Jump to content
Banner by ~ Wizard
Guidelines

I'd Like Other Ponies Opinions

Azura

By Azura, User

 Share

  

48 users have voted

  1. 1. Which avatar is better?

    • Avatar One
      36
    • Avatar Two
      12

Recommended Posts

Azura

Azura 1,107

(edited)

Hello everypony,

 

I have brought you here, not to cause a war but to listen to everypony's opinion.

 

Avatar One

Posted Image

 

Avatar Two

Posted Image

 

I want to know which one is better from other ponies perspective and not mine.

 

Please do not flame or troll on this thread.

 

To Moderators: If this thread is inappropriate then I apologize.

Edited by Cloud Chaser
  • Brohoof 1

post-3011-0-06850200-1426238081.png

Also known as "Cloud Chaser".

My Ponysona,

Azura.

Avatar & Signature by me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Replies 45
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Popular Posts

Azura
Azura

Hello everypony,   I have brought you here, not to cause a war but to listen to everypony's opinion.   Avatar One   Avatar Two   I want to know which one is better from other ponies perspe

Aureity
Aureity

I personally like the first one better, but I have a suggestion: You shouldn't tell others which is which, so they'll be able to give an honest, unbiased opinion.

thegoodhen
thegoodhen

The second one reminded me of the fact that I'm thirsty. I like pinkies face better on the second one, but the first one is far more original!   What the... You just said the same thing I did, at t

Aureity

Aureity 3,055

I personally like the first one better, but I have a suggestion: You shouldn't tell others which is which, so they'll be able to give an honest, unbiased opinion. ;)

  • Brohoof 1

r2m976.jpg

A lil' Catherine <(^.^)>

Link to comment
Share on other sites
letterone

letterone 1,204

In my opinion the one you made is the best. It's got a much less irritating shade of pink for the background, while that second one there annoys the crap out of me.

It's ironic how I fall just to get back up again...

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Jokuc

Jokuc 8,173

(edited)

The one you have made has higher quality, both the vector and background. The vector is pretty funny too.

 

If I would pick one myself I would chose the one you have made. But the thing the other avatar has is an easier visible text. The text on the one you made is very hard to read.

 

Oh and I agree with Aurora, don't tell which one is which.

 

btw. Maybe you should change "Bought" to "Brought"? x)

Edited by Mr. Pillow

img-2823101-1-UpBh15J.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Nouth

Nouth 496

My subjective opinion is this : The one made by you is more original and more easily recognizable, while the second one looks better for me, while being bit less original. The background on the second one makes it recognizable enough though.

If I was to pick one of these, I'd take the second. I don't like the expression on the first one.

dash.png

Splendid siggy by Chaotic Dischord, awesome avatar by Suntouched Coco!
Ask me anything you want ! You'll make me happy and (most likely) get an answer !
Omnia vincit Amor. When the world around you turns gray, stop, and think about rainbows.
-->(> How would you describe me ? <(<--

Link to comment
Share on other sites
thegoodhen

thegoodhen 698

The second one reminded me of the fact that I'm thirsty. I like pinkies face better on the second one, but the first one is far more original!

 

My subjective opinion is this : The one made by you is more original and more easily recognizable, while the second one looks better for me, while being bit less original. The background on the second one makes it recognizable enough though.

If I was to pick one of these, I'd take the second. I don't like the expression on the first one.

 

What the... You just said the same thing I did, at the same time I did... NINJA AND MIND READER IN ONE PERSON!
  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Azura

Azura 1,107

  • Author

I like the top one best. The bottom one is good also, but the top one is the one that takes the cake.

 

Thanks! :lol:

I personally like the first one better, but I have a suggestion: You shouldn't tell others which is which, so they'll be able to give an honest, unbiased opinion. ;)

 

I never thought of that. :blush:

In my opinion the one you made is the best. It's got a much less irritating shade of pink for the background, while that second one there annoys the crap out of me.

 

I totally agree.

The one you have made has higher quality, both the vector and background. The vector is pretty funny too.

 

If I would pick one myself I would chose the one you have made. But the thing the other avatar has is an easier visible text. The text on the one you made is very hard to read.

 

Oh and I agree with Aurora, don't tell which one is which.

 

btw. Maybe you should change "Bought" to "Brought"? x)

 

I fixed it, thanks for noticing.

 

I also think the text isn't that visible. :blink:

post-3011-0-06850200-1426238081.png

Also known as "Cloud Chaser".

My Ponysona,

Azura.

Avatar & Signature by me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Azura

Azura 1,107

  • Author

My subjective opinion is this : The one made by you is more original and more easily recognizable, while the second one looks better for me, while being bit less original. The background on the second one makes it recognizable enough though.

If I was to pick one of these, I'd take the second. I don't like the expression on the first one.

 

Thanks for your opinion, it's greatly appreciated. :)

The second one reminded me of the fact that I'm thirsty. I like pinkies face better on the second one, but the first one is far more original!

 

Originality eh? :P

Top one is the best, because it looks "crazy" shows pinkie pie more.

 

**************filler*************************

 

I agree, it brings out Pinkie's true self. :lol:

post-3011-0-06850200-1426238081.png

Also known as "Cloud Chaser".

My Ponysona,

Azura.

Avatar & Signature by me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
MrL0LZ

MrL0LZ 866

The first one, its more.... aesthetically pleasing. Also the vector is better and it collides with the background better.

Signature2_zps1695e437.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Nah

Nah 3,182

I'd go for the second one, its a little bit better than the first one, hope that would help you make your mind up. :)
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Dragonshy

Dragonshy 2,305

(I was a bit annoyed aswell Cloud Chaser ;))

The first one wins indefinently. Better quality, more work put into it, somewhat symetrical. The second has two exclamation marks and is written in an ugly font. The second looks like it took maybe 5 minutes at a maximum. That is my opinion.

Yeh


 


Want to know how to get more page views? Click here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Ol' Sarge

Ol' Sarge 885

You have a pretty good split going on here with the above opinions. I like that the first one has more originality. It doesn't look like every other Pinkie Pie avatar.

Untitled-20.png

This Signature Brought to you by Dragonshy Signature Service

Link to comment
Share on other sites
SPLinux

SPLinux 380

I like the first of the two avatars the best, its really unique looking, the second one is pretty nice too,

the expression on the first avatar catches my attention a little bit more.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Azura

Azura 1,107

  • Author

Bottom one is lacking something I think, It feels kinda empty. Maybe if it had ponies in the back partying with pinkie at the forefront it would be better

 

I agree.

umm..i like them both quite a bit..but i think the text and background make the first better...i think the second looks a little basic

 

Thanks!

The first one, its more.... aesthetically pleasing. Also the vector is better and it collides with the background better.

 

It sure is pleasing. ;)

I'd go for the second one, its a little bit better than the first one, hope that would help you make your mind up. :)

 

Okay. :blink:

(I was a bit annoyed aswell Cloud Chaser ;))

The first one wins indefinently. Better quality, more work put into it, somewhat symetrical. The second has two exclamation marks and is written in an ugly font. The second looks like it took maybe 5 minutes at a maximum. That is my opinion.

 

I completely agree with Dragonshy. :lol:

I gotta say, the top one seems to catch my attention more than the 2nd one, and that face on the first one :3

 

I know right? :)

I think the bottom one is much more pleasing to look at, but I think the top is better suited for an avatar.

 

It stands out from the crowd.

I like the first one better. I love the huge-pupil look on her face, it's cute and suits her character.

 

Thanks!

You have a pretty good split going on here with the above opinions. I like that the first one has more originality. It doesn't look like every other Pinkie Pie avatar.

 

Agreed.

I like the second one myself. Shows her in her natural form...partying!!!

 

So yeah I guess since I must type more...the second one

 

How does it even show her partying? She's just standing still..

I like the first of the two avatars the best, its really unique looking, the second one is pretty nice too,

the expression on the first avatar catches my attention a little bit more.

 

Catchy. ;)
  • Brohoof 1

post-3011-0-06850200-1426238081.png

Also known as "Cloud Chaser".

My Ponysona,

Azura.

Avatar & Signature by me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Azura

Azura 1,107

  • Author
(edited)

I demand a poll!!!!

I like the second one better, the lighter pink makes for a better background imo and it's more recognizable and memorable :) ! ~

 

I completely forgot to add a poll for this.

 

Thanks for telling me, I've added a poll so everypony can vote!

Edited by Cloud Chaser
  • Brohoof 1

post-3011-0-06850200-1426238081.png

Also known as "Cloud Chaser".

My Ponysona,

Azura.

Avatar & Signature by me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Join the herd!

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...