Jump to content
Banner by ~ Ice Princess Silky

Skyling

User
  • Posts

    40
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Skyling

  1. Yes, they were. Even discounting things like magic and flight, there is something even more basic that dooms them horribly - population numbers. Yaks live in the freaking arctic - there is only so much population that such conditions can support without heavy use of magic (Crystal Empire). It would be like an angry Eskimo tribe declaring war on Canada. The first Equestrian border city they could try and attack has a good chance of having more population than the Yaks have combined.
  2. Because they are more likely to accept your offer of friendship after you are done beating them into the ground and depriving them of all other options.
  3. In terms of personal wealth it's probably Rarity, but Twilight kinda muddies that up with being one of the monarchs of the nation. I mean, she probably isn't sitting on a huge vault stuffed full of bits that she can swim in, but if she decided one day that she wants a, say, skyscraper built in Ponyville she could probably clap her hooves and make it happen. If we define "richest" by physical money available on hoof, that's probably Rarity. If we define it by ability to obtain stuff (of any kind and scale), then Twilight's likely in a league of her own with the other princesses.
  4. Throw a dart randomly; whomever it lands on, it can't possibly be as bad as the people behind season 6
  5. The Cutie Map 1 & 2: In the hopes that by removing these episodes, the blight that is Starlight Glimmer never gets to impose itself upon the show. Past that ... hmm, perhaps Mysterious Mare Do Well - that one featured some shoddy characterization all around.
  6. She is certainly powerful alright, but on Twilight's level? No, she fall quite short of the mark there. Yes, she technically "fought" Twilight to a standstill during the finale, but the fight was incredibly stacked in her favor. Take a look at what Twilight actually had to do: She had to personally cast the time travel spell like a dozen times (and I doubt it's an easy spell to use), she had to deal with the shenanigans all the alternate worlds tossed at her in-between her brief fights with Starlight, and she had the task of beating Starlight without causing a big enough disturbance to derail the race and thus the timeline, forcing her to start all over again. And she looked like she was trying not to injure Starlight seriously (compare her mentality in Starlight's fight with the ruthlesness she displayed when truly pissed, aka her fight with Tirek). Meanwhile, Starlight ... only had to stall Twilight - stall, not actually defeat - until she manages to do something random to derail the timeline. And didn't have to expand any extra energy in between their fights, unlike Twilight with her constant visit to other hostile worlds and constant recasting of the time travel spell. It's actually pretty impressive from Twilight that she seemed to be tiring at the same rate as Starlight by the end of it, because she had by far the hardest job of the two. Yeah, they finished the race "even" - but only because Twilight was forced to take five steps for each of Starlight's one. In a straight up brawl, with no timeline shenanigans that continuously force Twilight to expend extra magic and effort, while Starlight gets to rest, with Twilight playing for as much keeps as Starlight did, and with the fight actually going until one of them drops, not until a time vortex sucks Twilight away again because the surroundings were disturbed too much? Yeah, I don't think Starlight would be walking away from that one. She strong and talented for sure, but a Twilight she is not.
  7. To add to the others, there is one more thing to consider - The Royal Guard, as the name might suggest, aren't necessarily the regular army or police force of Equestria. As the name suggests, one of their primary functions would be escorting and guarding Royalty, aka the Princesses - Celestia especially, since until recently she was the only one around. And since Celestia tends to travel by air (Luna and Twilight as well it seems), be it in a flying chariot or under her own power, it makes sense that majority of the Royal Guard are actually capable of performing their duty once the princess takes to the skies, meaning having flight of their own.
  8. Someone has to do all the paperwork, and she seems to have managed just fine for a thousand years already and the populace, by and large, like and respect her. I suppose Twilight could take over if the need arose, but I'm not sure if she would even want that. She might have liked peace and quiet above all else some time ago, but these days Twilight gets restless and complains about boredom if she doesn't get to go out on adventures - for better or worse, she seems to have developed a taste for some adventuring and excitement in her life. She seems to be a much more hooves-on, "frontline" type of Princess to Celestia's bureaucratic pencil pusher. So ... I guess there simply is no reason to. Everyone's quite happy with the way things are right now and it seems to be working well.
  9. No single stallion can hope to keep up with Celestia. That's what the all-male Royal Guard is there for
  10. We do know the horns grow back, since horn filing is a thing in the show - wouldn't happen if the horns didn't naturally grow out with time. So ... some bone like (nail-like?) substance, probably. And Celestia obviously haven't had hers trimmed in ages
  11. At the risk of sounding dramatic: I think she's the worst thing to happen to the show in all of its six seasons, and her continued presence is slowly killing my enjoyment of it. She made a fine entrance is a villain in her Equality town, but everything about her and the way she has been handled since the season 5 finale I have found to be gag-worthy, and the way they try and shoehorn her into the plot isn't helping things. By contrast Sunset had a comparatively lame introduction and her whole highschool plot was silly, but the following movie really made her a compelling character that I wouldn't mind seeing in the show proper on regular basis. Much better character than Starlight, past a rocky start.
  12. One has to remember that "earth pony magic" is mostly a fandom creation to begin with - it's very ill defined in the show, and when it's touched upon it's always in relation to farming and plant growing, or "connection to land" if you want to be generous. Strength? Endurance? Toughness? Those are things that have no actual support in the show that the fandom has assigned them (got to give them poor underdogs something against all the obvious advantages of Unicorns and Pegasi ) Maud aside (which is such a fringe case to be about as representative of your average earth pony as Twilight was of your average unicorn), the greatest displays of durability actually come from Rainbow Dash and Twilight (a pegasus and a unicorn), and greatest displays of strength from Twilight and Rarity (carrying Tom around ... Mac did pull a house along, but then again he was hyped on Twilight's freaky love potion at that time), and Twilight/Cadence (pulling along Dicord's golden monstrosity of a "charriot" in the sky) So ... yeah - I'd say Twilight and Cadence have displayed all the traits of your typical alicorn.
  13. Hm, I guess the question is - have there actually been other cases of alicorn pregnancies (or even other alicorns besides the sisters, prior to Cadence and Twilight entering the picture) before Cadence? Celestia doesn't seem like she's had any children (married to her work? Or simply making sure to avoid pregnancy if she has had lovers over the millennia) and Luna has been absent, so I guess it could be a case of no one actually knowing what to expect at all, if Cadence is the first documented case of alicorn pregnancy.
  14. This ^ An alicorn giving birth to an alicorn is perfectly believable. If one of those other "toy alicorns" turn up as foals from Twilight/Celestia/Luna, that's both plausible and to be expected - or at least nothing to be too surprised about. It's one appearing out of thin air that would cause me to have a fit. An offspring to an already established alicorn is fine.
  15. I believe that might have been the point, sort of. I mean, Equestria has been getting along perfectly fine with just Celestia as the 'administrator' type of Princess for a thousand years - it doesn't seem like the country needs another Princess-tier paper-pusher, nor would it necessarily benefit from having one. A hero, though? Considering all the sealed-evil-in-a-can beings that crawl out of the woodwork lately and other mishaps and villains that pop up occasionally - yeah, they can definitely use a hero, especially one that isn't too busy running the country to go and personally help where needed. And there are a few ways that being a Princess helps here - for one, it makes her very presence a symbol of hope and motivation, should she ever need to organize a large scale relief effort of any sort, and gives her the authority to do so. After all, a Princess has been Equestria's guide and proverbial protector for a thousand years, capable of feats few other ponies would ever dream of - having a Princess on the scene is probably the fastest way to get everyone moving and thinking productively (Just look at the ponies in Princess Spike and how almost instinctively they follow all the directions of a Princess). It also gives everyone a clear figure to rally behind should anything ever happen to Celestia (or Luna/Cadence) herself - a wise precaution for sure, seeing as how the Royal Guard immediately went to Twilight for orders after the plunder vines abducted the elder princesses. SHe's essentially an immediately-available backup and makes Equestria's leadership less of a "all eggs in one basket" type of deal, which is obviously preferable. And having schooled Twilight herself since young age, Celestia can be reasonably certain that her values will be largely upheld even in her own absence. And since Twilight does serve as Celestia's primary "troubleshooter", it probably helps to give her the full authority to ensure that she can always focus on the problem at hand, rather than having to jump through potential bureaucratic nonsense and red tape if some corrupt official turns out to be the problem and can't be denied access to any loction or evidence. It makes her job as a "hero" potentially easier, in other words, by ensuring that she is the highest authority during whatever crisis she needs to solve. So in short ... she may not have typical "princess duties" (besides ones that she assigns herself), but the title seems to be there both so that she can do her 'actual' job - being the hero that Equestria needs - easier (and it's non-commital enough to not interfere with whatever heroics need doing - I mean, "Princess of Friendship"? That practically screams "yeah, do whatever it feels like you need to do to make this country a better place, no specifics") and makes her in to a backup that Equestria can turn to in case something happens to the other Princesses (which can happen, as we have seen). Or something like that.
  16. It's all part of Twilight's future princess training. The upcoming princess of Equestria can't be seen running around on hoof when there is a perfectly fine carriage-equivalent for her to use, and the peasants to pull it.
  17. She smacks both sides upside the head for being silly and drag them to the negotiation table, and no one gets to leave until peace is to be had.
  18. In the end, it's not like it really matters whether they have that six-chaired "throne room" inside Twilight's castle or not, nor does it indicate anything aside from their bond as the bearers of the elements - the castle sprouted from the ground thanks to a magical tree. And it's not like the tree has some sort of actual authority in Equestria or has a say in its governnance. Equestria is ruled by Celestia, so it's entirely up to her if she wants to share that authority, and her decision whom to share it with. The tree and whatever castles it grows doesn't really enter in to the equation. Twilight is a princess, and was one long before the castle even existed, because Celestia decreed it so. The other five have no official positions of power, because no ruling body of Equestria has given them one.
  19. Eh, not really - only Twilight is an actual ruler with actual authority, the others have no authority beyond what Twilight would assign them for specific tasks. You could say they are potentially influential based on the fact that Twilight is liable to listen to their advice in certain matters, but that's about it. So at most they have the influence of political advisors - which can be decent enough, but they don't "rule" anything, nor do they have the authority to order anyone around, unless Twilight would assign any of them to act in her name (like Spike tried to do in Princess Spike). So ... no. Twilight is the only one who qualifies as a ruler. The rest are simply her friends and confidants, as they have always been - just that suddenly these positions carry a bit more weight since Twilight became a Princess. And nah, I don't find any of them less relatable - even Twilight, who is the only one to undergo a real social-political upheveal, has gone to some lengths to appear as the same old Twilight she has always been, instead of demanding special treatment and gets by with the absolute minimum royal decorum.
  20. Seeing as horn filing is a thing, the answer ought to be yes - horns do grow back with time, otherwise saloons/spas wouldn't offer procedures to shorten and reduce them. I imagine it might not grow back if you lost the "root" of the horn (kinda like with nails), but considering it's atached to your forehead, horn growth is probably least of your worries if the root gets yanked out and you are left with a hole in your skull.
  21. Perhaps a Winter Wrap Up episode where Twilight seeks to abolish the racist and tribalist ways of Ponyville that promotes discrimination and segregation against certain pony species.
  22. I kinda doubt it was ever intended to be Twilight's castle - I mean, it's in the middle of the Everfree forest, it would be more fitting a place for Equestria's highest security prison than a castle for one of its monarchs, nowadays. Unless they have plans for eliminating the Everfree or something, that location isn't exactly livable.
  23. Yeah, the country seems to be prospering and the vast majority of people seem very content - rebellions don't start for the heck of it, they are the people's response to poor leadership and poor living conditions (often oppression and explotation) of the masses. Equestria doesn't have this problem, so there is nothing to rebel over. If anything any such potential "rebellion" would be turned on by the masses and torn to pieces by the populace itself because they would come across as a bunch of crazy ponies trying to ruin everyone's else perfectly happy lifestyle. And people don't like their happy lives to be threatened.
  24. She strikes me as someone who has no patience for political games and all the associated shoulder-rubbing, which the Gala basically seems to be, so she simply doesn't attend. Simple parties or genuine celebrations like Nightmare Night where one gets to kick loose? Sure. Snobby high-class events that seem to exist for the sake of themselves? She'd probably turn in to Nighmare again before the night was out.
×
×
  • Create New...