What if a voice actor/actress quit? Would you still love a pony they voice?

[BritishBrony2012 823]

Just wondering what if one of voice actor/actress quit, like what if Tara Strong stop voicing Twilight Sparkle and voice by another voice actress? She was popular. Maybe Most bronies will still carry on loving their pony even voice actress quit. Bronies do love these voice actresses, of course I do, but would if it another voice actress voicing your favorite pony?

[PROJECT: Simon 3,955]

Of course I will. Ill just imagine they had cold and their voice changed. 

[BritishBrony2012 823]

Voice actors/actresses do make different voices so, a voice actress could have same voice as Tara Strong/Twilight, but guess some people don't want to see different person, cos they like the person who voice their favorite character since beginning.

[Hovershy 3,814]

If Tara Strong for some reason left (God forbid) I bet they would have Rebecca Shoichet take over as her normal and singing voice. 

 

But I don't know if Andrea Libman quit, I would be devastated. 

It would really suck if any of them left, but I would still watch the show, it might not be quite the same though.

[HereComesTom 2,268]

It wouldn't really ruin it for me, and I'd wish the actress well on her future endeavors.

 

...That being said, I still wish they could've gotten Ashleigh Ball and/or Andrea Libman in the Pacman Ghostly Adventures game...

[Silver Letter 1,832]

I would miss their voices but I would still enjoy the show and the characters they used to voice.

[ponylaces 1,870]

If the transition was anything like what they did in The Amazing World of Gumball (where the new voice actor/actress sounds similar to the old voice), then I wouldn't care.

 

If they totally changed the voice, that would be a different story. I'd still like the character, but it just won't feel the same.

[Argumedies 1,748]

Pictures Flutterguy as permanent voice...

 

Might want, but not sure....

 

Now if TSG left then THAT would be the worst possible thing and then I think I'd call it game over

Edited November 8, 2014 by Argumedies

[Roughshod 719]

No. That pony would be dead to me. Equestria would be dead to me. They would only serve as a bitter reminder of what had been and could never be again... The crushing reality of heart rendering shock and turmoil shaking my treasured world to its foundations and leaving emotional rubble at my hooves...

 

How can you even suggest such a thing? You're so cruel...

[Fawkes The Phoenix 737]

If the voice sounds similar I wouldn't mind so much, but if the voice is different it would never be the same. That happened to Luna in the latin american dub, her voice in Luna Eclipsed was really good, but they changed her voice in season 3 and it was awful, something similar happened to Scootaloo, but her new voice is not that bad.

 

If Tabitha ever quits it would be terrible, even if the new actress is good, i doubt she would be as amazing as Tabitha

[Zekromic 1,054]

If the voice sounds similar I wouldn't mind so much, but if the voice is different it would never be the same. That happened to Luna in the latin american dub, her voice in Luna Eclipsed was really good, but they changed her voice in season 3 and it was awful, something similar happened to Scootaloo, but her new voice is not that bad.

Damn, I been watching ponies in English so long that I didn't became aware of that. About Scootie, they changed her voice Twice, Gaby Ugarte was her voice in season 1, another actress took over when the former went to France, but the current one is Maggie 

Vera, who always been her singing voice (and Flutty's voice too  )

 

I dunno how to react if a main character's voice is changed after over 4 years with the same actors with most of the main and recurring characters, and that's quite a feat. The only recurring character whose voice has been changed that I know off in MLP (In it's original dub at least) is Pips, whose original actor was going trough puberty in his second spoken appearance (Twilight Time) btw) 

[Andaasonsan 3,205]

I dunno how to react if a main character's voice is changed after over 4 years with the same actors with most of the main and recurring characters, and that's quite a feat. The only recurring character whose voice has been changed that I know off in MLP (In it's original dub at least) is Pips, whose original actor was going trough puberty in his second spoken appearance (Twilight Time) btw) 

Well there is Bonbon 

 

 

Some crazy person might be inclined to think that she was never intended as an actual character and just as a generic all-purpose pony model.

[Zekromic 1,054]

Well there is Bonbon 

 

 

 

Some crazy person might be inclined to think that she was never intended as an actual character and just as a generic all-purpose pony model.

Well, despite her popularity, she's still a background pony, and as such, the staff gives zero fuck on her voice, nor her tone (since Tabitha did most of her lines as far as I know)

[HereComesTom 2,268]

Well, despite her popularity, she's still a background pony, and as such, the staff gives zero fuck on her voice, nor her tone (since Tabitha did most of her lines as far as I know)

 

That's not quite true; I think I heard somewhere that one of the toys of her (though they're calling her Sweetie Drops for some reason) had a blurb about her being able to change her voice easily.

[Falsey 44]

To give you a hint, I am unsettled when I hear the fandom's voice actresses/actors playing the mane 6/cmc, or any other characters from the show that already have established voices. So, I would still like a pony's design, but not necessarily the character, after a voice change.

[Oblivion 20,268]

Absolutely NOT, their is nothing in the whole wide world of Equestria that would make me stop loving my Dashie!

 

 

 

[Adorkable 2,737]

It would be hard to get used to, obviously. But as long as their character was the same, I suppose I would be alright with it. ^^"

[MassReflux 12]

I will love the pony for who they are, The voice however depends if it's bad good or better, Either way I will Like the character, (Unless if its Diamond Tiara or Gilda) I'll just complain about the voice about it being bad or better if that ever happens.

[Pastel 7,630]

It depends on how different the new voice is compared to the original.

For example, Derpy's new voice was too different from the original...

[Megas 27,746]

Depends, I could enjoy it if they perfectly emulated the voice or sound pretty close. If Ashleigh Ball ever left, I could see the person who voices Spinelli from Recess doing RD justice

[Lulaypp 2,555]

Well if AJ's voicer left, I won't be sad as long as the new person can put on a country accent and can sing country as good as the current one.

As for Pinkie, the replacment have to put the enthuiasm like how Andrea Libman does. If not, it won't be the same...

[Holiday Agnaktor 1,436]

If they sound alike, I'll be fine with it. I probably won't even notice. (I'm bad, I know) But if they change Discords voice actor... *shudders* ;-; John de Lancie is the best...