Overrated Characters?

[DonMaguz 1,023]

The only ones I can think of are:

- Marble Pie. 

A rock could have played her part, and I'm not even talking about rocks with great personality such as Tom and Boulder.

- Grogar. 

I actually like that Discord was impersonating the ridiculously hyped ram.

[Stardust Live 44]

- Maud Pie. Why is the boring, monotone voice and almost pathological disinterest so appealing to people? She's is like a black hole of charisma, charm and interest. There's nothing to bounce off of her, not even in her 'dry humour' moments. I would be happy to never see this pony again.

- DISCORD. Again, WHY the hype for him?! Is it the John De Lance voice thing? He's so overhyped for such an irritating clown. He was more interesting as a mischievous villain who did things for the fun of it and completely changed people, but as an unreliable ally? He's a drunk chaotic friend who thinks he's a great time but your other friends can't stand.

- Muffins/Derpy. Pandering to the fans to an embarrassing amount.

- Octavia/Vinyl. They do absolutely nothing, and really should have just remained background players.

- Lyra and Bon-Bon. I felt something really snap inside my noggin watching the fan episode and the Bon-Bon Being A Secret Agent thing ... just ... WHY?!

[Splashee 28,564]

On 6/22/2020 at 9:09 AM, Stardust Live said:

- Maud Pie. Why is the boring, monotone voice and almost pathological disinterest so appealing to people? She's is like a black hole of charisma, charm and interest. There's nothing to bounce off of her, not even in her 'dry humour' moments. I would be happy to never see this pony again.

When she made the rock joke in Equestria Girls, I laughed so hard, and I never laugh at that kind of humor. Who ever came up with her is a genius. Overrated not. Special, yes.

On 6/22/2020 at 9:09 AM, Stardust Live said:

- DISCORD. Again, WHY the hype for him?! Is it the John De Lance voice thing? He's so overhyped for such an irritating clown. He was more interesting as a mischievous villain who did things for the fun of it and completely changed people, but as an unreliable ally? He's a drunk chaotic friend who thinks he's a great time but your other friends can't stand.

It has to do with another show.

They kinda tried to do this with Mudbriar where they make a character based of a popular show, and in that case it is a show called Big Bang Theory and a character called Sheldon Cooper, however that didn't work, and didn't get the same attention as Discord.

I can understand that characters are boring and uninteresting when no one knows who they are based on.

Discord is based on a character from Star Trek The Next Generation, called Q. And for me personally, who just happened to watch the last episode of Star Trek TNG, and immediately fell in love with the character Q, I understood the hype about Discord before even going into Season 2. And trust me, that was a big moment for me. Overrated not. Special, yes.

 

On 6/22/2020 at 9:09 AM, Stardust Live said:

- Muffins/Derpy. Pandering to the fans to an embarrassing amount

... Guess what, I can only agree on this. I don't like disabled ponies, and why they should be called out for being disabled is like screaming evil things in the school corridor, to people that were born differently. Overrated yes. Special, no.

 

On 6/22/2020 at 9:09 AM, Stardust Live said:

- Lyra and Bon-Bon. I felt something really snap inside my noggin watching the fan episode and the Bon-Bon Being A Secret Agent thing ... just ... WHY?!

Yea, I agree. We had the same thing with Vinyl Scratch's eye color. The fans made up the idea of red color eyes, but the show staff made them pink instead. Just like the secret agent thing, which was not a fan idea, but a show staff idea, it is not good. Only fan ideas are good. Overrated yes. Special, no.

 

 

 

... Okay, the last thing was stupid.

 

[Paleopony 702]

Rainbow Dash and Luna.

[JMTV99 1,353]

Luna is overrated. Sorry.

[Savy 5,077]

Rainbow Dash, Luna, Derpy, Pinkie Pie, Trixie, Vinyl Scratch, Autumn Blaze, and Izzy is already starting to be overrated lmao

[Sparklefan1234 171,219]

45 minutes ago, Ocean Breeze said:

Rainbow Dash, Luna, Derpy, Pinkie Pie, Trixie, Vinyl Scratch, Autumn Blaze, and Izzy is already starting to be overrated lmao

 

I was with you up until Rainbow Dash then, I was back in your corner with Muffins.

Everyone else is hit or miss and Izzy is a "free space" for me because we don't know that much about her. 

[Tom Gallagher 33,588]

Discord and the Student Six. Only characters on the show who I outright can't stand. 

[Prospekt 11,018]

King Sombra. He's awesome in the comics but in his brief season 3 appearance?  Ehh... he just doesn't do anything for me, unlike most of the other villains.

Spitfire is pretty overrated, too. Cool design but never manages to be likable. Same with all the other Wonderbolts, though Soarin is a little better

[Sasoriman 138]

Princess Luna

Maud Pie

Marble Pie

Derpy

Trixie

Rainbow Dash

As much as I like these characters, even I have to agree that they're overrated. But that's not always a bad thing.

[HeebieJeebies 23]

Is it cheating to say all 5 of those chicks who are in practically every episode? Their hick friend seems alright though. Too bad she's just a background character. 

Any given fandom darling/most beloved waifu is overrated. That's the one consensus I'm seeing here. That said, "overrated" and "crappy" aren't synonyms and I'm not sure where people got the idea that they were. Most of the time, overrated characters are hyped up for a reason.

I've been burnt out on a lotta the characters others have listed here before - e.g. there was no escaping the Luna worship back in the day - but there's so many new characters entering canon constantly that I could never be too annoyed with anyone's excessive popularity for long. The Best Pony of the week would always be replaced with someone fresh, especially towards the end of the show's run. A blessing and a curse for sure lol.

the student six suck smelly wind tho reee

[ohne 408]

rainbooooooooooow daaaaaaashhh 

jokes aside, she is super overrated, no hate tho hehe

[ohne 408]

On 2020-06-22 at 9:09 AM, Stardust Live said:

- Muffins/Derpy. Pandering to the fans to an embarrassing amount.

- Octavia/Vinyl. They do absolutely nothing, and really should have just remained background players.

wait how was Hasbro pandering to us with Derpy?

Octavia, Vinyl and Derpy were given their characters and 'backstories' by the fandom itself. The fandom made them popular lul Octavia and Vinyl did remain as bg characters tho

[Savy 5,077]

Rainbow Dash. Ughh can't believe I used to be OBSESSED with her.

Also Derpy, Starlight, Vinyl Scratch and Trixie are pretty overrated too.

[AppleButt 8,675]

Rainbow Dash haters sure love these threads lmao.   Jokes aside, for me it’s Discord.  He was a good villain, that’s it. Also I find Starlight to be a bit overrated.  

[dead account 2,711]

I like Luna, but she really seems overrated.

I'm surprised to read about Starlight and Trixie here, I thought they are some of the more hated ones.

[ExplosionMare 18,064]

Although she didn't have popularity for long, Stellar Flare was quite overrated considering she only appeared in one episode. I also feel like Trixie is quite overrated too, she was well liked ever since the beginning despite infiltrating town and showing off to everyone the whole time.

[They call me Loyalty 1,948]

Probably derpy. People feel compassion towards her because of her handicap. But they wouldn't have given a damn if that horse didn't happen to have crossed eyes. I would even venture to say she would be pretty much non-existent by now. It really goes to show the conditionality of human love. What a sad story. And they even made the mistake to give her a voice and make a character out of her mental deficiency, because of course if you have crossed eyes, you also have to be retarded, offending some people in the process. Since most of the producers probably don't have a clue as to what is like to a have a child with mental defiency. I've seen parents taking out their mentally handicapped children, and it looks like a tremendous burden on them, seeing shame in their eyes. Speaking of eyes.

[FlutterIsBestAlicorn 21]

Twilight - I absolutely adored her before she became princess. She was so cute and nerdy and innocent. But once she became princess the show started trying to make her more mature and ruin everything that made her adorable. Sunburst is everything Twilight should've been

Flurry Heart - Flurry Heart is so infuriating. She had potential, she really did. A baby alicorn that can't control her magic? That's an interesting concept! BUT THEY DON'T DO ANYTHING WITH IT! In "A flurry of emotions" they could've just replaced Flurry Heart with Pumpkin Cake and Pound Cake and it would change nothing. And when they actually do something with Flurry Heart that's interesting she's just ruining everything!

Sunset - I don't know why. I just don't like her. She doesn't have the same charm Starlight has

Pinkie Pie - She's just so annoying to me

[Dr_Dinfield14 15]

I mostly think it's Rainbow Dash. She can be a jerk sometimes, which is her flaw, but some idolize her because of that. (Actually, I idolize her because of her confidence. She's truly cool, but what about the other characters?)

Also, 

-Trixie

-Starlight Glimmer

- The Royal Sisters (respectfully, they have their own fanclubs)

[Kadeda 178]

Rainbow Dash and Luna seems to have a ton of people obsessed with them. The Rainbow Dash train has slowed over the years though.

All the rest of the characters being mentioned aren't really overrated... because a good amount of people already dislike them.

I saw a comment mention Flurry Heart... really. Flurry Heart is the most hated thing in the show I think.

[Ring Team 123]

By far, the most overrated character in the show (and the one who got so much excessive attention) is this one.

[Megas 27,675]

Derpygate alone should warrant putting her here. That was absolutely embarrassing 

Edited March 12, 2023 by Megas

[FlutterIsBestAlicorn 21]

Twilight sparkle - She's the worst and doesn't deserve anything she got

Rainbow Dash - Annoying, self-centered, and people ship her too much (I will mention that whenever I say how bad she is because that lie is that annoying)

Pinkie Pie - Annoying, annoying, annoying, did I mention annoying?

Flurry Heart - WASTED POTENTIAL! She's just a bad copy of Poof

Lyra/Bon Bon - They're very bland and have nothing special about them

Apple Bloom - I don't understand why she's the leader of the CMCs. It should be Sweetie Belle, she's more interesting

Edited June 27, 2023 by FlutterIsBestAlicorn
I just changed my opinion

[Theautisticrebel 305]

As I Pinkie Pie fan, Maud Pie, she has nothing to go for other than just literally making three facial expressions, being obsessed with rocks, and dating Mudbrair, she wasn't even in The Cutie Mark Chronicles.

Am I saying she's A bad sister, no, but the other two sisters deserve their time in the spotlight too.