How would you rate the show in general?

[TheAnimatorOfficial 567]

For me:

 

S1: 7/10

S2: 9/10

S3: 8/10

S4: 9/10

S5: 8-8.5/10

S6: 9/10

 

Overall: 9/10

 

EG: 5-6/10

RR: 7/10

FG: 7/10

Edited April 27, 2016 by TheAnimatorOfficial

[Leere 8,291]

S1: 7.5/10

S2: 8/10

S3: 7/10

S4: 9/10

S5: 10/10

S6: 9.5/10

Overall: 9.5/10

 

EG: 6.5/10

RR: 8/10

FG: 7/10

[Yufery 205]

While I don't particularly have anything wrong with the show as a whole, I suppose I may as well just say my insanely high ratings.

 

S1: 10/10

 

S2: 10/10

 

S3: 10/10

S4: 10/10

 

S5: 10/10

 

S6: 10/10

 

Overall: 10/10

 

(yeah I'm the pure definition of a fanboy. I just can't really bring myself to go any lower than 10/10 for any of the seasons since I think they're all amazing and extremely well done. However, I should note that there still are a handful of episodes I'm not fond of, but that didn't hinder my opinion that each season is a step up in quality)

 

EG: 7.5/10

 

RR: 10/10

 

FG: 10/10

[Luminance 2,186]

S1: 20/10

S2: 20/10

S3: 20/10

S4: 20/10

S5: 20/10

S6: 20/10

Overall: 20/10

 

I'm not kidding.

[Moonlight 7,286]

Just going to do the show:

 

S1: 7/10

S2: 8/10

S3: 3/10

S4: 7/10

S5: 3/10

S6: 1/10

 

Average: 4.8/10

 

I prefer looking at each episode rather than season overall honestly.

[Megas 27,628]

It's a good show by normal standards, and a top 5 show by personal standards

[CastletonSnob 3,074]

I think it's a good cartoon, but not even close to one of the best cartoons of all time. 

[Yufery 205]

S1: 20/10

S2: 20/10

S3: 20/10

S4: 20/10

S5: 20/10

S6: 20/10

Overall: 20/10

 

I'm not kidding.

As Stan Pines once said, I can relate to this.

[BastementSparkle 20,326]

10/10, favorite show ever. It's not perfect by any means, it has flaws, plenty, but I love it more than pretty much any other piece of media of any kind. It's the only show that can actually at times make me smile when I'm feeling down, and the only show that's moved me to tears in years, that's got to count for something.

[Jeric 46,851]

S1 - 4/5

S2 - 5/5

S3 - 3/5

S4 - 4/5

S5 - 5/5

S6 - unknown

 

Overall 4/5

 

---

 

Equestria Girls - 3/5

Rainbow Rocks - 4/5

Friendship Games - 3/5

[Castle Bleck 19,360]

At least 4/5, if not more, overall.

[VengefulStrudel 1,486]

Hmm, well, I love all the seasons, and I prefer to compare pros/cons rather than give scores, but ah well. Let's see:

 

Season 1: 6/10

Season 2: 8/10

Season 3: 7/10

Season 4: 10/10

Season 5: 9/10

Season 6: Too soon to tell, but so far I'd give it a 10/10

 

Equestria Girls: 5/10

Rainbow Rocks: 8/10

Friendship Games: 6/10

 

I thought that Season 5 would've been my favorite, but upon recount, I generally enjoyed S4 episodes more than S5.

[GenderIsAnIllusion 2,177]

For me as a whole it's about a 7.5/10.... Not my favorite, but definenlty a decent show.

 

Eqg: 6/10

Rainbow Rocks: 8/10

Games: haven't seen it yet.

[Wind Chaser 4,768]

I don't normally do grading or rating, but I'll take a shot at it here.

 

S1: 4/5

S2: 4.5/5

S3: 3.2/5

S4: 2.8/5

S5: 3.8/5

Avg: 3.6/5

 

It's a pretty fair assessment of what I think of the show overall. There are better shows out there, things MLP could do to improve, and things limiting the show's reach that could hold it back. The fandom, however, greatly enhances the show's experience. The enjoyability and marketability of the characters are valuable assets, and the expanding setting is no slouch either. The art style pretty much lends itself to fan work and does a great job creating an atmosphere distinct from other shows in the MLP franchise as well as other modern cartoons. For what we have, it's a great show.

 

It's still too early to tell on Season 6. I don't know why people are just giving 1s and 10s to it already, but we're only a few episodes in.

[Odyssey 5,716]

Season 1: 6/10

Season 2: 8/10

Season 3: 5/10

Season 4: 7/10

Season 5: 7/10

 

EqG: 3/10

RR: 8/10

FG: 5/10

 

Overall: 7/10

 

I don't plan to watch Season 6 anytime soon, unless there's an episode I find to be interesting.

Edited April 27, 2016 by Odyssey

[JonasDarkmane 19,785]

Season 1: 8/10

Season 2: 7/10

Season 3: 8/10

Season 4: 8/10

Season 5: 9/10

Season 6: I think it is too soon to form an opinion about that season as of now  

 

Overall: 8/10 (Excluding Season 6) 

 

EG: 9/10

RR: 7/10

FG: 8.5/10

[Leave a Whisper 703]

6/10-Its a nice show. I sit down and watch it now and then, but it's not my favorite. Then again, I don't have a high opinion ofcartoon shows these days, so whatever.

[Concerned Bystander 2,902]

It give the entire run as a whole a pretty solid 9/10, it's definitely in my top three current cartoons, although the actual position within that top three is fairly fluid.

 

Equestria girls I would probably say 7-8/10, I have seen and enjoyed all three, but it's not at the same level as Friendship is Magic.

[Stormlight 1,371]

S1: 8/10

S2: 7/10

S3: 7/10

S4: 6/10

S5: 8/10

S6: N/A

 

Overall: 7/10

 

Have not seen any episodes from season six, and not planning on watching them anytime soon.

 

EG: 6/10

RR: 7/10

FG: 7/10

[Moon Sugar 532]

Hahaha if a show is good enough for me to make a 'ponysona' and join a forum I'm going 10/10

[cmarston1 5,959]

As an overall show I would give MLP FIM a solid 8/10.

[Phanact 333]

10/10 overall in my opinion. 

[Mesme Rize 15,683]

As a show. It's a solid 8/10.

 

It might not be considered as one of the all time greats in the future, considering if i now look at Season 1, which has not aged well. But it will certainly have a cult status.

[Dark Qiviut 22,398]

I don't do scoring or grading much, and when I review, I don't plug them in. But what the heck?

 

S1: B-

S2: B

S3: C-

S4: C+

S5: B+

 

Whole show: B

 

Season six has had some good episodes. Nothing mind-blowing, but nothing bad, either. Too early to grade at this point.

 

As for FIM, it's definitely a really good show, but there are other better cartoons out there right now. Steven Universe, which I don't like due to preferences, is objectively better than FIM. But it has a lasting legacy for bronydom coming alive and spreading their love for the show and for jumpstarting a background theme from Pixar, hundreds of children's literature, and other great cartoons from the past: Good family work is best when they're accessible and loved by kids and adults alike.

 

And EQG:

 

EQG1: F (If I could, F-)

RR: D

2014 Holiday Special: F (Again, F- if I could)

FG: F

Edited April 27, 2016 by Dark Qiviut

[Glike 487]

Season 1: 7/10

Season 2: 9/10

Season 3: 8/10

Season 4: 8.75/10

Season 5: 10/10

Season 6 (so far): 9/10

 

---

 

EG: 6/10

RR: 10/10

FG: 9/10