Chunky vs. Smooth Peanut Butter

[DokiLoki 519]

I personally love chunky peanut butter. Dunno why but its always my favourite, I love every food that has a rather crunchy texture. 

[Fubz 300]

Crunchy, of course! Biting into a sammich without the true satisfaction of a nutty crunch but rather a smooth goo which sticks everywhere in your mouth is not goodness.

[PfcRich 19]

Chocolate Peanut butter of nothing at all! Once you've had it nothing else will do. It's like biting into heaven on a slice of bread.

[Legacy Dash 439]

I do very much love chunky peanut butter, however, it's hard to spread.

If someone sat two sandwiches on a plate and said pick one, I'd probably go for the chunky one (unless the bread has been torn to pieces).

In conclusion, smooth peanut butter.

[RD4ever 9]

Smooth all day,all night. never gonna think of chunky peanut butter because i don't like crunchy/chunky food. So,i stay with smooth

[Malinter 3,064]

I hate peanut butter.... i can't even to look at it let alone touch it. Mostly because some brands look like... well something else entirely to be honest....

Edited October 6, 2013 by Greenfield

[CornBreadGang 514]

I have braces, so I can't have chunky peanut butter. And I know you'll all hate me for this, but I've NEVER had chunky peanut butter...

What am I missing out on?

[Galen 1,354]

Tho I generally like both, I prefer chunky over smooth. I like to have the bits of peanuts in the jam as to me, it makes the jam feel more authentic compared to the smooth version. It's the same as having orange juice with bits of orange in it to me. Plus, I always did prefer crunchy food except in certain circumstances.

[Zygen 6,066]

I actually prefer chunky peanut butter, but the thing is I hardly get to eat it since the rest of my family prefers creamy.

 

I still like both, but chunky is so good...

[Scootalove 10,689]

I prefer the smooth peanut butter in my opinion. I do enjoy eating both chunky and smooth, but if it was up to me I would pick smooth.

[Abstract 832]

Gotta be dat chunk. Smooth peanut butter isn't bad, but it simply cannot compare to that heavenly goodness that is the crunch and satisfaction of chunky.

[crazitaco 596]

I love em both very much! I may go with smooth though, just because my mom tends to buy it more often and it's easier to spread on the bread. (Hey that rhymed!)

[Chivalry Knight 161]

If were talking about sammiches, then smooth wins. If were talking about cookies then that's an obvious win for crunchy! SO that's another vote up for crunchy!

[Virulence 254]

Personally I like smooth peanut butter. It it perfect for sandwiches and for a smooth finish. When I have crunchy peanut butter, I have to chew more and it's not a good combination.  

[ReverseFaller 2,483]

I'm pretty sure I use Smooth. Yeah, I just checked. Smooth Jif Peanut Butter all the way for me. I've never tried Chunky so I can't really comment, but I guess Smooth wins be default then as it's the only one I've ever had.

 

Mmm...peanut butter

[Sweet Dreams 1,893]

Now, here's the thing. Although Crunchy peanut butter is obviously superior in terms of taste and texture, smooth peanut butter is still my preferred option. Why?

Have you ever tried spreading crunchy on bread?

I mean, even getting it at a relatively fair distribution throughout the slice is a challenge. The peanut butter just sticks to the nuts and clumps up so you just get a bunch of clumps on your bread and little to no peanut butter. And then, when you try to spread those clumps, you pick up chunks of bread on your knife. Seriously.

You know what? I'm gonna start buying little peanut pieces individually, and them just sprinkle those on my smooth peanut butter covered bread. I'll demolish the system.

 

RANT=OVER.

[Creamy Arty 6,252]

The age-old debate. One which was recently waged at work.

 

As for me, chunky. Everyone enjoys the crunchy texture of peanuts, chips, pork rinds, crackers, and plenty of other things. Why someone would want to remove that from their peanut butter is beyond me.

[Noazark 67]

First time I've tried peanut butter was last week, and it was smooth, so I guess I don't the best judgment, but I think smooth works better on sandwiches than chunky So I voted smooth.

[DenialZombie 82]

I LIVE FOR THE CRUNCH!

 

Also, I have no trouble spreading crunchy peanut butter on bread. Then again, I toast my bread.

 

GET ON MY LEVEL.

[Fluttershyfan94 5,742]

Prefer smooth, mostly just because I like being able to put it on my bread more easily. I love butter, I love peanut butter as well. Because it's easier to use the smooth one, I'll get more on my bread. Maybe put a few layers of it, make one nice looking bread.

[\/ 651]

Now, here's the thing. Although Crunchy peanut butter is obviously superior in terms of taste and texture, smooth peanut butter is still my preferred option. Why?

Have you ever tried spreading crunchy on bread?

I mean, even getting it at a relatively fair distribution throughout the slice is a challenge. The peanut butter just sticks to the nuts and clumps up so you just get a bunch of clumps on your bread and little to no peanut butter. And then, when you try to spread those clumps, you pick up chunks of bread on your knife. Seriously.

You know what? I'm gonna start buying little peanut pieces individually, and them just sprinkle those on my smooth peanut butter covered bread. I'll demolish the system.

 

RANT=OVER.

I will make the best thing ever for you. I will create a peanut butter dispenser that puts the exact ammount of peanut butter on your sandwich, and  will not end up getting stuck on anything or falling of the sandwich. It will be perfect for you.

[Flutter's lover <3 8,205]

I like both, but I prefer smooth.....I used to really like crunchy, but it's some what of a turn off now.and with smooth, I can put more on,I usually have 1/4'' thick layer of PB on my sandwiches.....and nothing beats PB on Rye....Rye is probably my fave type of bread....next to Pumpernickel

[Pomfritter 165]

I like chunky on occasion, but for the most part smooth. Maybe if there was an option for peanut butter that is like only 50% as chunky as regular would be okay, but otherwise it's too much.

[Sommar 1,289]

Chunky is obviously the best guys. Don't deny the power of chunky goodness.

 

All jokes aside, I do prefer chunky over smooth. Chunky has the sort of texture and crunch that is oddly satisfying. I miss the taste of chunky peanut butter; for I am not allowed to have it in my house (my dad's allergic). Oh, the horror!

[CC_Maud_Pie 6,431]

I prefer smooth because it is easier to spread and I like the taste better.