pony" in that one -- I wouldnt want to see her in that role.

[RoadtoEquestria 59]

Derpy!

 

Vinyl Scratch is right behind her though. I hope that both ponies will have expanded roles in S3, despite what has been already said about Derpy.

[DJShy 873]

Is Colgate a real pony, or is that something that somepony made up?

 

If no, my vote goes to Colgate. She's a very clean pony!

 

If yes, Derpy.

[Lifehax 81]

Is Colgate a real pony, or is that something that somepony made up?

 

If no, my vote goes to Colgate. She's a very clean pony!

 

If yes, Derpy.

 

Yeah Colgate is fanmade. I could put colgate in the poll if you'd like?

Never actually heard of colgate but just did some research.

[Zerul 554]

What a coincidence! That's exactly how I became a brony too!

Vinyl ftw.. hey go ahead send me a friend request if you want. Or i'll send you one.. whatevz :3

Yeah the radio show.. that video was called Epic Wub Time: Musicians of Ponyville, i think.

 

YES!I remember that one too.It was that video that led me to the master recording(The radio show video).

I'll PM it to you right now

[DJShy 873]

Yeah Colgate is fanmade. I could put colgate in the poll if you'd like?

Never actually heard of colgate but just did some research.

 

1st of all, yes. PLEASE add colgate to the list.

 

2nd of all, Colgate is a pony who is opsesed with oral hygen. Ergo, her specal talent being a dentist and her cutie mark being a tube of toothpaste.

[Zygen 6,066]

Derpy , even tho i'm pretty sure realisitcly she's proably not going to have anymore lines I still love her

I guess her like 3 lines will have to do.

[coconutbunny 121]

Derpy since she's the original background character. Plus, I think she deserves more than what she got on The Last Roundup but it's all good

[~SadisticFluttershy~ 779]

i Chose Derpy, cause shes my most fave backround ponies ever!

 

But id also love to see Vinyl Scratch too....

 

But tbh: I'd choose both!

[Zeruis 53]

I would love if Lyra was a main character and if Vinyl Scratch at least got a speaking role in the show. Isn't Octavia supposed to have a duet with Rarity in season 3?

[Clarity 3,094]

How about Applejack? She's been in the background for all of Season two and I didn't really appreciate their effort to make a mane character go in the background behind all the others. Underdeveloped characters should go in the front so they can work on them more.