Trixie or Twilight?

[Ember_star 229]

 

YARRR INTO THE THREAD!

 

Twilight Nuff said

[Radiance64 7,051]

lol Trixie, go Twilight.

[Nas 2,863]

Wait...wait a second.

 

You are comparing a main character with an antagonist.

 

 

 

Tarapony all the way.

[Sunny Fox 5,934]

I'm going to choose Trixie. I really think she'll return, but for what reason, I don't know. But I bet she'll have some epic episode with some intense character development that makes everyone feel for her. Lessons will be learned, tears will be shed, and friendships will form. Were there to be a seventh element, it would be Trxie.

 

I was going to be rude and sarcastic about your suggestion of a Seventh Element, but then I thought, what if it really happened? What Element of Harmony would Trixie represent? Element of Reconciliation? Any other suggestions? Edited July 6, 2012 by Full Spectrum

[Tuxedo Kamen! 114]

It seems like the good majority of the ponies were either solid twilight or a tough choice between the two. I Chose (You) Trixie, no contest

[Starswirl the Trixie 974]

This comparison is a bit unfair. The main character versus a controversial minor character? No surprise.

 

I want to see Gilda vs Trixie...

[Flame Blitz 85]

Trixie. Her personality is funny, and she could be a good rival for Twilight.

[ZStrike37 107]

I was going to be rude and sarcastic about your suggestion of a Seventh Element, but then I thought, what if it really happened? What Element of Harmony would Trixie represent? Element of Reconciliation? Any other suggestions?

 

Umm, maybe Element of Humility? Element of Trust? Element of Forgiveness? I'm trying to think of different aspects of what constitutes friendship that could be represented by an element. I do like the Element of Reconciliation.

 

I don't think they will really add another element, I think it'd be digging themselves into a deep hole storywise. But you never know. Maybe there are "lesser" elements that can affect the regular elements but have no power of their own. I don't know

[Strawberry Tart 161]

Trixie isn't half as talented as our favorite bookworm, Twilight!

[Guest]

Twilight, cuz Twilight.

[Ponei 48]

Twilight because Sparkle

Edited July 8, 2012 by Ponei

[RippedOffMattress 314]

Twilight.

 

She's a good filly.

[Chill Mists (Chilly) 801]

Trixie was a huge jerk. Twilight is really nice.

[Tom The Diamond 1,828]

Anypony who votes for Twilight is horridly biased and their vote should not count.

 

Anypony who votes for Trixie clearly knows who is the best, and should be rewarded a spot in Valhalla. (New York, not the real Valhalla, you can't get in there without a reservation these days.)

[Ember_star 229]

nope nope nope

[Half-Note 273]

Trixie is best pony. No. Discussion.

[Yukito 9]

Oh man, my two favourite ponies pitted together...I'd like to vote for both, but unfortunatly, I can't...I'll vote for Trixie, since she needs more love :3

[PonyEcho 1,610]

OK lets do this

(pulls out the mighty coin of fate and decision making)

Heads= Twilight

Tails = Trixie

(Flips coin)

Trixie wins