Trends in the fandom you wish would just die

[Gestum 2,493]

The hate for Pony generator. Not everyone can draw nor does everyone want someone else to draw their OC.

[AtomicStone 724]

Pinkamena being some sort of murderous psychopath.. Never understood it, never will..

[Pripyat Pony 2,608]

The hate for Pony generator. Not everyone can draw nor does everyone want someone else to draw their OC.

Also, a lot of people who say, "Pay someone to draw your OC!" Yeah, cuz everypony has money to burn on buying art. -.-

[DANUTERCISD 204]

Bronies who get butthurt over mature rated subjects about ponies.

 

Bronies who use MLP as an excuse to NOT be a man.

i  agree. Also bronies need to get over porn, every fandom has porn, it will never go away. The best thing to do is to not talk about it.

also, Nothing is wrong with using a pony generator. 

also, scootaloo is not a fucking chicken. JUST BECAUSE OF ONE EPISODE? THATS STUPID!!

Also, OCS.

Edited March 1, 2016 by DANUTERCISD

[ARagY 1,152]

Sparity.

 

Spike is a kid, and Rarity is an adult. Some fans hate Rarity for not loving Spike back. Do they WANT Rarity be to be a pedophile? 

Yeah actually 

 

I don't know, are there even trends in this fandom? 

 

OCs that remotely resemble Rainbow Dash for no reason

Alicorns 

Fics about some single character who is overpowered in comparison to everyone around him; you can have stronger characters than humans could ever hope for, so long as there is character development, decisions, and real challenges. This is why One Punch Man is interesting and (for me) Superman falls flat. 

Mega-edgy grimdark fics

Mega-boring lighthearted fics

 

02. Any and all references such as "Coming out as a brony" or "coming out of the stable" that make an absolute mockery of the real pain and emotional stress of coming out as bi or homosexual by pretending that admitting to watching a 22 minute cartoon is just as life altering.

ayyy ^ dis here

Flagging R34 tumblrs (e.g. Princess Molestia) because a few pics had scootaloo ...aww cartoon ponies must really cut deep into your childhood hmm?

git over et

 

If you ask me, all that vore, shipping, and porn artwork can go die in a fire.

 

Nah, how about we increase it by 40%? Vive la ship artwork and whatever porn we've churned out today

and low key vore

Edited March 1, 2016 by ARagY

[DANUTERCISD 204]

i want molestia back. because i never got to see it, or clop to it(jk maybe)

[cuteycindyhoney 13,307]

i want molestia back. because i never got to see it, or clop to it(jk maybe)

Molestia wasn't quite as graphic in it's artwork as many would leave you o believe. Much of it was silly stuff, such as Molestia wearing odd cosplay outfits and the like. It did get quite risque at times though. Not condoning this or anything, but shortly after the take-down, I totally accidentally and by mistake activated a Bit Torrent file. Before I realized what I had done, the whole Molestia Tumbr site prior to the take-down landed on my hard drive.

[Ze Ubermage 226]

YouTube comment wars between the bronies and the non bronies. It's just really annoying in my opinion.

[Luminance 2,186]

All of the NSFW material. Its a show for children for crying out loud.Google image search "Mlp" and I get a crap load of disgusting, rude, gross-out content that shouldnt even be made in the first place.

[aoEAF2FBvC0MIo2Q 3,673]

 

 

1. I definitely wouldn't call the fandom special, but it still is pretty unique, especially in terms of talent level.

So according to you, the brony fandom really is more talented than other fandoms? Are you being serious? It's one thing to say that there are a lot of talented fans but that can easily be attributed to the fandom's size.

 

 

 

2. Well, it is made up of good people, but with bad people in addition. Just like anything else, don't associate yourself with those weirdos who take it too far.

Indeed it can be quite risky, if not outright foolish, to assume the best in everyone. Best be on your guard with people whether they are bronies or whatever else -- it's really all the same. 

 

 

 

3. Haven't really heard anyone use it except Anti-Bronies.

 

Says a lot about just how deeply that phrase has fallen from grace. Back in mid 2011 when I was fresh meat a new brony, bronies took that phrase "Love and Tolerance" to heart, even if just implicitly.

[Kapitan zur See Hans (Daz) 883]

All of the NSFW material. Its a show for children for crying out loud.Google image search "Mlp" and I get a crap load of disgusting, rude, gross-out content that shouldnt even be made in the first place.

I think you have your filters off then, because when I look up mlp terms with them on I very rarely ever encounter nsfw unless it is a term that would be something related to nsfw. The only issue you really encounter is when the filters do not keep up with demand, considering most image stay on certain sites it does a fairly good job catching it. I also did search "Mlp" with safe search one, didn't even find anything remotely nsfw on the entire first page(Even off I only found 1 image and it was of dark pinkamena). If safe search is off on a child's computer that is the fault of the individual who has it off.

Edited March 1, 2016 by Commissar Twilight

[BlinkZ 1,151]

Also, a lot of people who say, "Pay someone to draw your OC!" Yeah, cuz everypony has money to burn on buying art. -.-

Yeah that..nothing wrong with pony creators well expect for Dusk Dawn *shivers*

 

aslo  know this wishful thinking but dam I wish the fanodm had more oh straight shipping instead of lik 80 same gender..this fandom wow so many transgenders and such it just yikes!!

[Luminance 2,186]

I think you have your filters off then, because when I look up mlp terms with them on I very rarely ever encounter nsfw unless it is a term that would be something related to nsfw. The only issue you really encounter is when the filters do not keep up with demand, considering most image stay on certain sites it does a fairly good job catching it. I also did search "Mlp" with safe search one, didn't even find anything remotely nsfw on the entire first page(Even off I only found 1 image and it was of dark pinkamena). If safe search is off on a child's computer that is the fault of the individual who has it off.

It still exist anyway but lurking in the deep depths of the internet.I just can't stand it.

[ARagY 1,152]

All of the NSFW material. Its a show for children for crying out loud.Google image search "Mlp" and I get a crap load of disgusting, rude, gross-out content that shouldnt even be made in the first place.

All for desexualisation, but why should people not be allowed to make said images about it? Are you really so violently repulsed by it you'd want it to never exist for those who like it?

 

I don't particularly like dogs, but if someone wants to do doggy art and I happen to see it while browsing hte internet, I'm not going to be a. surprised or b. act like my innocence was taken or something

[Luminance 2,186]

All for desexualisation, but why should people not be allowed to make said images about it? Are you really so violently repulsed by it you'd want it to never exist for those who like it?

 

I don't particularly like dogs, but if someone wants to do doggy art and I happen to see it while browsing hte internet, I'm not going to be a. surprised or b. act like my innocence was taken or something

It just devalues whatever/whomever it portrays in that regard.

[ARagY 1,152]

It just devalues whatever/whomever it portrays in that regard.

 

Subjective value of devaluation, really

 

I'd argue it only does so when a character is deemed as a sex object rather than a person/animal/whatever

 

*Which is not the entire case*

Edited March 1, 2016 by ARagY

[Kapitan zur See Hans (Daz) 883]

@@ARagY

 

Love how your sig fits perfectly with this thread, also happy birthday.

 

 

It still exist anyway but lurking in the deep depths of the internet.I just can't stand it.

Don't think about it then, if this bothers you that much I'd hate to see worse how you may react to things such as snuff films and the like.

 

 

 

Before anyone says it I know this may be a complaint thread and I complained as well, but sometimes it is interesting to reply to others complaints when they are so strongly held.

Edited March 1, 2016 by Commissar Twilight

[Luminance 2,186]

Before anyone says it I know this may be a complaint thread and I complained as well, but sometimes it is interesting to reply to others complaints when they are so strongly held.

I've really appreciate this thread as I've been wanting to get something off my chest ever since I joined the fandom.

 

-Thanks

Edited March 1, 2016 by MiataPony

[Lil Pip 775]

The thing that I really want most gone is hypnotizing yourself to be a pony. The reason I say this is because it is down right STUPID (Sorry if you have done it, I am directing any hate towards anyone, I just don't like the idea). Now, I have read the disclaimer several times over and I think the disadvantages outweigh the advantage. I would rather read a whole terms and conditions than hypnotise myself as a pony. Now, to quote Jeff Foxworthy:

 

"Nine times out of ten, the side-effects are fifty times worse than what the thing cures. It's like, "Try new Fluorofluor. For itchy, watery eyes, it's Fluorofluor. Side effects may include: nausea, vomiting, water weight gain, lower back pain, receding hairline, eczema, seporiasoriasis, itching, chafing clothing, liver spots, blood clots, ringworm, excessive body odor, uneven tire wear, pyorrhea, gonorrhea, diarrhea, halitosis, scoliosis, loss of bladder control, hammertoe, the shanks, low sperm count, warped floors, cluttered drawers, hunchback, heart attack, low resale value on your home... feline leukemia, athlete's foot, head lice, clubfoot, MS, MD, VD, fleas, anxiety, sleeplessness, drowsiness, poor gas mileage, tooth decay, parvo, warts, unibrow, lazy eye, fruit flies, chest pains, clogged drains, hemorrhoids, dry heaving and sexual dysfunction." I'm watching it, going, "You know what? I'll just have itchy, watery eyes..."

I've tried it, didn't work outrageously well or anything(itd take months of daily use to really get a good effect going, minor effects abound but strong effects not so much, prolly has to do with the wording of the script) but the community has on and off drama and I sorta agree with you. The major warning being EKP if you try to use multiple files that contradict, but I took cognitive affirmations to prevent the issue and I didn't get the issue(warning is mostly there for removal of liability). Also for the love of all thats holy especially do not try the youtube video pet file. Thats the source of 90% of drama or psychological issues that occur in the community.  I mean one issue with the files is inconsistency to work, but the pet file literally will cripple you socially if misused, and let others abuse you if they know for some reason that you use it. Only reason why people think most of the drama isn't from that is because theres a ban on talking about it at the site so others dont get the genius idea of using it.

 

But also everyone crying about clop, I think clop > most porn emotionally and relevantly speaking.

Edited March 2, 2016 by Lil Pip

[P1nkiedank 125]

Obsession over Luna, Rainbow Dash, Derpy, etc:

 

Shipping, honestly why? Too many gay and lesbian ships as well. And even shipping two family members? Why people?

 

Clopping. I've seen horrifying images of gore, clop, etc: like why? It ruins the whole aspect of "Happy and Colorful."

[Luna the Great of all the Russias 2,985]

8. Pontifications that make no sense or are legitimately tasteless. Crossing it over with another piece of media is great, but trying to ponify Hitler or Donald Trump (pun intended) is ridiculous. Oh, and don't get me started on the pontification of the HOLOCAUST and 9/11!!!!

When you have interest in both ponies and history, this sort of ponification happens... at least if you're me specifically. I already ponified, say, politicians including Hitler and did create an image depicting Nazi prison/concentration camp (I didn't plan specifically which it was though the image was to depict that notable Nazi OC negatively rather than positively). Anyway, avoid my content I suppose.

 

Says a lot about just how deeply that phrase has fallen from grace. Back in mid 2011 when I was fresh meat a new brony, bronies took that phrase "Love and Tolerance" to heart, even if just implicitly.

Also being Brony since 2011, I would say that "love and tolerance" was not used legitimately by majority of the fandom. I still remember many Bronies still being notably angry towards those who were against them, and phrase "love and tolerance" was originally made to troll anti-Bronies anyhow.

 

Pinkie being a psychopath. 

 

There was one time where she went crazy after she believed that her friends didn't like her anymore, but Pinkie is not a psychopath. She can feel remorse, truly cares about her friends, and wouldn't want to hurt anyone. She's not a psychopath.

I think this is obvious. But remember, Lyra's obsession with humans originated from her sitting like a human in one scene. Same thing happened to Pinkie becoming Cupcakes Pinkamena.

 

 

Human Rainbow having big breasts.

 

I swear, finding one where she's small is hard. She's an athlete! Big breasts don't make any sense! I don't mind Fluttershy having big breasts, but Rainbow doesn't make any sense.

I don't know how that's possible because when I see anthro or humanized Dash, vast majority of them depict her with smaller breasts.

 

All of the NSFW material. Its a show for children for crying out loud.Google image search "Mlp" and I get a crap load of disgusting, rude, gross-out content that shouldnt even be made in the first place.

Perhaps consider using Derpibooru to search for MLPFIM images because that site has a more advanced filtering system.

[Zantetsuken 364]

Analysis in in general 

 

And people obsessing over every tiny detail. If there is so much as a character with a wrong sounding voice, A WRONG NAME EVEN, your gonna fucking hear it yelled out loud from the rooftops by some dude.

 

That is a trend that needs to die I wish more people would just enjoy the show without obsessing over every wrong the step the show makes or MIGHT make.

[ARagY 1,152]

Shipping, honestly why? Too many gay and lesbian ships as well. And even shipping two family members? Why people?

 

Clopping. I've seen horrifying images of gore, clop, etc: like why? It ruins the whole aspect of "Happy and Colorful."

There are several places where family marriages are legal.. those are mostly Asian countries

 

And again, is clopping that bad? Here's a tip: Don't search for MLP on Google. Use Derpibooru and blacklist tags like sex, blowjobs, etc. Honestly, I've only found clop when I was the one at fault - searching google (which is a search engine, mind you, it gives you results of what you typed, NOT what you thought) for pictures when its much better (for efficiency, too) to use Derpibooru, which defaults to hide suggestive - explicit content, although I always turn it off but that's a story for another time. Aaaanyway, you shouldn't find it unless you're being really lazy about searching, you aren't taking protective measures, and/or you're walking into a trap.

 

But also everyone crying about clop, I think clop > most porn emotionally and relevantly speaking.

The thing about clop artwork is that it's done in a different perspective to human stuff. These are things maybe someone who isn't a frequent studier of art may notice, idk. But there are subtleties that add up to a difference when it comes to some of the big artists (Joseco, fearingfun, Omi, etc..) in their work versus the smut you'll find on just about any porn site. I'm not trying to go "cloppin is classy *fedora tip*" here, but I'm serious that there's a difference in how things are presented and the intended effect. It's an interesting thing I'd like to know more about, because I look at the same thing when I look at the difference between perspectives of two well-drawn OCs and feel the desire to know one better than the other.

Edited March 2, 2016 by ARagY

[Jeric 46,851]

We are locking this topic. It stands as a monument to posting the same negative topics over and over again that exist elsewhere. For one, it feeds into self perpetuating negativity. It has been the source of drama multiple times now. Most importantly for me, it is duplicating and fragmenting other standalone discussions. Look, criticizing the fandom and the show are fine here ... but there is a way to do it. 

 

I am reminded of a Cosby Show episode where Cliff Huxtable claims that presentation is key when he compares serving a fillet minot on a trashcan lid. It obviously makes the steak less appetizing, just as some of these comments undermine an otherwise valid point. Ideas on a trashcan usually don't elevate discussion.