general media Worst fanfiction you've ever read?

[Alpha9571 69]

There are some pretty bad fanfics out there.I have read many.

The worst is probably either My Immortal or Half Life:Full life Consequences(which is so bad it's good,like The Room or Troll 2) in my opinion. 

What are the worst fanfics you've ever read?

Edited May 25, 2014 by Alpha9571

[Discordian 6,015]

Not much of a fanfic reader. I prefer my fanworks in comic or visual art form.

 

The only ones I've read are the first couple big ones: Cupcakes (plus a couple alternate endings) and My Little Dashie. Out of the two, Cupcakes is definitely the lesser one simply because MLD actually induced some genuine emotions. Cupcakes was mostly laughs. Though I fully admit that the first time I read it I didn't see Pinkie in the same light until I watched the show again to reaffirm Pinkie's original concept.

[GoneForeverBye 184]

That... is a very difficult question you pose there, Alpha. Why? Well, all it takes is one glance at the FanFiction website, and suddenly you have a dozen or so more crap to choose from. Quite difficult, considering I am in a constant hunt for good Zelda fanfiction...

 

I can't think of the 'worst', but one I happened to come across made for a good laugh...

 

The basic gist of it? You had Shadlink (actual name... Also, I find I pronounce it as 'Shit Link'. Hah.), born in the Twilight Realm with the fourth piece of the Triforce (Bravery, which... well...) and he had to reunite the Twilight Realm and the Light World...

 

Again, not the 'worst', but just that sticks out in my mind at the moment...

Edited May 25, 2014 by Oleg

[Megas 27,594]

My Little Dashie, I still have no idea how that's one of the most revered fanfics ever

[M'aiq the Liar 5,804]

Do you mean like bad in the classical sense? Like apple family massacre were they got the anatomy wrong in their gorefic? I mean, if you are going to write a gorefic, get the anatomy, and description of internal organs correct. And as for just lazy and terrible, any OCxMane6 clopfic is terrible.

 

 

But for my personal worst, FoE. Prose so purple it broke the carrying capacity of the ultra violet spectrum, a chapter structor with no consistency, a main character who either bored me or pissed me off. And their entire journey/plot was a copy paste of fallout 3, with some fallout 1 and 2 elements thrown in, and just painted pony.

[Courageous Thunder Dash 7,824]

Don't get me started, I've got quite a few on my list like

 

Sweet Apple Massacre and all other fanfics that have unnecessary gore that is just used to shock the reader. 

[Castle Bleck 19,338]

Anything by SaiyanUltima.

 

It's always OP Human X Princess Harem with him.

Edited January 1, 2016 by A.V.

[Discordian 6,015]

That... is a very difficult question you pose there, Alpha. Why? Well, all it takes is one glance at the FanFiction website, and suddenly you have a dozen or so more crap to choose from. Quite difficult, considering I am in a constant hunt for good Zelda fanfiction...

 

I can't think of the 'worst', but one I happened to come across made for a good laugh...

 

The basic gist of it? You had Shadlink (actual name... Also, I find I pronounce it as 'Shit Link'. Hah.), born in the Twilight Realm with the fourth piece of the Triforce (Bravery, which... well...) and he had to reunite the Twilight Realm and the Light World...

 

Again, not the 'worst', but just that sticks out in my mind at the moment...

Breaking world building balance is usually pretty terribad. It's fun to do on your own time but it doesn't garner a lot of attention cuz it ruins the validity of existing canon.

Edited May 25, 2014 by Discordian

[sxp 404]

My Immortal, the ultimate best worst fanfiction. I highly recommend the below dramatic reading if you want a good laugh.

[Alpha9571 69]

Oh I forgot:

 

 

Half Life:Full Life Consequences 

 

So bad it's good.

More Half Life.

 

Peter Chimaera has written some bad fanfics(actually,all of them are horrible).

https://www.fanfiction.net/u/181593/Peter-Chimaera

Edited May 25, 2014 by Alpha9571

[Celtore 2,770]

Metroid High School. Not to say it isn't extremely entertaining in how bad it is of course...

[Khaoios 1,970]

My Little Dashie, I still have no idea how that's one of the most revered fanfics ever

 

I concur..........it was very depressing, especially the "tone" of it.  Not really appealing to me, tbh

[Yellow Diamond 7,568]

I won't name titles, but I am particularly irritated by the "Recon Sniper in Equestria" and other such stories that crop up on Fimfiction every now and again. They're generally poorly written, filled with gun porn (i.e., copying the Wikipedia article for a weapon or vehicle), possess little faithfulness to the content of MLP, and ultimately read like weird power fantasies on the part of the author.

[Panne 1,342]

Easy way to find horrible fanfics on fimfiction. Just browse: Mature Sex Gore and you will be able to find many many horrible fics. The worst one I read, though I forgot what it was called, fell under this category. I made zero sense the description had nothing to do with the story the, cover art was MS Paint, it had over 200 dislikes, the grammar was so broken, one second the guy is sexing luna then the next they are killing zombie ponies, Stalin and Lenin make an appearance even though humans weren't even in the tags... there was no way that it was passed through by a mod that was sober...

Edited May 26, 2014 by Biznis Kitty

[ghostfacekiller39 23,860]

Barring any gorefics, because I hate all of them, I'd say My Little Dashie.

 

WHY ON EARTH is that pile of rubbish popular? It's TERRIBLE! The dialogue sucks, the storytelling sucks, and it just feels like it wants to force "feels" out of the reader rather than tell a coherent story. It's terrible.

[Panne 1,342]

My Little Dashie, I still have no idea how that's one of the most revered fanfics ever

I'll tell you why it is so popular, it is a self insert fanfic that isn't at the same time. The main character is so bland and flat that he could be any sad Brony that is reading it. Seriously off  the top of anybody's head, nobody can tell me his name because he doesn't matter. All that matters is that you can adopt Dashie for yourself.

Barring any gorefics, because I hate all of them, I'd say My Little Dashie.

 

WHY ON EARTH is that pile of rubbish popular? It's TERRIBLE! The dialogue sucks, the storytelling sucks, and it just feels like it wants to force "feels" out of the reader rather than tell a coherent story. It's terrible.

See my above statement as to why people like it...

[Commissar Alexer 763]

There are plenty of bad fanfictions, some just plain bad and some ouright horrifying like for example: Traumatic Insemination.

 

Horny Changeling Warriors + lone and defenseless Zecora = AAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!

[Pripyat Pony 2,608]

Loads. The worst ones I've ever encountered are definitely legolas by laura, My Immortal, Prisoner of Imaldris, Celebrian and Subjugation. Thank goodness for hilarious youtube presentations. XD

 

Here's a funny video of "legolas by laura".

 

 

And another.

 

 

Also, a Sims video of My Immortal. Part one, but if you are interested, you can find the other parts on youtube as well. XD

 

 

And a live action. Somehow, the live actions of crappy fanfics are always the funniest.

 

[N.W. 3,619]

My own, no I am not posting the title or linking, I hate it, but feel obligated to finish it as some people did say they wanted me to continue it.

[ReverseFaller 2,483]

Sweet Apple Massacre. It's poorly written, the grammar is atrocious, and it's just gross. 

[Skeleton Kin 385]

I guess I could say Cupcakes since it is pretty much a gore pornography, though I am a fan of gore the fanfic is pretty tasteless in the sense of gore.

[Pripyat Pony 2,608]

Any fanfic which ships two female ponies and has them have a foal together. Um, did you pay attention in sex ed?

 

 

I understand that you want your same sex pairing to have a foal together, but you could, you know, do what same sex couples do in reality; ie, get a co-operative male to donate. You can't just have two females breed a foal between them with no male in sight.

[Everleaf 541]

Likely Sweet Apple Massacre I like some gore time to time but it was the writing which got to me...

[Odyssey 5,716]

My Little Unicorn. This fanfic is hilarious for all of the wrong reasons. I find it more hilarious that it's written by an anti-brony.

 

Also, My Immortal.

[Christmasy Britty 2,553]

okay back when the site fanfiction.net originally went up there were not a lot of fanfics, however the few that were there were some what decent, then things changed and the site got popular and everyone was on it. with it being so popular there were an addition of questionable works O_o one of them being in the Harry Potter section. this particular work is probably not there anymore I forget the name but I remember the concept it was baisically Hermione Granger being shipped with every male character in the series with her character being so mary sueish that it borderlined on her being a completely different person. the story might of worked out well had the author not lost so much interest that they changed the story where random things would happen that did not make sense, at one point Ron dies of an overdose of heroin and its never explained why or the fact that he is an addict lol I guess we as readers were supposed to assume that, but overall i'd call it the worst thing I ever read and I have not found one that bad since, believe me it was so bad you couldn't pull yourself away even if you tried XD