S05:E03 - Castle Sweet Castle

[Pip_Gobbler 32]

My take on this episode: too many songs (seriously? 2 in 1 episode?) I hated the part where Pinkie was a jerk again (way out of character, I hope they don't keep up with that as a theme) and finally SPIKE HAS A RARITY PLUSHIE HAHAHAHAHA I can see they're still putting in easter eggs for the bronies hahahahaha.  

[Omar 692]

My take on this episode: too many songs (seriously? 2 in 1 episode?) I hated the part where Pinkie was a jerk again (way out of character, I hope they don't keep up with that as a theme) and finally SPIKE HAS A RARITY PLUSHIE HAHAHAHAHA I can see they're still putting in easter eggs for the bronies hahahahaha.  

I don't remember pinkie being a jerk...

[Pastel 7,630]

My take on this episode: too many songs (seriously? 2 in 1 episode?)

But they didn't beat Magical Mystery Cure, which had 7 songs. x)

[Chewbroccali 32]

Loved the way spike just got picked up by Bulk Biceps and smashed through a wall  . Have to admit, one of the funniest moments in my book. couldn't stop laughing!!!

[Chaton 3,766]

Loved the way spike just got picked up by Bulk Biceps and smashed through a wall  . Have to admit, one of the funniest moments in my book. couldn't stop laughing!!!

"I hate it when he does that"

[Light Diamond 950]

I watched this the other day, i liked Twilight's new hairstyle or mane. It was sad seeing the old library destroyed and i can see how the castle didn't feel like home for her. Pinkie Pie was also funny and it was a great episode.

[Hyper Flurry 0]

Love how they used the roots of the Golden Oak Library, but how would they get those gems to reflect the past moments in their life. I mean was magic used, was it just them saying a moment and then we just saw it through the gem?

Another thing, how was Pinkie Pie able to get her hoof up to the gem when it shows them all up in the air??? (Maybe I'm just overthinking things)

[BlackBoard 28]

Pinkie Pie is Pinkie Pie after all

 

But seriously I found this episode to be quite tasteful. It was very sentimental about how they brought back the Golden Oaks Library and didn't just make it fade into the distance.

[PyromaniacFirebolt 14]

I have never been a fan of this sort of plot, but I did enjoy watching Spike's efforts to distract Twilight.  Her temporary mane style was pretty awesome, too.^^  I loved Bulk Biceps' moment in this episode.  I like the thought of him working as a massage therapist when not offering personal training to ponies, and that the spa ponies just accept his actions by now.  It was hard seeing the remains of the Golden Oak Library, but from the ashes rose a shiny, sentimental phoenix.  :3  Wish they had gone into detail about how they put the memories into each crystal, though.  Was it just a pretty effect for the audience?

[MLPFanatic34 3,241]

Just watched the episode today. Laughed through the entire thing. Especially the part with bulk biceps.

And then there is this.

Screen Shot 2015-04-13 at 2.48.57 PM.png

I don't know why, but Pinkie during that scene reminds me of the scene in Courage The Cowardly Dog when Courage has food on his face and laughs, also love this someone did of Bulk Biceps bashing through the wall.

 

 

 

Edited April 15, 2015 by MLPFanatic34

[Pip_Gobbler 32]

I don't remember pinkie being a jerk...

"Remember when the library got smashed to smitherenes?!" that's not being a jerk? Lol

[Omar 692]

"Remember when the library got smashed to smitherenes?!" that's not being a jerk? Lol

She wasn't trying to be a jerk.

[Pip_Gobbler 32]

but it was out of character, like during the ponytones episode when she insulted fluttershy, I hope they don't keep up witht hat because to me it's super weird.

[TopQuark 409]

Did anyone else notice that it was strikingly similar to the plot of 'Testing, Testing, 123'?

 

Testing, Testing, 123:

- Rainbow has a personal problem (she could fail a test)

- The other five try to help with things that would help them (study methods)

- None of them work

- The problem is solved when Rainbow does it her way

 

Castle, Sweet Castle:

- Twilight has a personal problem (she is feeling depressed by the impersonality of the castle)

- The other five try to help with things that would help them (decorations)

- None of them work (especially not together)

- The problem is solved (sort of) when they use Twilight's way

 

I say the problem is 'sort of' fixed because I don't think that one chandelier (made from the carcass of her old home) in a room that she'll probably only use once a week will keep her from getting depressed.

 

A few plot points that bothered me, but other than that, an over-all decent episode.

[Luffyiscool 397]

but it was out of character, like during the ponytones episode when she insulted fluttershy, I hope they don't keep up witht hat because to me it's super weird.

Personally, I wouldn't even put those two things in the same ballpark.

 

It wasn't out of character at all, Pinkie sometimes gets ahead of herself and says things without thinking.

That's perfectly within her hyper character limits. Just like when she accidentally let slip some information in the premiere. 

 

So, by logic of comparison:

Letting slip some information doesn't mean she wants to aid the villain.

Therefore, making a faux pas about the library doesn't mean she was being a jerk.

Edited April 15, 2015 by Luffyiscool

[paradoxical 1,735]

"Remember when the library got smashed to smitherenes?!" that's not being a jerk? Lol

 

 

but it was out of character, like during the ponytones episode when she insulted fluttershy, I hope they don't keep up witht hat because to me it's super weird.

 

It wasn't out of character at all, Pinkie sometimes gets ahead of herself and says things without thinking.

Like Luffy;

I think it's more along the lines of Pinkie is the least socially observant of the ponies. 

 

Pinkie thought process:

Everypony was talking

about memorable things.  What can I think of that was memorable Golden Oak [blanking blanking what did I last do with the Library, oh yeah right, watch it be blown up!] 

"BLURT FIRST thing that comes to mind"

[Samurai Equine 58,589]

I am keeping up with the season too. 

 

Honestly, I thought this episode was... okay. To me, so far, it was the slowest of the season. It really dragged along with only a few gags to hold us over and a less-than-amazing as well. But the ending was really sweet. Probably the sweetest gift any friend (or in this case, a group of friends) could give another friend. The memories we make with the people we care about are truly the most precious memories of them all. Our belongings can be lost or destroyed, and we may become different along the way, but we'll carry our precious memories with us always.

Edited April 16, 2015 by Samurai Equine

[SanityNotIncluded 335]

Finally got around to commenting on this thread. This one was alright. Songs were kinda flat, but there was a decent amount of nostalgic stuff going on, and I'm a sucker for that sort of thing. Also,"I'm Pancake! I mean awake!" A tiny part of me is leaning toward buying a pony shirt, and if someone made that quote into a shirt, I'd be far more tempted than I should be to pick one up

[Vertigo-01 101]

It feels like MLP songs have been gradually becoming more lack-luster over the seasons. That may just be my take on it, but the song in this episode felt very forced / rushed.

I do like that they paid homage to the library. That was a very cool touch they installed at the end in the castle. But otherwise, the episode felt a little dull around the edges. It just seems like a bit more could have been done with the time allotted...

Although we all now have a new mane style to play around with Twilight. 

[The Second Opinion 270]

On one hand, it was sweet and funny enough. On the other hand, as "transitional" third episodes go, I thought it was the most gimmicky and formulaic one so far with the whole redecorating "too much/too little" thing. (At least Ticket Master managed not to be too wooden when reusing the old "one extra ticket, lots of friends who want it" plot).

[Unlikeable Pony 2,700]

I watched this the other day, i liked Twilight's new hairstyle or mane. It was sad seeing the old library destroyed and i can see how the castle didn't feel like home for her. Pinkie Pie was also funny and it was a great episode.

 

Pinkie pie is weird, in that she shows both why she can be a good character and why she can be a BAD character IMO. At the start she was pretty good. her starting jokes were nice, and her diving for the pancake were funny. Unfortunately, the writers have a tendency to devolve pinkie's modus operi into "Pinkie screams, and that's the joke" more or less.

 

After about the first 5 or 10 minutes, she began to devolve more and more into just screaming things really loud, and she stopped being funny at that point; which I found really disheartening, because she had been a real asset to the episode at the start. (By comparison as well, I feel she was really good in the premier too since her jokes were her just talking rather than screaming-- there was Logic to her comedy, if that makes sense).

 

 

Her temporary mane style was pretty awesome, too.^^

Eh, I just didn't think it looked good on Twilight. Maybe for dash, but it was too spikey IMO to fit twilgiht (or any of the other 5 for that matter) well.

[Thespian 78]

I didn't like how Rarity purposefully used spikes affections for her to her advantage. Its messed up man. The song was a bit meh in my opinion, but there were funny jokes throughout, so overall it was ok, but I really want sparity to end. Either make them a couple, which will never happen, or stop messing with Spikes emotions. 

[colt_following 169]

I liked it. a bit slow-paced, but I enjoyed the setup and using the roots of the library is a sweet sentiment.

 

But Spike's Rarity doll though 

[Luffyiscool 397]

I didn't like how Rarity purposefully used spikes affections for her to her advantage. Its messed up man. Either make them a couple, which will never happen, or stop messing with Spikes emotions. 

I honestly think the writers keep allowing it to happen because SPIKE is allowing it to happen.

 

We've seen in Inspiration Manifestation that Spike has it within himself to say no to Rarity. 

If he truly had a good personal reason to object, then he would.

 

But in an every day situation where his crush asks him to do something, I imagine it would be very hard to simply refuse.

After all, he's assisting the one he feels affection for. And that makes him happy.

Of course his affections are being used to Rarity's advantage, that actually gives him more of an incentive. 

 

Rarity getting an advantage = Rarity being very happy.

Rarity being very happy = Spike being very happy.

 

You see where I'm going with this?

Spike is 100% aware of what's going on, but he's more than happy to oblige because that's what a crush does to someone. 

Yes, it's Spike's own fault that he's getting taken advantage of. He knows this, and he accepts it.

He doesn't expect anything in return, he just wants to please his crush. This is entirely his choice.

 

I honestly can't blame Rarity for counting on a reliable friend who will help her out through thick and thin.

She merely asks for the help, but Spike is the one with the power to say yes or no. 

So to me, nothing is wrong with the way the two interact.

 

Spike gives his consent every time. He makes his bed and then lies in it.

[sweetolebob18 728]

I can't believe how popular this episode is.  I give it 2 stars out of 5.  There's nothing you could really point to & say "this is bad", but little that is really good.

 

Seriously, the ponies are all at least in their late teens (IMO) & they've known Twilight for at least 2 years (depending on how long you think the 1st 3 seasons lasted).  They've got to be told that the way to cheer up T is with books? Are they really that clueless?

 

If it was me, I would have gotten the library from the destroyed Castle of the 2 Sisters & brought it in as a gift.