Worst MLP Fanfictions

[Wingnut 6,988]

I haven't read too many fanfics, but the worst one I've read (well, listened to on Youtube) is called Fluffy which is about Twilight Sparkle and Fluffle Puff. For this fic, Fluffle was male and Twilight had a mad sexual obsession with him. If you haven't guessed, it was a clop fic. It was pretty bad. Props to the guy who did the reading as I don't think I could have done it with a straight face.

[MidnightBlue 51]

I just read 120 days of Blueblood, and it was without a doubt the funniest thing I ever read. Granted, it went way past the depths of human depravity, including things as taboo as necrophilia. Even so, it actually managed to have a plot and a decent writing style. It's bad, but read it if you have no sense of morality.

[HunterTSN 1,444]

I wouldn't know the bad ones because if I don't like the first chapter then I don't finish it. However if you want some recommendations I would be happy to help.

 

Oh wait, I remember one; it's called Equestria Girls.

Edited July 11, 2013 by TheSteampunkNinja (TSN)

[GeneralDirection 1,043]

Scootaloo's love for pain. It comes to mind almost instantly when the words "bad" and "fanfic" are used together.

 

Or was that really just awesome in disguise

Nope XD

This is what I had in mind actually. ^^

Also, And Then They Did It is a pretty content-less and mindless story. One can only imagine what it's about...

[Astrobrony 655]

The worst one I've ever read was called 'Momma Fluttershy'.  What Fluttershy goes through in that story is just....  incredibly messed up in every sense of the word.  

[MidnightBlue 51]

I wouldn't know the bad ones because if I don't like the first chapter then I don't finish it. However if you want some recommendations I would be happy to help.

 

Oh wait, I remember one; it's called Equestria Girls.

Why so much mindless hate for a mindless film? The last time I ever heard of a film being recieved this badly was when AVPR came out. Equestria Girls made that movie look amazing.

[HunterTSN 1,444]

Why so much mindless hate for a mindless film? The last time I ever heard of a film being recieved this badly was when AVPR came out. Equestria Girls made that movie look amazing.

I'm just kidding, Equestria Girls wasn't nearly as bad a I suspected it would be, but I still like to think of it as an official fan product rather than canon.

Edited July 11, 2013 by TheSteampunkNinja (TSN)

[dedacct6 2,591]

I read quite a few crappy fan fics...you guys should all know these ones. Sweet Apple acres, and Cupcakes *blech* i dont know whats more disgusting, the terrible writing and lack of story, or how much bucking gore there is in the damn thing. I read other bad fanfics, but i cant remember the friggen names...

[Scootalove 10,689]

Sweet Apple Massacre might have been a scary fan fiction but, it just wasn't executed well when it comes to a lot of effort put into a story or at least some development.

[Capt. Snuggle Gruff 101]

I don't even read Fanfics.  I mean yeah sure I bet they are great, but I would like to keep my idea of MLP completely to the canon.  Again no offense to any fanfics I bet they are amazing, just not for me.

[DND 2,355]

I would say anything that doesn't even have proper or 'mature' grammar even with the story description. I know that not all stories have preview descriptions, but any hints of poor grammar makes a pretty poor story. BELIEVE ME. I read F.F. all the time. Not just MLP ones.

[dashie99 8]

I don't even think this is a question. Sweet Apple Massacre is the worst fanfic i've ever seen. It makes cupcakes sound like a g-rated movie.

[Cody Blair 0]

what about Trixie and Lyra's Pinecone Adventure? It's not gory, but DEFINITELY disturbing. It made me wonder what the heck I'm doing with my life.

[Pripyat Pony 2,608]

I admit that sometimes I deliberately seek out bad fanfiction to rip apart. I belong to an LJ sporking community and it's fun to do. I'd love to spork a MLP badfic, but I've never found one yet that's bad enough. I don't mean disgusting, or gory; my prefered type of badfic is one starring a loathsome Mary Sue. If anypony can oblige... XD

[Mand'alor Dash 2,224]

I admit that sometimes I deliberately seek out bad fanfiction to rip apart. I belong to an LJ sporking community and it's fun to do. I'd love to spork a MLP badfic, but I've never found one yet that's bad enough. I don't mean disgusting, or gory; my prefered type of badfic is one starring a loathsome Mary Sue. If anypony can oblige... XD

Merry Christmas.

 

Prepare yourself for the suefic to end all suefics. A fanfic written by an egotistical hipster about how great his animu Mary Sue is, and how she somehow found herself a cliche'd animu villain trying to destroy Equestria.

[Pripyat Pony 2,608]

Merry Christmas.

 

Prepare yourself for the suefic to end all suefics. A fanfic written by an egotistical hipster about how great his animu Mary Sue is, and how she somehow found herself a cliche'd animu villain trying to destroy Equestria.

Ugh, that made me feel physically ill just reading the first chapter. -.- Some people really need to get a clue and not force such atrocities upon the internet.

[Sectus 246]

Merry Christmas.

 

Prepare yourself for the suefic to end all suefics. A fanfic written by an egotistical hipster about how great his animu Mary Sue is, and how she somehow found herself a cliche'd animu villain trying to destroy Equestria.

 

I couldn't even bring myself to read that one, let alone submit a decent length review of it. It's just too hateful and anti-show for me.

Edited July 26, 2013 by Sectus

[Fergus Mo 21]

Without a doubt, it was Return of the Changeling's [sic] by RawHavoc.

http://www.fimfiction.net/story/45746/return-of-the-changelings-reedit-ms

 

It was so bad FIMfiction had to nuke the comments section THREE TIMES because of all the flak it was getting. The third time they just gave up and made the story link-only. You can't even find it in a search. It used to be completely incoherent, but when some beta editing made it readable, it was revealed to be offensive and trollish as well.

 

I took it down in an epic review a few months ago after my friends all begged me to read it. 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q0cikhW_Ndk

Lol, it doesn't even exist anymore.

 

But yeah...my least favorite fanfic was this trollfic on fanfiction.net. It was about Twilight saving Equestria, but contained the grammer, spelling, maturity, continuity of a 2-year-old. I don't remember the name, though.

[Fender 1,283]

Basically: Any fanfic based solely around sex. Clopfics.

 

Bloody pointless, at least in my opinion.

 

I don't particularly like human in Equestria fics either. Just come off as a bit...lame...to me.

[Mand'alor Dash 2,224]

Ugh, that made me feel physically ill just reading the first chapter. -.- Some people really need to get a clue and not force such atrocities upon the internet.

 

 

I couldn't even bring myself to read that one, let alone submit a decent length review of it. It's just too hateful and anti-show for me.

 

Relevant.

 

Because if people complain that your characters are one-dimensional and your plotlines are mean-spirited, just throw in some porn!

[Super Derpy 535]

The worst I've seen are the My Brave Pony: Starfleet Magic series. They are just really,really poorly written. There also a lot of bad grimdark or gory fanfics out there.

Edited July 26, 2013 by Super Derpy

[Dr. Eggnog 203]

I read a short clopfic called Apple Juice once that was my least favorite.  Let's just say that for a while I would cringe anytime I heard the word apple juice, and since I work in a restaurant it happens more often than you might think.

[Khaoios 1,970]

well, there arn't that many that are really rubbish. but i can give you some recommendations if you want to read good stuffs

(atleast, i enjoyed them)

 

- fallout equestria

- my little dashie

- MIA equestria

- vinyl & octavia: university days

- treating her right

- worlds apart

- hells angel

- sweet treats and royal delights

 

i hope you'll enjoy these as much as i have

Read a few of those but i gotta say the worst one i read was Fallout: Equestria. Have a post-apocalyptic event in MLP is dumb as hell. I can understand villains destroying but something involving a "human mistake" (and by that i mean outbreaks of deadly diseases, radioactive weaponry), is just no-no.

[Live Forever 316]

Basically: Any fanfic based solely around sex. Clopfics.

 

One of my favorite MLP fanfics is the clopfic Mirror Mirror. Then again, it stays as a heartwarming story throughout, so if you don't mind the clop, read it.

 

Speaking of clopfics, I hate Breakfast. It is just disgusting.

[Princess Pinny 6,099]

That with Pinkie Pie and no Rainbow Dash.