Who was your FIRST favorite pony?

[L1ghtn1ng_Flash 213]

I believe my favorite pony was fluttershy, or maybe celestia, i have memory problems as it is, and i certainly have a no memory of anything i did three years ago.

 

[Varrack 1,080]

It was Rainbow Dash, and then it became Starlight Glimmer for a while, but now I think I'm turning back to RD. They're both great, but RD has more of a history in the show so...yeah

[PinkieAwesome 65]

Pinkie Pie

Ever since smile hd which brought me to the show

I just find her adorable and awesome

I have never been annoyed by her antics

I would say rainbow dash is the most annoying pony..i like rainbow dash though just not more than the other 5

[The Mint Pone 2,294]

Rainbow Dash because she was the one that i saw everywhere before starting to watch the show. Also rainbows are great so i loved here design from the get go.

[Luminn 109]

Rarity was my favourite, back in S1, I relate to her creativity, so I assume that was the reason. Nowadays its gotta be AJ

[Niniibear 157]

At first was Pinkie Pie,but then then it's Moon butt all the way :3

[Zamasu 20]

Twilight.

Right now its either Twiilight or Starlight... too close to call.

[Rawzy 1,302]

Rainbow Dash was my favourite pony from the beginning, although these days it would probably be Pinkie Pie if she had more episodes :/ I need that positive happiness in my life right now I guess xD

[Renzie 100]

My first favourite pony was Scootaloo.

[Foxy Socks 2,599]

My first favorite was definitely Rainbow Dash. As soon as I saw her I fell in love with her.    Despite being different than me, I admired her.

 

Now my favorite is...  Rainbow Dash. My opinion hasn't changed.   

Edited June 3, 2016 by Namae

[Mooncake 38]

Pinkie Pie was my favourite. I thought she was hilarious and I loved the little noise when she jumps around, thought it was really unique.

[Zeal Crown 196]

Applejack. Funny enough, it was from Smile HD. I thought she looked really pleasing, and I really enjoyed her hat. I then followed suggested videos that had her in the thumbnail and grew to learn about her and like her. It's also how I got into this fandom. Thanks to Applejack.

[HolyCelestia 8]

Celestia, the best troll in Equestria

[Tarnation 142]

It used to be Princess celestia , but now it is Rares

[PiratePony 8,475]

First it was good ole Applejack...she's still a near tie with my favorite pony. Wild guess who that is.

[TeeSix 116]

When I became a brony way back in mid-2012, I didn't really have much of a favourite pony. I kinda liked Twilight and Rainbow a little more than the others, but whew, I still remember the date - December 15th, 2012, or December 16th here in New Zealand. That was when Wonderbolt Academy first aired, one of two episodes that I've ever been able to watch live. And that was when I fell in love with Lightning Dust's character - cocky, sassy and brazen tomboy who doesn't take "no" for an answer. Loved her ever since. 

[-Nobody- 519]

Rarity. My first and last!

[Cwanky 17,579]

Applejack by far. honestly though, when I first saw Applejack , her appearance and mannerisms made me cringe and I initially passed her off as a bad country cowboy stereotype from the first episode.

 

But that changed quickly as I saw her actions and how she's a much deeper character that I quickly came to respect and enjoy. Fluttershy has also caught up on that list and dare I say, despite her annoying habits Pinkie also has begun to grow on this cranky old donkey.

[Detritus 258]

Fluttershy was the one who kept me watching past the first episode. It took a while for the other characters to catch up to her.

[IsraelYabuki 446]

That would be Fluttershy

[Sonic Shimmer 4,132]

It was Rainbow Dash for quite a long time, with Pinkie right behind.

 

But Twilight eventually became my favourite when I realised how much I identified with her 

 

That said, I still adore Rainbow Dash and Pinkie Pie! 

[Clawdeen 14,108]

Rarity was my first favorite pony. She remains my favorite as well. Applejack is my 2nd favorite.

[Luminance 2,186]

It was Applejack at first but then I've realized how so many people were given pity to her. She's not the most popular or the most developed character but somehow I feel the need to back her up with good intentions and that she's the most realistic of all of the mane 6.

 

That's all changed now. She will only receive as much attention as the ones who further develops and built a goal for her own life but I didn't see that in the time I was rooting for AJ and that left me unsatisfied with her progression.

Edited September 13, 2016 by Melodic Twilight

[Chuckles4lyfe 441]

Rainbow Dash was my 1st and still is my favorite pony of the mane 6  . Without Dashie performing her Sonic Rainboom, the entire world would have been flipped upside down (see the Season 5 Finale for reference). Twilight is still a close 2nd, but Fluttershy has been climbing up the list very quickly with how she's been so far in Season 6. She used to be my least favorite character, but now I enjoy every moment whenever she is on screen. She probably has the best comedic timing of the mane 6. Plus all those smug faces that she makes in episodes like: Flutter Brutter, Dungeons and Discords, Viva Las Pegasus are just so adorable  .  

[Kings&Hooves14 616]

Fluttershy was probably my "first love," but that changed as I began to realize that--strangely, considering her element--she has a pretty severe cruel streak.

Don't get me wrong, I certainly don't hate her, but she has kind of started to freak me out; I feel as if she could go full psycho killer at any moment.   

It's always the quiet ones, ya know?