Overrated/Underrated Characters?

[River Melody 2]

Overrated: Fluttershy. She's super cute but that's really all...

 

Underrated: The Cutie Mark Crusaders! I want to see more of them and their little shenanigans.

[Lostwanderer 366]

Overated:None, it's impossible to overate a pony.

Underated:All the ponies, as they are all more awesoem then anyone gives them credit for.

[Dreadmallon 353]

Overrated: Fluttershy. She's super cute but that's really all...

 

Underrated: The Cutie Mark Crusaders! I want to see more of them and their little shenanigans.

 

 

I agree with overrated, but the CMC don't deserve crap. They're annoying.

[Penny Lane 7]

Rainbow Dash is overrated. I may just be saying this because my FB friends have posted at least 100 pictures of Rainbow Dash in the last 2 weeks -_- I think that may be the only pony they know...

[Jokuc 8,172]

Underrated: Spitfire, Applejack, Luna

Overrated: Vinyl (I'm not a fan of Vinyl at all sorry)

 

Haha I disagree.

Overrated: Luna

Underrated: Vinyl Scratch

 

 

 

 

I agree with overrated, but the CMC don't deserve crap. They're annoying.

 

Whaaaat?! The cmcs are awesome!

[Iris Melody 90]

Underrated: RAINBOWSHINE!

 

 

Overrated: (is that possible?)

[Dreadmallon 353]

Haha I disagree.

Overrated: Luna

Underrated: Vinyl Scratch

 

 

Whaaaat?! The cmcs are awesome!

 

I don't like 'em.

[be my waifu 2,842]

Underrated: Carrot Top

 

She is best pony

[Yurusumaji 33]

Overrated: Cadence.

 

Underrated: Big Mac & Applejack.

[AnonyPoni 564]

Overrated....Got nothin'

 

 

Underrated: Those awesome bat ponies that pull Luna's chariot. BAT PONIES!

[Leo 5]

I would say the underrated character would be Applejack. I think it could be her voice, and that I think many people, myself included, find it hard to relate to Applejack.

 

The overrated character in my opinion would be Derpy. I don't know why she is getting so much attention.

 

No offence if I caused any.

[Chantilly Angel 52]

Overrated: All the background ponies, and Fluttershy. (It's not really her, it's the fan(boy)s that drive me crazy!)

Underrated: Applejack, Rarity, and Spike. Can't forget about him!

[Emerald Glow 40]

Overrated: the background "fan-service" ponies: Dr. Whooves, Derpy, etc, They're fun where's waldo sight gags, but that's about it.

Underrated: Hmm. Maybe Applejack.

[Private Pansy 32]

Overrated - Scootaloo, OCs, Luna, Trixie, Lyra

 

 

Underrated -

 

Braeburn

Edited July 17, 2012 by Private Pansy

[Light Speed 11]

I think Derpys definitly overrated though

[Swit Swat 536]

Overrated:The Great and Powerful Trixie. *Please don't hurt me*

 

Underrated:Snips, Snails, Applejack.

[Guest]

Underrated: That purple/ginger lake dragon from the first episode.

 

Overrated: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic.

 

[Dreadmallon 353]

Overrated: CMC's (Scootaloo, especially), Fluttershy (still best pony though), Derpy, and Trixie.

 

Underrated: zecora.

[MaggieXawesomeness 24]

Overrated- Trixie

Underrated- Doctor Whooves or Pinkie Pie :

[Homura Akemi 974]

I fail to see how Luna is underrated. She was voted the 5th most popular pony, and she's not even in 10 episodes. Really? I don't hate her, for I hate no pony, but she is my least favorite princess. How can she be underrated if she has nothing but hype?

[Starstream 182]

I felt like AJ was left out that's why she's my avatar. :3 I think one of the most overated characters are Rainbow Dash tbh.

 

Do you realize how ironic it is to read that after you've changed your avatar to Rainbow Dash, of all ponies?

[dreaper 136]

For me is:

 

Most overrated of the mane 6: Rainbow Dash

 

Most overrated ever: Derpy

 

-

 

Most underrated of the mane 6: Applejack

 

Most underrated ever: Spike

[Radiance64 7,052]

Fluttershy is overrated- I'm guilty of liking her too though.

[Half-Note 273]

Underrated: Crackle. We need more Crackle.

 

Overrated: If I had to pick Its Celestia. Princess not God.

[Isobel 279]

Overrated:

 

Fluttershy: Everyone will kill me, but she just...doesn't appeal to me. And though she's cute, ALL the ponies are cute And I personally find Pinkie Pie's appearance and personality more adorable

 

Derpy: I like Derpy, but I find the overwhelming amount of attention for her a bit much.

 

Vinyl Scratch: Again, I like her, but the fact that she's some people's favorites is quite odd.

 

Luna: Everyone loves Luna, it seems. And yes, Luna's nice, but the amount of adoration for her is really annoying. Paired with the hate towards Celestia, it's even worse.

 

Underrated:

 

Applejack: Like a lot of people have said, Applejack in underrated. Why? I think Applejack is adorable and fun to watch! Her design is amazing, I love her color scheme - the blonde, the orange, and the green!

 

Rarity: People don't really enjoy Rarity because they can't find themself in her, so therefore gather her as annoying and snobbish. Also, people who don't think deep enough into her character, and just view the outside.

 

Celestia: I'm in the process of writing a sad fanfiction that looks into the life of Celestia, in the hopes of helping others understand her more. Everyone loves Luna, and then they forget about Celestia. Personally, I prefer Celestia over Luna.