Best Pie [POLL]

[Pastel 7,630]

Pinkie Pie will always be my favorite.

But of course, Marble Pie and Maud Pie are great too. (I'm surprised by Marble's popularity Oo)

[GuyNamedEarl 1,332]

Marble Pie is so cute, she's basically Fluttershy without the extreme social anxiety.

[redaxted 1,765]

Pinkie Pie! She's the best! She;s just so funny and loveable and... Pinkie Pie! So yeah, Pinkie is Pie. But in a close second is Maud, naturally. I am also strangely drawn to rocks.

As for my favourite kind of pie, apple pie; it's the only pie I've ever eaten, if I"m completely honest. It's great with custard, I think!

[BPCannon 193]

3 letters in Pie

 

1 Mother

4 Sisters

1 Father

5 with the last name Pie

9 Letters in Limestone

2 With M as the first letter of their first name

6 in the Family

5 Females

3 Grey(ish coloured) Ponies (getting tenuous now, as if it wasnt enough already)

5 Letters in Rocks (pushing it)

9 Letters in Pinkie Pie

 

Pi = 3.14159265359

 

HELP, THE CONSPIRACIES ARE IN MY HOUSE!

Edited October 25, 2015 by BPCannon

[Snake 516]

Pinkie Pie all the way. <3

Also, I do not like pie... I was forced to pick Apple. I am sorry. I have lied. 

I DON'T LIKE APPLE PIE
I do like the ship though!
 

[Envy 6,167]

I remain with Pinkie and Maud Pie. Although I did really like seeing the rest of the family and their personalities.

 

As for real pie, the kind I really like is custard pie, which is not in the poll, so...

[VengefulStrudel 1,486]

Ah, I love 'em all~ Out of the 'new' ones, I'd have to say Limestone, she's so grumpy But Marble is quite adorable~

 

Out of real pie, I guess apple pie? Never really ate too much pie, so...

[Lyra's Pants 154]

I have a feeling the only reason why Marble Pie's winning the "Favorite Pie" poll is because of her relationship with Big Mac.

 

Take that away, and how will she fare with just her "mmmhmmm's" and shy personality?

[M'gann M'orzz 745]

Marble has effectively no personality beyond the basest bits of being a Fluttershy clone, she was by FAR the least interesting character introduced in the most recent, depressing to see her winning, that moeblobs with no character are what people want.

 

Compared to characters like well Pinkie who is one of the main freaking characters and really should not be on this poll, Maud who's received quite a bit of characterization over the episodes she's appeeared in and has many many hilarious moments and even Limestone demonstrated lots of passion, and dedication to her work, as weird as it may be, plus she was hilarious. 

Edited October 25, 2015 by M'gann M'orzz

[Arrowstormen 62]

Marble Pie is so cute, she's basically Fluttershy without the extreme social anxiety.

She seemed way more shy than Fluttershy ever was. 

 

Can't pick between Pinkie, Maud and Marble. Leaning towards Maud because I love her deadpan humor, but it feels weird not to pick Pinkie. Marble is just adorbs. 

[Kyoshi Frost Wolf 41,531]

Limestone Pie, you win this vote from me. She might be incredibly harsh and abrasive, but that is the thing, every very harsh character has a soft and sweet side to them as well and often, it is incredibly cute when that shows. So I will go with Limestone, she is a badass, cute and I can guarantee she is doubly cute when her soft side shows. :3

 

Also, the favorite type of pie vote needs an 'other' option because I do not like any of the listed ones, I like Oreo pie. :3

[Luna the Great of all the Russias 2,985]

I don't know between Maud and Marble.

[Glike 487]

Marble has effectively no personality beyond the basest bits of being a Fluttershy clone, she was by FAR the least interesting character introduced in the most recent, depressing to see her winning, that moeblobs with no character are what people want.

 

Compared to characters like well Pinkie who is one of the main freaking characters and really should not be on this poll, Maud who's received quite a bit of characterization over the episodes she's appeeared in and has many many hilarious moments and even Limestone demonstrated lots of passion, and dedication to her work, as weird as it may be, plus she was hilarious.

 

I see your point, but that last part seems rather subjective. I found Limestone more annoying and unnecessarily aggressive than hilarious. It's the same kind of behavior that made a bunch of people dislike Gilda.

[Lexamena 391]

PINKIE! will always be number 1 in my book. Then Maud and then Marble.

[Princess_Bellalatanya 1,053]

marble pie and pinkie pie

[Moved to Elsewhere 11,331]

I'll be predictable and vote Pinkie.

 

Also, I don't actually eat the traditional kind of pie so apple.

[Odyssey 5,716]

From favourite to least favourite:

1. Maud Pie
2. Limestone Pie
3. Pinkie Pie
4. Igneous Rock/Cloudy Quartz
5. Marble Pie

I will say though that it was hard deciding whether or not I prefer Maud or Limestone. While I do like how mature Maud is than the other Pies, I can relate to Limestone's demeanour. Plus, Limestone has the best mane of the Pies. I can't say I'm too crazy over Marble Pie, though. She has a pretty mane, but I don't particularly like the whole "cute person who happens to be shy" trope. It gets stale quickly, at least for me.

 

As for my favourite traditional pie, it's definitely apple pie. Not only does it taste nice, but it's also kind of special to my family. We would always have apple pie alongside with ice cream on holidays like Christmas and whatnot.

Edited October 25, 2015 by Duchess

[cmarston1 5,959]

Outside of Pinkie I have to go with Maud as being the best member of the Pie Family.

[Star-Gazer 202]

Best Pie? Pinkie Pie, of course.   .

[M'gann M'orzz 745]

I see your point, but that last part seems rather subjective. I found Limestone more annoying and unnecessarily aggressive than hilarious. It's the same kind of behavior that made a bunch of people dislike Gilda.

 

Well if you find her funny or not is subjective, but i don't think it's really hard to say that Limestone received a lot more actual characterization than Marble.

[MLPFanatic34 3,234]

Definitely Maud Pie, but I love Pinkie Pie!

[Omega Centauri 317]

Pinkie pie is my favorite of both the pies and the main 6, so since that was a bit of a given, I gave my vote to Marble Pie instead.

[Hovershy 3,814]

Haha, no one voted for either of the parents. 

 

As for the new question, blueberry pie is sooooo good.

[Shanks 10,816]

Wow Marble Pie got real popular real fast, she is quite adorable though. For me it is Pinkie Pie though I also love Maud and Marble.

[MidnightNoir 13]

Clearly the greatest pie is Steak and Ale Pie. And the best desert pie is Lemon Meringue pie.

 

And the best Pony Pie is Maud Pie.

 

Marble, as cute as she was, is just an inferior Fluttershy clone.