The Smile, Smile, Smile Challenge!

[Demiurge 108]

Imposhibible! Imposhibible!

I knew there was no chance, so I watched the video just to make sure. I smiled before I even pressed play.

[Planty 1,052]

Its impossible to look at Pinkie Pie without smiling!!!!

 

let alone the entire song!

 

gotta be my third fav MLP song

[Parties like Pinkie 385]

I have a theory that it is impossible to listen to Smile, Smile, Smile withouth smiling. So my challenge to all the bronies is to listen to the song and try not to smile (smirking and laughing counts). If you think you need more of a challenge try singing the song without smiling. If you can then you are the toughest pony that I have ever met!

 

 

 

Well, I did it.

 

Now, if you'll excuse me, I need to make a doctor's appointment. I think I might be a mule.

[Lunar Guardian 80]

I lost at 15 seconds. I knew I was about to crack. I could just feel it coming on. It's just impossible.

[Brook 663]

God danmit! That's so impossible!

 

I smiled like 5 seconds into the song! And I was thinking of tragic stuff beforehand on purpose!

[Radiance64 7,051]

I can't do it! It's too awesome and cute, how can I?

 

And that, my dear sirs, is all that I have to say on this topic (yet i must fulfill the character limit).

 

That scared the hell out of me... D:

[pinkiefan1287 610]

It can't be done. I mean it's such a happy and joyful song. How can I not smile when I here thing song?

[lerandombrony 0]

I listened to it, and having in mind that I wasn't allowed to smile, I immediatly began smiling and laughing...

[Dusty Soul 2,611]

Well I failed 10 times, and I won't be continuing the challenge. What you propose if done will likely result in a nuclear explosion that blasts a hole in the ozone so big that the moon will crash into the Earth...

So I failed.

[Dotter 4]

It took me 6 tries but I did it. I don't know how I did it but I know have full control over every muscle in my face.

[KakeiTheWolf 652]

Okay, I've seen it several times, and I have NEVER smiled during it. Primarily because it's centering around a formulaic and bastardized form of happiness that does not appeal to me in any way.

 

So, yeah, the moment I saw the episode (And a non-brony commentary of the episode), I won your challenge. Forgive me if I seem an exceptionally cold person because I'm not infatuated with a song centered around a puerile, garish little ditz.

 

That, and Pinkie Pie makes me feel an overwhelming urge to go to Equestria and stab her.

Edited August 13, 2012 by KakeiTheWolf

[Lightning Fluttershy 1,844]

Ahhhh I was so close! I put on my best poker face and listened to it all until the last few seconds then pinkie pie got to me and I burst out in a big smile!

[Hawk 100]

Challenge denied! It's no good... I can't do it!

 

Just thinking about the song is making me smile. I wouldn't last 10 seconds. Now it's stuck in my head even though I haven't listened to the song in awhile.

[Jalaton 155]

I think I'll give it a shot since I've been able to not smile for things before. Don't know how I'll do for the singing though.

[Sky 746]

I did it. Surprisingly enough its not that difficult for me to not smile at things. Because smiling feels uncomfortable to me

[Luna317 43]

I CANT DO IT!!! i Smile every time!!! and hears an awesome mash up of Smile,Smile,Smile https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WqM-l9165zk

[Midnightive 458]

haha i did it on my third try!

 

first time: laughed as soon as it started

 

second time: my name is pinkiepie

 

third time: come on everypony smile smile smile feel my heart up with sunshine sunshine

 

but four time i had a poker face! They may have turned into a bad poker face every so often.

[Dreadmallon 353]

Please, you really consider this a challenge? I can do this so easily!

 

*watches video*

 

WHY AM I SMILING?!

[Xievie 498]

I can manage not smiling, but if you make me sing it? Oh Celestia my mouth is gonna fall off trying not to smile.

[Waplon 14]

I didn't smile either, but that's largely due to the fact that when I listen to music I like, I tend to let my mind get wrapped up in the music, and this is no exception.

 

Some of the responses to this thread, on the other hand...

[Book 45]

I do not accept this challenge. Instead I will open up the karaoke version of "Smile Smile Smile" and sing it to myself until I am satisfied and beaming like no other. Who is with me!

[thegoodhen 698]

Uh. I bursted into laughter the moment you mentioned Smile song.

[Moved to Elsewhere 11,329]

I did it it was very hard I had to force frown and I didn't even sing along.

Do I get a prize maybe a cookie.

[Charming Knight 56]

i got through the whole song with out smiling then i decided time to go ahead and sing i got through about half way but i just couldn't resist smilling cause it makes you happy no matter what =3 hahah

[RainbowAwesome 26]

I did it it was very hard I had to force frown and I didn't even sing along.

Do I get a prize maybe a cookie.

 

I did it it was very hard I had to force frown and I didn't even sing along.

Do I get a prize maybe a cookie.

 

Okay. I'll give you a cookie. It's gonna be chocolate chip so I hope you aren't allergic to chocolate.