Which Of The Other Mane Six Should've Been Made Princess?

[Denim&Venöm 19,952]

So say for some reason Twilight couldn't be promoted to princesshood,  but one of the remaining 5 could,  which of the other mane 6 members would be best for ascension to alicorn?

 

 

[Mzukiller 233]

None. Absolutely none. No one besides Twilight deserves to become an Alicorn Princess. Plus if you make the other 5 princesses, then the title just stops meaning anything.

[Mr F 1,522]

I'd say noone should become a princess becouse then they would stand equally, and not promote one pony before the others.

(just my opinion).

[CaptainCanti 5]

I'm sure they'll all become princesses eventually. We gotta keep in mind that this is still a kids show, and Hasbro needs to sell toys.

[The Blades Shadow 444]

Well I was going to be original, but never mind then... Everypony else beat me to it...

 

But seriously, none of the other ponies deserve to be a princess... It wouldn't make any sense, Twilight is the only one who deserved to be a princess out of all of them.

[Denim&Venöm 19,952]

I'm getting the feeling that people here think Twilight was the only one who deserved to be princess.

 

But if you HAD to choose some pony else out of the mane 6, who would she be?

[Scootalove 10,689]

Well, I would choose Applejack. But, Twilight is a princess that might get stressed at times but she could still accomplish what she needs to do. I see Hasbro trying to make them all princesses in the dire need of toys.

[~Silver Essence~ 2,625]

Other than Twilight, I can't think of another.

 

But if the second choice has to be made, I guess Applejack fits the ticket, as I can somewhat see that happen.

[duidamasterXD 9,627]

This thread appears to be discussing MLP:FiM in some way, shape or form. Thus, it has been sentenced to Show Discussion.

 

This is an automatically generated message, by the way.

[Shanks 10,816]

None of them, there is at the very a case for Twilight becoming an alicorn eventually even if it has been handled poorly so far with a rushed season finale but there isn't one for the others. It would completely cheapen the meaning of being an alicorn princess and be a huge Mary Sue moment for that mane 6 character.

[RrVPfX9cPtw59FpC 1,304]

Applejack. She takes care of a family of her own, and quite a big one, so becoming a princess wouldn't be as much of a change as it would be to the others.

[GhostPony750 959]

Fluttershy, just a princess to take care of the animals.

I guess she would do well here, and being a Princess of Nature would fit perfectly here.

Since the MLP world is in the beggining of the industrialization, she would take care of natural habitats...

[EpicRainbow275 21]

Rainbow Dash, definitely. Or, i prefer, all of them because there should be no one pony who is superior to the others. That's just wrong. They should all be equal, for harmony's sake.

Edited August 22, 2013 by Epic Rainbow <3

[Chain Combo 135]

Rainbow dash- wants to be a wonder bolt so no. She also isn't the type to lead a kingdom imho 

Fluttershy- Wants  to take care of animals and is definitely not princess material to shy.

Pinkie- Come on now

Applejack- She may be able to handle it but it's not her goal and would obviously get in the way of handling the farm.

Rarity- cares about fashion.

None of the others need to be princess so why should they be.

[DarligPegasi 315]

Eew none of them! None of them deserve it and it wouldn't make any sense.

Pinkie Pie is a definite no.

Rarity only cares about fashion.

Applejack...I don't think she'd want to be anything that isn't an earth pony.

Fluttershy what does she even need magic for? And she'd break under the tiniest amount of pressure.

Rainbow Dash she wants to be a wonderbolt not a princess.

[BluntySrBlunt 4]

None, now bow to your future overlord

 

Applejack - no comment

 

Pinkie Pie - Sure if you want Equestria to go down in flames...

 

Rarity - Dem wings

 

Fluttershy - pfft

 

Rainbow Dash - Save that for fanfiction

[ReGen 1,466]

Spike. Buck yo rules.

 

No one. Twilight's the only one who had a reason to become a princess, even if it was a bit sudden and out of nowhere.

[TailsIsNotAlone 3,696]

None of them. I'm against the entire princess thing on principle. Having three of 'em in Equestria is enough. Heck, two was enough.

 

The Mane 6 doing the things they do while being regular ponies is one of the things that makes them special.

[hawkflame 3,310]

Rarity.  I think she's the only one who would appreciate what it means to be royal and have royal duties rather than view it as a distraction.  I certainly can't imagine Fluttershy, Rainbow Dash, or Applejack particularly caring about any of that.  Pinkie Pie would probably be bored.

 

Rarity, on the other hand, would love every minute of it. 

[Sparkle 4]

Well if i HAD to choose one, it would probably be rarity over all the others on that list, but if there was no poll on this thread i would say none of them, including twilight!! I just hate the idea of the mane 6 being princesses. When did the show go from being about friendship to who is more important then who... oh right, the last episode of season 3  :okiedokielokie:

Edited September 1, 2013 by Sparkle

[Pinkieparty 15]

As much as I love my pinkie pie I'd have to choose applejack as the next one to become a princess because she's the only one I feel is capable enough to handle it.

[Emerald Heart 25,006]

Fluttershy, as the element of kindness I am sure the ponies would love her. Although it would take her a bit to get used to speaking in front of crowds. She would still live in her cottage as Twilight lives in her library, but Photophinish would constantly send photographers to get pictures of fluttershy. (

[RiseofSpectrum 359]

Oh Applejack, so underappreciated. You are, personality-wise, the best out of the remaining 5, but no one really cares about you...

[Splashee 28,589]

On 8/18/2013 at 8:03 PM, Denim&Venöm said:

So say for some reason Twilight couldn't be promoted to princesshood,  but one of the remaining 5 could,  which of the other mane 6 members would be best for ascension to alicorn?

 

 

None of them really. Not even Twilight fit that role

[Landi 602]

None! I can't see any of the mane 5 becoming a princess. Heck, I still don't think Twilight should've become one. When I started watching the show back during season 2, the idea of any of the mane 6 would become a princess was preposterous. So I definitely don't think any of the others should become one.

But if I had to choose...it'd still be hard. None of the others are the princess type. They all have their own jobs and skills that don't pertain to being a princess. The closest would be Rarity. She's the only one who would like being a princess. So even though I say none should, Rarity would be my choice.