Overrated/Underrated Characters?

[TwiForLife 87]

We all have characters on this show that most certainly get a lot of lot of love and others just doesn't seem to get enough. Who do you think is the most overrated/underrated character in MLP:FiM?

 

For me:

 

Underrated: Applejack, for some reason she doesn't get a lot of love as much as the others...

 

Overrated: Probably Derpy, I fail to see the obsession with this character, though she is a cutie. And maybe Fluttershy a little.

[Doctor XFizzle 8,669]

I don't wanna call them overrated because it implies they're inferior when really we all love ponies, just some more than others

 

Under-appreciated: Applejack

Over-popular: Fluttershy, yeah I said it

[Marcato 2,143]

Overrated: Probably Derpy, I fail to see the obsession with this character, though she is a cutie. And maybe Fluttershy a little.

 

To an extent, yes. Derpy is somewhat overrated. But I think that's because of the fact that they actually gave her the name Derpy like the fans were calling her. They made it cannon and her eyes just make many people laugh and like her. But still, the whole Derpy drama was a little unnecessary.

 

IMO Twilight is a little Underrated by the fanbase. I don't see her mentioned as a favourite or any other way much online. I could be just not looking in the right spot of course.

Edited April 7, 2012 by Silver Arrow

[Senor Citizen 516]

Underrated: DISCORD.

Overrated: This technically isn't a pony, but the Rarispike shippings are trumpeted about WAY too much to be healthy.

[Trixies Apprentice L 493]

Overrated: Vinyl. scratch I mean seriously 3 secs of air time and she has almost as many fans and fics as most mane 6

 

Underrated: Appleajack It's true she gets the least love from the mane 6 and

[Crazy Misty 653]

Underrated: Like many others said Applejack

Overrated: Fluttershy

 

Now don't get me wrong, I LOVE fluttershy but them fluttershy fanboys are just crazy, I think they'd tear off there own skin and let he walk on it :v

[Doctor XFizzle 8,669]

Overrated: Vinyl. scratch I mean seriously 3 secs of air time and she has almost as many fans and fics as most mane 6

 

You're just upset Vinyl beat Trixie in the MLP March Madness poll lolol

[Vicke 3,189]

I have to agree with Leoc on this one.

Overrated: Vinyl

Underated: Applejack

 

I would also like to see more of Trixie.

[Trixies Apprentice L 493]

You're just upset Vinyl beat Trixie in the MLP March Madness poll lolol

 

.....

Maybe a bit but it still true Vinyl is over rated as hell. At least derpy is canon and they have her as an easter egg in many episodes whiile Vinyl had that 2-3 sec of airtime

 

I have to agree with Leoc on this one.

Overrated: Vinyl

Underated: Applejack

 

I would also like to see more of Trixie.

 

More Trixie I agree with that.

[Fox 5,330]

I felt like AJ was left out that's why she's my avatar. :3 I think one of the most overated characters are Rainbow Dash tbh.

[Radiance64 7,053]

Spike is so underrated it's not even funny.

[Legendary Emerald 622]

Overrated: DJ PON3. Other than the visual design, I just don't see the appeal of the character. Plus, I hate the genre of music the fans have taken to associating her with. Dubstep... ick.

 

Underrated: Berry Punch. She isn't exactly overlooked, but she doesn't receive as much attention from the fans as say, Derpy Hooves or Lyra.

Edited April 7, 2012 by Legendary Emerald

[Doctor XFizzle 8,669]

Vinyl dislike in this topic makes me sad

 

She's not overrated to me because we, the fans, can make her however we want her to be because all we were given was a 3 second clip of her design. She's like a sandbox for the fans to mold her into whatever pony they want her to be. That mystery and that ability for people to give their own interpretations is what makes Vinyl cool.

 

Unlike that jackwagon Trixie who we already know is a meanie and show off *kidding kidding*

[Rainbow_Crash 92]

underated: Rainbow dash, his ages more awesome than you can imagine

Overrated: Luna xD

[Lady Rarity Pony 4,892]

Overrated: Derpy Hooves. Overrated the Pony (aka Fluttershy).

 

Underrated: Rarity. Trixie.

[1Fluttershy 411]

Vinyl dislike in this topic makes me sad

 

She's not overrated to me because we, the fans, can make her however we want her to be because all we were given was a 3 second clip of her design. She's like a sandbox for the fans to mold her into whatever pony they want her to be. That mystery and that ability for people to give their own interpretations is what makes Vinyl cool.

 

Unlike that jackwagon Trixie who we already know is a meanie and show off *kidding kidding*

 

You're describing why the fanon version of Vinyl isn't overrated, which i'm sure others could agree with.

 

They meant the canon version of Vinyl is overrated because we haven't seen enough of her in the actual show for there to be this much hype surrounding her.

[Groo 252]

Overrated: Fluttershy, Dont get me wrong, I like her, but she is overrated.

 

Underrated: Trixie, She deserves more love!

[JhonHipster 124]

Over rated: vinyl and trixie, both have only made 1 apperance and are hugely popular

 

Under rated: octiva and Lyra

[Trixies Apprentice L 493]

Over rated: vinyl and trixie, both have only made 1 apperance and are hugely popular

 

Under rated: octiva and Lyra

 

Trixie is far from overrated. She has so many haters that completly over shadow her fanbase

[Fghik 360]

Overrated: Fluttershy...honestly, I know she's cute and all, but please: SHUT UP

 

Underrated: Clearly Applejack. Everypony loves everypony else, but Applejack just isn't getting enough love....

 

 

Then of course, the secret category, "Needs to become Overrated:" Rainbow Dash.

Sexiest Pony.

Awesome Pony.

Cutest Pony.

Iron Pony.

Coolest Pony.

Has all the elements pony.

BEST BUCKING PONY

[Champion RD92 8,658]

Underrated: Spitfire, Applejack, Luna

Overrated: Vinyl (I'm not a fan of Vinyl at all sorry)

[RippedOffMattress 314]

The most underrated is Hayseed TurnipTruck. (Severely overshadowed by that tramp Fluer De Lis http://mlpforums.com/public/style_emoticons/default/dry.png)

 

The most overrated is ironically my favorite, Fluttershy

[The Alpha Team 51]

Underrated: Spike, Luna, Spy Pony Joe

Overrated: Celestia (Really can't think of any pony)

Edited April 7, 2012 by Xevoz

[Jokuc 8,173]

Overrated: Fluttershy and tGaPT

 

Underrated: Spike, Photo Finish, Granny Smith and Applejack

Edited April 7, 2012 by Jokuc

[--- 41]

Underrated: Applejack, for some reason she doesn't get a lot of love as much as the others...

 

Overrated: Probably Derpy, I fail to see the obsession with this character, though she is a cutie. And maybe Fluttershy a little.

 

That is PRECISELY what I was going to say!

 

I might add that I think Rarity is under appreciated, too. I don't think she deserves the amount of criticism she gets.