music Still Alive Or Want You Gone?

[FyreDash 3]

So Which one. btw if you dont know what im talking about

Still alive is the ending song for Portal 1

Want you gone is for Portal 2

Which One Would you choose?

Personally i would choose Still Alive,

the nostalgia factor and the lyrics are a little better for me

[Champion RD92 8,658]

Still Alive

[Luurilka 325]

Wait, r u asking which one is better?

[Kaborer 164]

"Still alive" is much better composed than "Want you gone", the lyrics are better and the voice is also better sounding. In my opinion at least.

[FyreDash 3]

Wait, r u asking which one is better?

 

Yea basically.

[Kyreth 194]

I'm going to go with still alive. Tough choice though, I love them both. But I think still alive was funnier.

[pizzaparty9 19]

i like still alive but i would half to say want you gone is better

[Guest]

I love them both, but I kind of like Want you Gone a tinsy tiny bit more. *shields face from angry glares*

[Mephala 2,633]

Still Alive. Maybe I thought it was funnier then.

*listens*

STILL ALIVE XD

[Killian Jones 2,655]

Both are good. But Still Alive was felt better somehow.

[LunaShy 168]

I <3 still alive

[Ron Jeremy 2,032]

Still Alive has a certain charm that Want You Gone doesn't. It's hard to describe, really. Probably has something to do with how Portal 2 tried too hard, story-wise.

 

We do what we must, because we can~

[Kapi 215]

Both are good, but I like "Want you Gone" more than "Still Alive."

 

And Wheatly still owes me the Pony Farm he promised me. Guess I'll never get that now.. *sigh*

[Arkane 270]

Want you gone for me.

 

But the turret orchestra topped them both.

[Blue Moon 6,341]

I prefer Still Alive. The lyrics are more charming to me, and I like the tune in Still Alive more than I like the tune in Want You Gone. Nothing wrong with Want You gone; it's a very good song; I just prefer Still Alive.

[Moonlight 7,288]

I'm going to be that small percentage that votes "Want You Gone".

 

The lyrics are funnier, it sounds better, and it's just a lot more fun to me, personally.

[Mutemutt 773]

Still Alive. Want You Gone isn't bad or anything but I think it's one of those situations where it's just funnier ( or funner) the first time around. They tried to recreate the magic and just didn't work as well for me  -_-.

[Sunny Fox 5,952]

I prefer "Want You Gone" to "Still Alive". The lyrics are so much more ironic, the melody is better, and the sound production is higher, being a later creation.

[Celtore 2,770]

I don't know... I like Want You Gone a bit more. I think it's a lot catchier and a lot more song like than Still Alive. It doesn't carry the same nostalgia or the same type of humour as the original, but I like it more as a song.

Edited September 1, 2013 by Celtore

[Broseph 215]

They're both equally great.
But I think I'll go with Still Alive.. Probably because I like how it keeps building up (i.e. With each verse and chorus, a new instrument is added and the song sounds bigger).. That and I prefer the sounds of real instruments over synthetic instruments which seemed prominent in Want You Gone..
But still, both are really good songs, I just prefer how Still Alive sounds.

Edited September 1, 2013 by Broseph

[Sparkle Speed 87]

Still alive hands down. You cant beet the classics with pop music. Pop is coolieo but classics are FREAKING AMAZING!!!

 

-Sparkle Speed

[HunterTSN 1,444]

Both of them are incredible songs. If I have to choose I will go with Still Alive, but Want You Gone is still one of my favorite songs.

[Scootalove 10,689]

I'm going with Want You Gone I still like Still Alive but, Want You Gone is my favorite song from the Portal game. They are both really great songs.

[Zygen 6,066]

Ok, this is like, freaking impossible.

 

I love both songs to much.

 

Like heck i love the portal series in general, and especially so the fact that both end themes have humorous lyrics.

 

However, as much as "Still Alive" is very classic and a bit nostalgic, I think i'm going to have to lean very slightly to "Want you gone", i dunno, both are good, but i just find "Want you gone" to be a bit catchier.

 

Both are great though, and i love both games a ton .(Seriously, i love games that don't take themselves very seriously at all, or really just humorous games in general. Maybe its because of how random i am lol.)