What Eye Color Fits Vinyl Scratch Better?

[Misty Rose 3,216]

Ok so I'm curious. Vinyl Scratch has been shown with two eye colors? In fan made pictures with red eyes, and super briefly in A Canterlot Wedding, and Equestria Girls with purplish rose eyes. Kind of like Rainbow Dash's. Which color do you guys think goes with her better?

I personally think the red is a little too dark for her white coat and mane colors. I like the rose color best. What do you guys think?

Edited August 11, 2013 by Pink Mist

[Mr. Critical 434]

The purple are fine. But with the red ones, people will make the asumption that vinyl is a stoner. And the show has nough to deel with as is.

[Moonlight 7,286]

Personally...I like the shade to the right better....Red eyes just look really strange on a pony, but the darker shade looks quite lovely. 

[SkyBound 828]

I would definitely have to go with the rose-colored eyes over the red.  Vinyl already has quite a vibrant coloring with her hair and I think the red eyes with it are a bit too much while the rose is a bit more subtle and blend much more nicely.

[Lunas Husband 2,777]

I have to say purple, looks so much better on her. The red looks kind of.. off like she's evil or something. The purple makes her look for friendly and loving

[GrimCW 658]

The right fits better IMO.

Although the comic cover shown at the end of the Big mac book has them as red as well... Not sure the designers at hasbro ever agreed on anything it seems.

TMK she was always intended to have RD's deep red looking ones though.

[Misty Rose 3,216]

Yeah I saw Love Is In Bloom again and she does take off her glasses for like two seconds!! I was like SQUEE I SAW IT THIS TIME!! They were kind of like RD'S even from far away you can tell they're not red. *shakes head* Fans, I don't know how they thought they were red.

[Kyoshi Frost Wolf 41,494]

The red just pops out against the rest of her color scheme and in this case that is not exactly a good thing. The purple-ish color is much more appealing to the eye, or eyes if we are being technical about it.

 

The red color is indeed being very selfish, not realizing that it is the odd one in the group.

[Winona the Dog 1,984]

I prefer the purplish eye color.

 

The red makes her look demonic or something and I don't really like it. The purplish shade though seems pretty though. 

[Brother Orin 20]

I do like her magenta eyes.

 

I don't mind seeing the red eyes that people draw up, but the problem is a lot of people give a lot of hate to the cannon eyes.

A lot of people even give me a lot of guff over my own work because I used her magenta eyes, some people just need to relax.

[GrimCW 658]

some people just need to relax.

 

Nailed that one big time... 

ANY little change to whats already set and watch the fireworks.... oye.

TBH i sometimes question the actual average age of the typical brony

[MichaelxXxTrixie 433]

Red eyes look cooler honestly to me but it could spring all this dumb fan-junk about how she wears sunglasses to hide that she's a stoner and of-course after the Derpy incident we might have parents jumping all over that concept. 

 

In my depiction the Red eyes fit her better because it creates a unique contrast no-other pony has. 

 

But the rose color is perfectly fine with me.

[Sugar Song 6]

Meh, doesn't matter to me, but I personally like the purplish Rose-colored eyes as seen in Equestria Girls.

Just my opinion, but the rose-colored eyes look a little cuter.

[lincolnshirepony 527]

I'm partial to the purplish eyes. It fits with her color scheme a little bit better. The red is just a bit jarring. It seems out of place, IMO.

[ReGen 1,466]

It seems the general consensus is that purple is better. 

 

I agree, it doesn't pop out as much as the red and blends in with the rest of Vinyl. 

[Moniker 93]

I would agree with the purple eye color it fits her characteristics better in my thoughts of course others think differently.

Edited August 11, 2013 by ShadowBolts

[Ihei 713]

I'd say purple. I don't know why, but red kind of.. stands out and it doesn't really suit Vinyl's appearance. Purple is more of Vinyl's kind of color.

[Celtore 2,770]

I don't know... I sort of like the magenta eyes a bit more. The red eyes on the left seem to stand out a bit more from her overall design and it doesn't look quite as natural. My stance might differ if we were comparing two ponies rather than a pony and a human, but I think my opinion is fair.

[Dsanders 5,747]

The red makes her look like a vampire, which probably lead some fans to write some of those fan-fictions that involve Vinyl Scratch being a vampire(other than the fact that she often wears the shades).

 

^In fact, it's probably that very fact on how she wears her shades all the time that lead fans to come out up with the whole vampire headcannon.

 

I personally don't support that fan junk.

 

I think the rose color fits her much better since it looks a lot more natural.

Edited August 11, 2013 by Sanderspie

[GhostPony750 959]

I have to say Purple.

1. It was supposed to be purple from the beggining, I guess.

2. It fits way better, since Red is oo flashy, and she already have bright blue mane.

[Misty Rose 3,216]

Oh wait totally forgot to make a poll out of this. Just to make it easier to see the results. But I can clearly see that most people are voting for purple. SWEET  

[Azura 1,107]

Definitely the purple eyes, the red just looks creepy. Purple looks a lot more subtle and easy to the eye compared to red. No wonder she always wears her shades to cover them up.

[hawkflame 3,310]

Definitely magenta. The red clashes so severely with the rest of her design that it just doesn't look right. The bloodshot look just doesn't work .

[Tails_155 68]

In all honesty, she's had purple as a pony, too. But that aside, I don't really think there's a "fit" of one over the other. I think they are what they are.

[~Silver Essence~ 2,625]

The purple shading looks the best to me, despite it being my favorite color.

 

The red is her fan cannon color, but purple looks the most fitting.