Pony x pony or human x pony?

[Bendy 1,821]

Pony x pony or human x pony?

 

As in romance between the two in fan fiction. I dunno... maybe I'm weird and insane, but I personally find pony x pony quite boring. I much rather read human x pony. The story Xenophilia is one of the most heart warming HIE stories I ever read.

 

So what about you? Which do you prefer? 

Edited May 12, 2015 by Bendy

[The Awesome One 1,315]

If I were a pony and a human was trying to get with me, I'd say

 

ARE YOU NUTS? I'M A HORSE!

 

So Pony x Human is not for me. I just can not see how that would work.

[Castle Bleck 19,376]

What if it's a Human transformed into a Pony?

[Bendy 1,821]

If I were a pony and a human was trying to get with me, I'd say

 

ARE YOU NUTS? I'M A HORSE!

 

So Pony x Human is not for me. I just can not see how that would work.

 

Fanon Lyra would disagree with you there. After all, hands are amazing. 

What if it's a Human transformed into a Pony?

 

I personally don't really like those stories. I kinda hate a story when a human is transformed into a pony. There is very few of those stories of that kind I like.

Edited May 12, 2015 by Bendy

[InsertUsernameHere 149]

How about neither? That'd be great

[Snow Frostflame 3,568]

I don't like romance let alone shipping.....  so I agree with @InsertUsernameHere

Edited May 13, 2015 by Snowflake Frostflame

[BastementSparkle 20,326]

I like both equally, long as it's well written.

[WriteCodes46 178]

I dislike zoophilia, so I prefer it to at least be between 2 horses.

[Moonlight 7,287]

I dislike zoophilia, so I prefer it to at least be between 2 horses.

                 ^^^

        This basically.

 

Human x Pony is extremely disgusting imo and it's never even written well. pony x pony is definitely better, at least they're the same species.

[They call me Loyalty 1,948]

By the nature of some of your question, it looks like you're afraid of some of the subjects you bring about.

For example here, the appeal from human x pony sounds like it comes from fear, a morbid reaction of self-rejection within yourself, rather than an open mind and heart. Most likely the attractiveness of the very idea is generated by the thrill of taking such inter-specie interaction as something prohibited or taboo, rather than a heartful interaction between Consciousness experiencing the very same life into each other.
 

 

Take away all fear, rule and limitation within yourself. Knowing that any hurtful reaction comes from the isolation generated by fear itself alone, which often ends up in violence, either sexual or not, due to lack of life acceptance, despite its current condition. Wisdom is within our hearts, and it lacks all fear.

 

Do you think there's anything wrong with a pony and a human being loving each other, in a reality that would allow such experience?

 

What do you think there is beyond your body, and your physical self? The lively presence you're beyond your vital functions. Do you thing there's any difference at all between all of us, beyond our current physical bodies? What do you think is left when we take away our current bodies, either they be human, pony or whatever else?

 

Make it with love, without judgment. Without "right" and "wrong" Such judgment comes from fear.

 

 

Just the feeling of heart. How does it feel to love beyond all physical conditions?

 

[Coco before Pommel 679]

I only ship pony/pony (and human/human in EQGverse) ships - the whole "human in Equestria" or "pony in our world" genre doesn't interest me much. I'm cool with people liking human/pony stuff though - it's really more alien/xeno(?) than bestiality, since MLP ponies are sentient, intelligent and capable of consenting to whatever, unlike actual animals

[Dark Qiviut 22,439]

I ship quite proudly in other fandoms, including human/anthro crossbreeds in Digimon and Sonic. This is no exception. I ship human/pony and pony/pony equally. As long as it's well executed, I don't give a buck.

Edited May 15, 2015 by Dark Qiviut

[aoEAF2FBvC0MIo2Q 3,673]

By the nature of some of your question, it looks like you're afraid of some of the subjects you bring about.

For example here, the appeal from human x pony sounds like it comes from fear, a morbid reaction of self-rejection within yourself, rather than an open mind and heart. Most likely the attractiveness of the very idea is generated by the thrill of taking such inter-specie interaction as something prohibited or taboo, rather than a heartful interaction between Consciousness experiencing the very same life into each other.

 

 

Take away all fear, rule and limitation within yourself. Knowing that any hurtful reaction comes from the isolation generated by fear itself alone, which often ends up in violence, either sexual or not, due to lack of life acceptance, despite its current condition. Wisdom is within our hearts, and it lacks all fear.

 

Do you think there's anything wrong with a pony and a human being loving each other, in a reality that would allow such experience?

 

What do you think there is beyond your body, and your physical self? The lively presence you're beyond your vital functions. Do you thing there's any difference at all between all of us, beyond our current physical bodies? What do you think is left when we take away our current bodies, either they be human, pony or whatever else?

 

Make it with love, without judgment. Without "right" and "wrong" Such judgment comes from fear.

 

 

Just the feeling of heart. How does it feel to love beyond all physical conditions?

 

 

Gee, it's a good thing ponies that look, talk and express themselves like humans only exist in fiction then... 

[JonasDarkmane 19,787]

I think I would prefer Pony x Pony  , the other thing just sounds really really..... obnoxious 

[Skye 463]

Not really into pony x human, sorry. I love pony x pony, I ship many things.

[Shanks 10,816]

If you are talking shipping in general I have no preference one way or another but human on pony is my favorite kind of clop which makes it the tie breaker.

Edited May 16, 2015 by Darth Bane

[Flappity boom boom 28]

I mean both are pretty disgusting for a lot of reasons.
But, if I was forced to choose I would obviously choose pony x pony.

The pony x pony is still freaking gross cause... well you know why. It's like clopping (searched that term figured out what it means and its pretty gross) but 3x worse.

The human x pony is just... ew. It goes beyond all nature of how someone should act.

I can understand imaging pony x pony out of curiosity maybe, but purposely seeking it? No thank you.
(This thread is also opening up a lot of stereotypes I've heard about. Whelp.)

[Positively Pinkie 109]

I really don't like HIE.

 

Ponies are sort of in universe or cute to read about.

 

Mixing humans with ponies, unless in some funny cross over way, always resulted in the worst fics I've ever read.

 

 

The pony x pony is still freaking gross cause... well you know why. It's like clopping (searched that term figured out what it means and its pretty gross) but 3x worse.

 

 

I would assume you can ship without going into sex and stuff.

Edited May 16, 2015 by Positively Pinkie

[Bendy 1,821]

I mean both are pretty disgusting for a lot of reasons.

 

By a certain point of view.... a view I shared until this fandom corrupted me and turned me to the darkside. Thanks, Bronies, I now like ponies too much. It's true, I've joined the Sith and I love ponies too much.

 

They aren't ponies from our planet. Therefore making them sapient aliens. If you said this to a pony "You are a filthy animal, that's why I won't date you." Be prepared to be slapped across the face.

 

You could turn a pony down, but make sure to do it in a nice way. Otherwise they'll be very angry with you.

Edited May 16, 2015 by Bendy

[Commissar Alexer 763]

Only a human can succesfully please a mare.

 

 

Also, interesting how people say humanXpony is bestiality and disgusting but watching two mare making out isn't? Kek.

[mars 4,862]

Pony/Pony.

I hate human/pony because it's just really weird and never works. Also, most human/pony stories are just self-insert human in equestria stories, and those are cringeworthy.

[LittleMac 3,085]

I wouldn't say I'm a fan of shipping but, if push comes to shove, pony x pony.....the other one sounds....bizarre to me

[Solid 1,327]

By the nature of some of your question, it looks like you're afraid of some of the subjects you bring about.

For example here, the appeal from human x pony sounds like it comes from fear, a morbid reaction of self-rejection within yourself, rather than an open mind and heart. Most likely the attractiveness of the very idea is generated by the thrill of taking such inter-specie interaction as something prohibited or taboo, rather than a heartful interaction between Consciousness experiencing the very same life into each other.

 

Take away all fear, rule and limitation within yourself. Knowing that any hurtful reaction comes from the isolation generated by fear itself alone, which often ends up in violence, either sexual or not, due to lack of life acceptance, despite its current condition. Wisdom is within our hearts, and it lacks all fear.

 

Do you think there's anything wrong with a pony and a human being loving each other, in a reality that would allow such experience?

 

What do you think there is beyond your body, and your physical self? The lively presence you're beyond your vital functions. Do you thing there's any difference at all between all of us, beyond our current physical bodies? What do you think is left when we take away our current bodies, either they be human, pony or whatever else?

 

Make it with love, without judgment. Without "right" and "wrong" Such judgment comes from fear.

 

Just the feeling of heart. How does it feel to love beyond all physical conditions?

 

Very insightful, I like it.

 

 

 

Sometimes when it comes to Love it's not just about physical/sexual love, and on occasions it could in fact have very little to do with it. There are many forms of relationships that could be associated with love as well, friendship, family, mentorship, etc.

[Ashen Pathfinder 16,161]

All right guys let's keep this thread on topic. I've had to prune a few posts from this one that were distracting from the main question.

 

Let's keep it on track guys.