S04:E14 - Filli Vanilli

[Dynamo Pad 11,260]

I really like this episode. Good songs and a nice homage/reappearance of flutterguy. I also love this episode and even some episode that featured fluttershy in this season because she became a new favorite character of mine this season. From random moments in power ponies to this and other episodes I really enjoyed how she acted and became one of the many favorite characters in mlp. 

[Draxon 214]

Just watched this episode for the first time, and I love it.  I love how they brought back the voice change which happened when Fluttershy was first exposed to poison joke - brilliant!

[JonasDarkmane 19,785]

I loved it, I loved seeing Fluttershy enjoy singing ^^. It was lovely . 

[Ninja(Pinkie)Midget 180]

This is one of my favorite episodes.

[ggg-2 3,552]

When i found out about the turkey call contest and that pinkie took his title away, I was pretty pissed. (Big Mac is best pony) But, I did some thinking, and realize that, presuming Big Mac took second, it's actually a better fit for him. Yes, second place isn't as glorious as first, but that's just it. It isn't as glorious. I think him coming in second fits better with his modest personality.

[ShutterBat 134]

Fluttershy is my favorite pony, so hearing her sing more than usual was fantastic. Previously, we only heard her sing in May the Best Pet Win and at the Gala. I do like it being focused on her being able to enjoy her talent while being able to avoid her fear. Later of course, this fear is addressed. Which is fantastic. Kids need to see fears being addressed in the end and overcoming them.

[I Bring Da LULZ 131]

1. Best. Fluttershy. Episode. EVER!

2. I HATE Pinkie Pie in this episode!

[Yukibana 65]

This is probably my most favorite non-Pinkie centric episode.  Also am I the only one old enough to know what the title of the ep is referencing?  I hope not XD  

 

Anyways, I loved seeing Fluttershy get so excited about the group in this ep.  She was so adorable when she was shaking her little tail and singing along with them.  I think we got to see a different side of Fluttershy when she got so into performing, even if it was just backstage.

 

While I also didn't like how Pinkie Pie pushed Fluttershy, I can kind of understand why she did it.  I don't think Pinkie always thinks about how her words affect other ponies and doesn't think before she speaks.  I have that problem a lot  As much as I love Pinkie Pie I was kinda hiding and going PINKIE NO when she was being pushy.

 

Also the song totally gets stuck in my head.  This ep never fails to make me happy if I'm having a crappy day.

[Mad Cyantist 30]

I just watched this one again last night, and I had forgotten how good it is.  The beginning with Fluttershy in full-on Disney princess mode was cute/funny, and I loved all of the stuff with the Pony Tones.  I really hope we get to see that group again.  

[Lamniform 33]

I enjoyed the episode but I really really wish Fluttershy would've overcome her fear and sung in front of a real crowd by the end. It would've been a much more encouraging message to the viewer.

Also, Pinkie could've toned it down a notch, sheesh. Aand hearing the same song over and over again made me not like it anymore.

But yeah, overall liked the episode.

[Tameless 979]

Filli Vanilli was a marvelous episode in my opinion.

 

Sure I always love rarity, but to see big mac sing, and all of them sing in a group? That was fantastic. Of course there were a lot of reprises but the song itself is very catchy and fun to sing. Personally I thought fluttershy did a great part with doing what she always dreamed. That was great to see.

 

Anyhow, I would watch this episode over and over and hum that tune all day till it kills me ha.

[Graystrip 551]

Such a nice episode of Fluttershy.  What can I say, I love her voice.  I can see how she gets all nervous, though.  Each time I perform on the piano in front of a large crowd, I get all weird myself.  The only thing that helps me is to pretend the room is empty and I'm just playing for myself.  It was too bad she had to hid behind a curtain and not sing in her real voice.  She has such a beautiful female voice. Do it for the animals! nice touch Rarity =^.^= 

 

image from fimfiction.com 

[BrawnyCharger 511]

Does anypony get the feeling that Pinkie Pie was either off her meds, under a troublemaking spell of some sort, or was hidden away somewhere while one of the Pinkie clones from "Too Many Pinkie Pies" had returned and took her place in this episode.

 

That must not have been the real Pinkie Pie to be that mean spirited.

 

Plus I have reason to believe that Pinkie Pie deliberately caused Big Mac to lose his voice so she could steal the Turkey Gala championship.

[Jackie Holloway 36]

I don't see why Fluttershy don't just use the poison joke to go on tour with PonyTones . Just keep her behind th curtain and call the band:

PonyTones & the Shy-Voice

 

Get it ... since she is the opposite as FlutterGuy

[powerpuff-tsubasa 448]

aha! my fav eppie! i owned it digitally but one day i shall rewatch it and hear flutterguy again

[BrawnyCharger 511]

Do you suppose that Pinkie Pie was sent to the "Bad Pinkie Corner" for a week for her mean spirited mischief, as well as forced to forfeit the 1st prize for the Turkey Gala contest for her supposed cheating as soon as the episode was over?

[powerpuff-tsubasa 448]

Do you suppose that Pinkie Pie was sent to the "Bad Pinkie Corner" for a week for her mean spirited mischief, as well as forced to forfeit the 1st prize for the Turkey Gala contest for her supposed cheating as soon as the episode was over?

havent watched this one for a long time...but if Pinkie took her "humor" too far. she deserves to be cornered

[Aquamarine453 17]

Honestly the best part of the whole episode was the music. 

[cmarston1 5,959]

I really enjoyed this episode a lot.

The song was really great.

I also really liked the moral of Fluttershy taking baby steps forward.

Before Flutter Brutter, this was my favorite Fluttershy episode.

[SoulHarmony 43]

I have heard alot of youtube reviewers knock this episode but I am glad there is a huge amount of support for it if the voting has anything to say about it

[twiia 1,843]

Return of Flutterguy made this one quite enjoyable. However, is doing that illegal?

[Thrond 3,263]

Same old Fluttershy episode with a slightly different context. Okay, sure, having an episode about stage fright is nice and all, but for a while it felt like every Fluttershy episode was about her fear of something. I'm sure that people with stage fright can uniquely relate to this, but it still feels like yet another excuse to have Fluttershy be afraid of something. At times it feels like there's nothing else to her as a character. This is where season 4 really starts to lose me. 

 

I don't think Pinkie was intending to be mean, however. I think that writing her this way was a bit of a misstep, as I like to think she's learned to be more sensitive, but I also think the was trying to express sympathy towards Fluttershy even as she went too far. Also, the "don't be ridiculous" joke early on more than justifies the setup. 

[Tropical Melody 6,047]

This:

 

 

I notice Pinkie's expression is more of a grin, rather than just gob-smacked.

 

 

 

This:

 

 

 

AWWW!! score #15 

 

 

 

[Moony the Cat 3,702]

This Episode had a kinda good song, so i give it an " ok " rating, otherwise i found this Episode to be pointless.

So, the Episode makes it seem, like Fluttershy wants to overcome her fear, by not overcoming her fear at the end, so nothing changed. This is the first Episode i would call a Filler. Unless i called an Episode a Filler years ago, i dont remember anymore. XD

[Thrond 3,263]

Pinkie Pie beat Big Mac in a turkey call competition. That's amazing. 

Also, is there nobody else in town who could fill Big Mac's part? 

Anyway, I've been really harsh on this one, and I think that was mostly borne out of frustration for where Fluttershy was at this point. It's yet another episode about Fluttershy being afraid of something. But while I still wish the show hadn't mined this same territory this often, this time around I had a much easier time seeing that this is actually a particularly good version of the "Fluttershy is afraid" plotline. The stage fright conceit does a really nice job of balancing Fluttershy's anxiety with other emotions: she genuinely loves singing, and might like to sing in front of a crowd some day, but she's just not ready for the actual limelight - she's afraid to take the responsibility of putting herself out there to be recognized. The way this episode ends, with Fluttershy making progress towards that goal and even suggesting she'll get there one day, is a particularly nuanced and mature take on the usual Fluttershy themes, even if it's very similar to lessons Fluttershy has learned in past episodes. I've always found this one immensely charming, so I'm really happy I was able to see through the kinda rote premise this time around.

Score:
Entertainment: 9/10
Characters: 7/10
Themes: 8/10
Story: 7/10
Overall: 78/100