What would your favorite pony have to do to lose favor in your eyes?

[PonyMage 228]

So what would your favorite pony have to do lose that position, and make them only your second favorite character or worse?

 

My favorite pony is Applejack. She would stop being my favorite pony if she lost her mind and killed her family.

Or if we're aiming for something more plausible to actually happen, I might like her somewhat less if she was revealed to be scornful or disapproving of Big Mac's closet fantasies of being a hero, or maybe she wasn't understanding of what he did in Brotherhooves Social.

 

How about y'all?

[yeet 2,027]

If fluttershy were to stop being a doormat. That's why I like her XD

[Castle Bleck 19,351]

If they all started acting like the Go! versions of the Teen Titans.

 

[GrimGrimoire 4,973]

I dunno.. I like Twilight the way I do because I identify with her personality and interests a lot. She would have to undergo a complete personality change for me to dislike her or start liking the other characters over her.

[FluttersisBestPony 63]

Same with Flutters, I relate to her and if I stopped relating to her? So pretty much if either me or her underwent a complete perosanlity switch. Although I think I'd still like Flutters even if that happened! lol 

[RivkaBobble 110]

My favorite pony is Pinkie Pie! I love her bubbly personality, and how she's always trying to make other ponies happy. She'd need to stop trying to cheer up other ponies or become less social

[Ganondorf8 11,298]

If Sunset were to regress back to being a bully who desires power above all else.

[Luminance 2,186]

Nopony is perfect but a far-fetched idea to make me lose my favor specifically would be if Princess Twilight became blinded by her status and loses her humbleness and eagerness to help others and her friends. In a position like her is very easy to overlook and stress over the most simplest things because she has quite a large role and duty as a advocate of peace for all of Equestria. Anything to make her a complete nightmare of herself for obvious reasons dictate that she had lost herself in what she believed in and what she learned upon all of those long gone days and that can be a very devastating result. Not just for me but for her entire characterization in the show as well.

[Kings&Hooves14 616]

I think Rarity would have to become a genocidal megalomaniac for me to dislike her.

[LeafFerret 3,382]

If Applejack is given a reduced role in the show like not being the secondary protagonist behind Twilight.

[cmarston1 5,959]

If Fluttershy were to lose her assertiveness that she gained through seasons 5 and 6.

[Tropical Melody 6,146]

Nopony is perfect but a far-fetched idea to make me lose my favor specifically would be if Princess Twilight became blinded by her status and loses her humbleness and eagerness to help others and her friends. In a position like her is very easy to overlook and stress over the most simplest things because she has quite a large role and duty as a advocate of peace for all of Equestria. Anything to make her a complete nightmare of herself for obvious reasons dictate that she had lost herself in what she believed in and what she learned upon all of those long gone days and that can be a very devastating result. Not just for me but for her entire characterization in the show as well.

 

There's a plot right there! Say if she was possessed by something, then brought back to normality by the love from her friends.

[KiraTakahashi 748]

If rainbow dash were to finally quit it all and ignore her friends I'd so be done with her.

[EmeraldStar04 250]

If my favorite pony became Starlight Glimmer, then yeah.

[Lightning Pixel 34]

If Fluttershy becomes an opposite of herself (I'm mad at Discord since he appeared in show because of that)

[TBD 17,254]

If RD have to apology for something she doesn't need to apology (oh wait...she already did..​28 prank later) 

 

if RD have a crush on somebony. I can't really see her in a "owning" relationship, she is more of a free pony. and also if lost her touch on her awesomeness.

Edited November 1, 2016 by satrox

[Castle Bleck 19,351]

There's a plot right there! Say if she was possessed by something, then brought back to normality by the love from her friends.

 

They did that in comics #43-45 (the ones with the "Dark Water" or whatever).

[Jimmy Page Fan 39]

I know RD is supposed to be a narcissist, but if that became her 'big thing' and she just stopped caring for anyone but herself then, yeah, she would not be my favourite pony.

Out of the shows boundaries? Probably murder.

[Widdershins 9,959]

Sell their body.

...

Well, let me put it this way. My favorites are Limestone, Celestia & Maud. So yeah, maybe I have soft spot for tough girls, but I can understand a bit of a give in a tough demeanor. Each of the main characters have had their mental breakdowns, so I'm not about to leave somepony when the chips are down & their mood isn't up to being as much as a bluster as usual. But there's a limit.

You lose respect for yourself to that extent, you lose mine. And considering how Loyalty is my biggest trait...well, that's putting it to a depressing degree.

 

On a happier note! If Fluttershy started up with some bunk like "Flies are an important part of our ecosystem." No, there's only so much hippie I can take. And I LIKE hippies! You protect them little decaymongerers an' I'm swattin' you with the rest of the pests!