Dr. Pepper vs. Mr. Pibb

[Dusty Soul 2,611]

(If this is already a thread I apologize, I searched and I didn't find anything so...)

Dr. Pepper vs. Mr. Pibb. Two sodas that taste the same, but different at the same time. I ask you which one is better. The awesome Dr. Pepper or the epic Mr. Pibb.

 

I vote for Mr. Pibb because honestly I just love the taste a little bit more then Pepper's. I still like DP, but when I have to decide I will choose Mr. Pibb.

Edited August 17, 2012 by Dusty Soul

[MrFox 44]

Dr. Pepper all the way. Mr. Pibb rides the waves of Dr. Pepper.(But, seriously they are both pretty good.)

[Gears of Halo Duty V 394]

I've never had a Mr. Pibb, but this is exactly like the whole Pepsi vs. Coke thing. For me, the only time I ever have an issue with them is when they are both on the menu and I have to chose.

 

Or why not both? Dr.Pibb...

[Radiance64 7,053]

Dr. Pepper all the way, Pibb is a little too watery in my opinion.

[Ad Foedera Cresco 188]

I chose Dr. Pibb because I LOVE A&W Root Beer I like Dr. Pepper too, but it's not something i'd drink every day like Dr. Pibb.

 

(Also, Pepsi * Sprite ftw)

[Dusty Soul 2,611]

Edit: due to popular demand Dr. Pibb has been added to the selection. Lot's of Dr. Pepper fans in here.

[WTFisupwithyouguys 24]

Neither, they both taste like liquified ass. I much prefer root beer or cola or pretty much anything else.

[Vaporeon 1,168]

Neither, they both taste like liquified ass. I much prefer root beer or cola or pretty much anything else.

 

Pretty much this. You can't beat a good Coke. It's like trying to hate a Mario game you just can't do it. [The CDi game doesn't count]

[XUNUSEDXXX 3,459]

im not usually picky about sodas, but ive always liked dr pepper. it just has like a perfect taste!!

[BaBaBrony 111]

It's Pibb Extra now. Market research indicates that consumers find the name "Mr. Pibb" too misogynistic.

[Tank Legend 19]

Mr. Pibb because I don't get to have it as often as Dr. Pepper. I think they both taste the same though Pepper may be a little bit stronger than Pibb though.

[Fluttershy05 17]

...hmmm I like Dr.Pepper a little, not much but I dont like the other two. Oh yes sssppprrriiittteee ftw!

[FordFan99 9]

I like Dr. Pepper more than Pibb. I don't have Pibb very often but it's an okay substitute when I can't have Dr. Pepper.

[Zoop 8,384]

Pibb all the way - I don't even consider Dr. Pepper a viable option when Pibb is available for consumption.

[Azurini 0]

I'm going to say have to say Doctor Pepper, mostly because I've never had Mr. Pibb...

Where could I purchase Mr. Pibb ?

[Dusty Soul 2,611]

Where could I purchase Mr. Pibb ?

 

As I've been told it goes by Pibb Xtra now for some reason... So if you see that it's basically the same thing. I think Wendy's has it.

[Haven Celestii 9,385]

Dr. Pepper all the way. I've never had Mr. Pibb and don't exactly plan to unless im forced or its the only thing to drink within miles. I used to love guzzling down Dr. Pepper when I was younger, but now I'm back to full on Sprite all day errday.

[Evilshy 5,090]

This is not even close.

Dr. Pepper is the sweet nectar of the Gods. It elevates you to a higher state of existence, where all becomes well. Man walks side-by-side with the power of the universe. Flowers sprout in your footsteps and disease is cured by your breath. The taste is heavenly and can take you to worlds beyond this one. A perfect ratio of 23 flavors, mixed by a master alchemist long ago, his sights set far above a simple method to turn lead into gold; he aimed to create liquid aether. And he succeeded.

 

Pibb is a pale imitation, a wretched attempt to steal the glory of Dr. Pepper. With the taste of something a middle schooler might come up with while tryin to guess all the ingredients of Dr. Pepper, it sows agony and sorrow wherever it and it's drinkers go. None can feel joy with the taste of oblivion on their tongue, none can be satisfied as they consume a pitiful counterfeit drink, a blasphemous mockery of a truly divine beverage. Spawned in the darkest pit of the underworld, Pibb languishes and awaits a time when it can strike, bringing down Dr. Pepper, replacing truth with deceit, happiness with sorrow, peace with war, and love with hate.

 

My fellow Dr. Pepper Drinkers, we can not, and will not let this happen! We mustn't become complacent, we must stamp out Pibb wherever it leaves it's foul taste. It must be crushed under the weight of justice, morality, and all that is holy. Do not hesitate, show no mercy.

I'm sorry, Zoop, but I shall have to kill you now.

 

 

 

Umm... Yeah... Anyway... I think Dr. Pepper is better :/

[Gone Airbourne 21,977]

I have been a dr. Pepper lover for some time now... I know the difference! Mr. Pibb meh... it's ok... But Dr.Pepper & Mtn Dew are the kings of sodas.

[ToridAkbolto 170]

I prefer doctor pepper but I normally don't drink soda so I probably wouldn't be able to tell the difference anyway ^^.

[SrFrog 927]

That shouldn't be to hard to decipher, right? Dr. Pepper of course! It's smooth and sweet, just goes down easy. Took my first sip a couple of years back and good lord, I've never thought bliss could come in the form of a can.

[concertoldham 140]

Mr. Pibb all the way! I like how it's sweeter than Pepper. I don't necessarily want that bite in my soda all the time.

[Mysterystar 5]

Dr.Pepper is defenitly BETTER! but my fav soda is defenitly Coca-cola & Grape!!

[Lex 33]

We don't have either of these sodas Australia. At first I thought Dr Pepper would taste like Coke but then I heard that it's a weird mix between prune/spicy/vanilla/raspberry/cherry flavour? Mindfuck. It sounds like win in a can.

[Chill Mists (Chilly) 801]

What in the hell is Mr. Pibb? I don't think you can get it over here because I've never heard of it.