Have You Changed Your Favorite Mane 6 Pony Since You Started Watching?

[hawkflame 3,310]

At first, my favorite was Pinkie Pie because she was the funniest (and still is, of course ). But then I gave a little more thought about the show and how they handled Rarity (I think it was Suited For Success that brought this on) and that made me realize how unique she was as a character, and how she's really the best example of the show just totally destroying your preconceived expectations, as in other shows she'd basically be Diamond Tiara or Sunset Shimmer. And then I realized that the combination of flaws she had with her more positive qualities really made her interesting as a character.

[~Silver Essence~ 2,625]

Out of context, fluttershy, I don't know why, I just did at first, maybe it was the fan made content that made me like her at first.

 

Then rainbow dash, of course, because of how cool she was and being the fastest and all.

 

Then Pinkie Pie because of how funny and cheerful she was most of the times.

 

Then Twilight because I found her so adorable and very amazing compared to the others.

 

Then finally, Rarity, but that was after re watching the whole series, finding content of her, and eventually realizing how amazing and underrated she is.

[UJn92kwC 108]

Well, my favorite has changed a LOT.

First, before i was a brony, it was Applejack,

Then, when i was first a brony, it was fluttershy

Went through a Twilight phase

Rarity was my favorite for a while,

And now its Pinkie.

And, well, Rainbow, I has no excuse.

[Vertigo_95 572]

When I first started the show, I liked Rainbow Dash. But as I got deeper into the first season, I started to like Pinkie Pie. So Rainbow Dash is now my second favorite out of the mane 6. My overall  favorite pony is Luna

[GrauWitz 1,010]

To be honest, when I first saw the show (season 1), I was like 'What the fuck is this shit?'. Then, I checked out Season 2 and I loved it. Fluttershy was my favourite and she still is

[GhostPony750 959]

My favorite was Applejack, and it's still Applejack.

She's an awesome character, and she always stayed my favorite through all the show.

[Smarts 1,623]

When I first watched the show, this pony right here was my favorite because I liked her color scheme and she seemed really likable.

 

Twilight Sparkle remained my favorite for a little while. Then, I saw this beautiful character and she instantly became my favorite.

Chrysalis became my instant favorite. I loved everything about her. Voice, design, race, color, and so on so forth. No character has come close to beating her in my opinion. She was just perfect in every way possible. I just hope that I get to see her again in one of the new episodes.

 

If you mean in terms of the main six. My favorite pony of the six is Applejack because of how underrated she is and the fact that she is a great character. Also, I like that southern accent she has and her personality. One final thing, that hat is awesome.

Edited September 2, 2013 by SmartyPants

[VoxelBrony 65]

When i first started watching MLP, my favorite was Rainbow Dash. Then, i moved onto Fluttershy. Then, Lyra Heartstrings. And now, Flitter.

[Megas 27,890]

When I first started watching, my favorite was Rainbow Dash. Now... it's still Rainbow Dash

 

 

OK, maybe my second favorite would be a better reflection of how much I changed.

 

When I first started watching Fluttershy was my seconf Favorite. Now Rarity is my second favorite

[Woohoo 34,699]

When I first watched the show in November 2011 up until the end of Season 2, I didn't have a favorite pony. However most of the time, it was Rainbow Dash 

 

But after rewatching some episodes, Twilight Sparkle grew on me

 

Rarity is a close second (which is why she's mad)

[Tual 152]

Pinkie Pie has been my favourite since the start. (For personal reasons, mainly.) She's just so..Pinkie Pie. Hard  for me to explain. :V 

Though, my opinions on the other ponies have swapped during the seasons. 

[Haven Celestii 9,385]

As the natural thing for one when first coming into the show, I like Fluttershy as my favorite, but then I saw the truth.

 

The apple-y truth.

And bubbly truth.

The apple-y bubbly truth.

[VindalfOthala 4]

Well, when I first saw MLP I liked Fluttershy the most. She was (and still is) really cute. But now, I've changed my opinion quite a while ago. In terms of mane6 I like Pinkie Pie the most now, and overall I'm a big fan of Princess Luna.

[Guest]

Gosh, I don't know. From the very beginning I was very conflicted about who I would choose as the best. I think fluttershy used to be my #1 because she was so cute, but as I watched the show I was turned off by fluttershy's timid personality and turned on to rainbow dash and applejacks' personalities. Rainbow dash is my current number 1, and applejack sits only a tiny bit behind at number 2. I'm still pretty indecisive as where to place 3-6.

Edited September 3, 2013 by Guest

[Rainbow lightning 19]

At first it was rainbow dash but as time went on DEFIANTLY luna after all she is way funnier and I just like here all around chareter deisgn

[ShadowRose2k 271]

Lets see Id have to say when I first watched  Pinkie Pie  was my favorite.   She still is but I like how Rainbow Dash has improved over the years.  So She is edging ahead of pinkie at the moment.    I have also gain more respec for Rareity, I don't think I had that high of an opinion of her at the start.  

 

Also I put my vote in for most attractive pony.  Octavia.

 

 

 

 

[Whofch 128]

Erm, Fluttershy was the one who actually got me liking the show. I'm pretty sure I loved her the most throughout seasons 1 and 2. I still absoloutly love her but Rarity and even AJ have steadily pushed their way to the top.

 

Not counting Luna who lives in her special place, far too high for any other pony to reach.

[RrVPfX9cPtw59FpC 1,304]

Fluttershy was my favorite when I started, and it had been that way for awhile. After a bit, however, I got conflicted between her, Rainbow Dash, and Pinkie Pie. Now, my official favorite pony is Twilight Sparkle, but that's only because of a vote (And a free ride to Bronycon with Daring XD)

[Shanks 10,816]

 but that's only because of a vote (And a free ride to Bronycon with Daring XD)

I think I remember that "vote", not the best reason to pick a favorite but I did try to make the case for AJ so I guess I am the last one to criticize. Twilight is not a bad choice though, Twilight is pretty awesome but so is AJ.

[NocturnalTwilight 32]

When I first started watching MLP, I LOVED Applejack, still do, she's just not my favorite now.

Now, my favorite is Twilight Sparkle! Cuz she's awesome!

Hmm, now that I think of it...I've had every one of the Mane 6 be my favorite Pony, I guess it's because they're all so great!

[Bonko 73]

When I first saw the show, my favorite pony (from Mane 6) was Applejack.

After I finished season 3, it's Fluttershy   . Although my favorite pony other than the Mane 6 is Trixie.

[Keyfur 40]

Rarity has pretty much always been my favorite. Mostly because she's the kind of pony I'd want to marry if I was a pony.  I'm still watching the first 3 seasons for the first time, and as of late, Rainbow Dash is quickly taking 1st place. She's just so adventurous... it's awesome! 

[Hyper Tumble 1,483]

Applejack's almost always been my favorite. The person who got me started on MLP loves Applejack, and she is just all around best pony. It was Scoots for a couple episodes, but I came back to the light.

[Jackleberry 1,923]

When I first started watching MLP.

Fluttershy

 

Now.

Fluttershy

 

Yep, I've been a Fluttershy fan ever since I became a brony, and to be honest I don't see that changing any time soon, or even at all. I just find her too adorable, and I can relate to her in so many ways!

[Thorns 55]

Pinkie Pie was my favourite in the very beginning. And then it became Twilight Sparkle. And now it's still Twilight Sparke. Dat flowin' mane. Dat tantalizingly beautiful colour scheme. Da Magicks.