Nova12

Even though I wasn't really a fan of EG, I'd love to see a Equestria Girls spinoff series as long is it doesn't interfere with the original. Although I hope its not secretly fake like everyone is theorizing... And I still think the human versions should have had normal names...

Frankly, I don't care about Flash Sentry that much. However, I do think that most bronies deserve Twilight more than he does. And yes, that was an insult to both sides. You're welcome. Also, characters can only have a horrible personality if they have a personality at all, so that might be my source of my general apathy. < She's got a ton more personality. (No offense to Maud)

I've had dreams about this. Frankly, I would love for MLP to continue into other generations until the creators finally run out of ideas to come up with ideas with. Idealy, It would be set in the same universe, but in the near future, with minimal references to the previous generations. It would be awesome for the kingdom to be ruled by Queen Twilight, who acts as a "new Celestia" but is hardly ever seen. Also a mythical goddess named Pinkie Pie... I'd love a new set of characters but the same general show format with a bit more adventure. But to be honest, I'd be happy with G5 as long it just exists.

Yes, but in a different way. When I watched the movie, I found it a bit unrealistic that Sunset Shimmer would be making fun of Twilight when she tried to become the new "popular girl." However, I would definitely feel resent towards Twilight if she stole from me what she stole from Sunset. Sunset was taking the "laugh her off cuz she's a nerd" approach, even when she had no idea who Twilight was. What would have been realistic in the movie, logical for Sunset, and what I would have done if I were her - was to harbor a deep and primal resentment for Twilight, and eventually just straight-up attack her. (Much like the final battle at the end of the movie.) Not that I would ever hate Twilight, of course!

I'd have to say Pinkie Pie. I used the phrasing "have to" because she is best pony, and I am therefore obligated to do so. I'm actually a lot like her. I easily obsess over things, my friends think I'm weird and my best friends know I'm crazy. I'm always smiling, and I love to laugh in the face of danger. What makes me most like Pinkie, though, is that though I frequently smile, I occasionally use my happiness and positivity as a veil for my admittedly large list of mental disorders. PINKIE PIE IS BEST PONY there is no escape

My OC, Sunny Melody, isn't much of a fighter, but I'd say... Give a loud and high-pitched battle cry, and then gallop towards her opponent to beat them senseless with her hooves while pummeling them with magic. Adorably.

I'd say... Twilight: Being part of a unicorn elitist group. Rarity: Shoplifting. Fluttershy: Smuggling illegal animals. Rainbow: Beating someone up. Applejack: Not that many options here... I'd say framed, and she's too honest to talk her way out. Pinkie: Insane asylum. Definitely.

How did I not know about this club?!? Also, I found a very interesting and bittersweet fanfic about Applejack's hat. Link: http://www.fimfiction.net/story/56565/stetson Applejack's hat is best hat.

My guess (a bit like KokoraiNoSenshi's) is that they're just regular horse hooves, but covered in and molded to the same coat as the rest of the pony's body.

To contribute to the topic, I believe someone truly becomes a brony when they consider themselves a brony. Personally, I actually started watching the show so I could join the fandom, but I could hardly get through the first two episodes. After a few days, I stopped watching it, deeming it too much afford to put into being popular. (No, seriously. At the time, all of my friends watched MLP, and most of them were teen girls.) However, I just couldn't pull myself away from the show. For it was only only when I stopped trying to obsess that I really could obsess. I dropped all pretense of becoming popular, and just enjoyed the show and its fandom. That's when my self image upgraded into a full-fledged pegasister.

NOTE: I started writing this about fifteen minutes ago, so sorry if I contest any recent replies. Very interesting discussion. All the previous replies have good ideas, but I have my own personal two theories: 1. Equestria was first created not as a planet, but as a huge chunk of rock floating through space. This became a problem when the organisms living on the asteroid began evolving into sentience. Equestria only slowly orbited the sun, requiring the ponies to "wrap up" the seasons. It did not rotate, requiring Celestia to latch onto the sun with her magic and spin the planet accordingly. It eventually caught another asteroid in it's gravitational pull, adopting it as its "moon." The rock was too far away to orbit properly, so Luna (who was born later) needed to guide it's rotation around the planet. 2. Equestria was once named Earth, and populated by humans. The human race eventually doomed their own species and planet in a huge nuclear war, somehow scarring it so badly it halted its rotation and orbit, and effecting the moon as well. But soon a new species rose out of the dirt, evolved from horses and adapted to human lifestyle. The leftover radiation from the colossal nuclear war would explain the horrifying mutants that devour rocks and minerals, the use of "magic," and the grotesque hybrids of completely different species. The ponies' habitation of Earth would explain their obsession with human culture: Their sayings, their houses, and completely illogical teacup design. UPDATE: Regarding recent evidence, I am also beginning to speculate that ponies are actually aliens, either to Equestria or Earth. For those contesting the "Planet of the Ponies" theory for EG reasons, I believe the portal was not to the human world, nor the pony one, but a crude crossover of both. I mean, seriously: In our world, there are no weird technicolor pony-people, there's no one named Sunset Shimmer or Rainbow Dash, and don't you think the bronies would have noticed if the humanizations of their favorite TV show characters were walking among us? Also, the news would have noticed an inter-dimentional portal and a high school being destroyed by demons. Case closed. (P.S. I also have a theory that it's just a kid's show about magical talking horses, and it doesn't need any logic to be enjoyable. But I know it would be suicide to state this among True Bronies.)

I think it's adorable. Fluttershy and Discord have great chemistry together, and by the fourth season finale, it's practically canon. I actually think Fluttercord was my username on some MLP site.